4 ms·
> I had found access to the remote server [...]. I was able to find the [...] Management Console and use a teachers [...] password [...] create a hidden admin u
by ajross 13y ago
> I had found access to the remote server [...]. I was able to find the [...] Management Console and use a teachers [...] password [...] create a hidden admin user [...]. Through this I could [...] control every PC in the school.
And this is why we can't have nice things. Admins at The Age (in this case) see someone trying to "report" a vulnerability and instantly jump to the conclusion that the user is someone like you, who has already compromised and exploited the system and at this point just wants to gloat on top of it all.
Surely there is a spectrum between white and black hat hacking. But this is over the line, sorry. Once you start trying to guess passwords and modifying state to add backdoors (seriously!?), you have to reasonably expect the rest of us to try to resist and suppress you, by law enforcement if necessary.
- cmiles74 13y agoI don't see the point in bringing the legal hammer down on a student. With security holes this large and gaping, it's the system administrator that needs to change the way they do things. For instance, monitor the creation of new admin accounts, monitor logged data for events that indicate a breach, enforce some level minimal password difficulty, etc. This sort of malfeasance seems like _exactly_ what the sysadmin at a school should be expecting. Someone who waltzes up to the login prompt and types the first thing that comes to mind. Personally, I don't think this or anything close should be made illegal. Who was hurt? What was the damage and the cost? Private data was likely at risk, and maybe there's a case to be made there, but I'm not entirely convinced that shouldn't be laid at the feet of the organization for shoddy security practices.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoI don't know if it is the times that have changed, or it's just that old stories were all romantic, but I get the feeling that nowdays IT staff has no sense of humour or understanding of the concept of having (creative) fun. > Once you start trying to guess passwords and modifying state to add backdoors (seriously!?), you have to reasonably expect the rest of us to try to resist and suppress you, by law enforcement if necessary. In this setting (a school) I'd reasonably expect the "rest of you" to play the game, not to swing the legal hammer. If your system is so easily compromised, you should feel professional shame and try to attone, not reach for law enforcement and general grown-up dullness. Especially given that this school, one would hope that everything there, including the computer infrastructure, should be a part of learning experience, as long as no one gets seriously hurt. BTW. in my high school, the school server and computer rooms were managed by students, not teachers or any hired staff. Everything worked well most of the time, and at the same time every generation of students was busy putting their backdoors everywhere, while searching and removing ones left by their predecessors. It was fun, and we learned a lot.