3 ms·
Great question. Don't have much time for an answer, but I think a lot depends on how critical the software is to the company in question. Another user of Apac
by davidw 17y ago
Great question. Don't have much time for an answer, but I think a lot depends on how critical the software is to the company in question. Another user of Apache? Probably don't need to do much, just put a "thanks" link somewhere on your site. Took some BSD licensed code, closed it up, added something to it, and based your business on it? Morally, I think you owe something, even if you don't, legally.
What really bugs me as an open source guy is when people don't even attempt to participate in the community in even minimal ways. I can understand if you don't want to hang out answering questions on the mailing list, but if you find a bug and don't even bother to tell me so that I can fix it (for free, for #####'s sake!), that's just lame.
But that's a really quick treatment of a very interesting question - I look forward to seeing other responses.
- mechanical_fish 17y ago* if you find a bug and don't even bother to tell me so that I can fix it (for free, for #####'s sake!), that's just lame.* You need to read Cialdini's Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Cialdini http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Cialdini That will get you in the mindset to understand what is going on here. People are shy about reporting bugs in your free software because they -- perhaps correctly -- sense that to ask you to fix a bug is to subtly demand a favor from you. And they don't want to demand favors from you. Perhaps because they got your work for free, and it feels like being a jerk to take someone's free work and then demand more. Or perhaps just because asking you to do a favor for them will make them feel socially obligated to reciprocate, but they don't know how that's going to work. They can't just give you money, because you aren't asking for it. What are you going to ask for? Are you going to ask for something they don't have -- like time -- or something they don't want to give you, like a signature on a petition that they don't agree with, or the license to some software that they really wanted to hang on to? Perhaps you will ask them to buy some Amway products, or some life insurance, or a timeshare, or an entire box of candy bars for your kid's fund drive. Don't think that this sort of thing doesn't happen. When people offer me free stuff as I walk down the street I usually decline. I've learned better. I believe it was Cialdini who described the classic Hari Krishna trick of starting conversations on the street by giving people tiny flowers. Once you've been given a tiny gift the part of your brain that calculates social debt starts ticking, whether you want it to or not, and you'll find yourself feeling guilty if you just walk away. A lot of terrible products have been sold this way. Indeed, even if you tell people over and over that providing a bug report is doing you a favor, they will still think of it as a demand on you. Because if I walk up to you and do you a favor I am creating a subtle expectation that you will reciprocate. This is why charging money for your software -- even a dollar -- creates a magical change in your customer relations. Suddenly customers understand the rules: You do things for them, they reciprocate with money, and it's all square! Suddenly customers will start calling you up and reporting bugs -- they paid for your bug-fixing efforts! They'll report a thousand bugs -- hey, look at the value they're getting for their dollar! Of course, the terrible flip side is that, once they've paid you a dollar and then cheerfully reported a thousand bugs, your own reciprocity calculator might start to ping, whether you want it to or not. You may begin to resent those bug reports -- the very ones that you are currently begging for -- because you were only paid a lousy dollar for the work of accepting them all. Watch it happen.
- davidw 17y agoDan Ariely comes to a similar conclusion in "Predictably Irrational": "“FREE!” has a striking effect on people, causing them to make irrational decisions." > This is why charging money for your software -- even a dollar -- creates a magical change in your customer relations. Sure, but that changes things in other ways too... we were talking about open source software and how to be a good citizen in that community.
- profquail 17y agoI wish I could upvote you 100 times for mentioning that book. Probably one of the most informative books I've ever read, and it's only ~200 pages. Seriously folks, get a copy and read it. It'll make a huge impact on your perspective of other people.