6 ms·
I don't know much about the particulars of BitCoin mechanics, but the general spirit of this story seems like a natural evolvement of any unregulated organizati
by pron 13y ago
I don't know much about the particulars of BitCoin mechanics, but the general spirit of this story seems like a natural evolvement of any unregulated organization. People who favor unregulated markets/societies dislike the concentration of power in the hands of a central authority, but the reality is that in any social system there will always be concentration of power in the hands of the few. I've read a hypothesis[1] that it was this dynamics that propelled the neolithic revolution (the transformation of humans from nomadic hunters-gatherers to settled farmers): most people suffered as consequence (hunger, disease, less leisure), but a few benefitted greatly.
The same thing happened in the American Gilded Age. In that period of unprecedented (and largely unregulated) growth, much of the US population became quickly enslaved by a few members of an elite group, later called the robber barons (Rockefeller, Frick, JP Morgan, Vanderbilt, Carnegie, Mellon et al.), and it took tremendous efforts by the American press and then by President Roosevelt (the first) to partially dismantle that semi-feudal structure and strengthen the central government, to free the populace from the stranglehold of the robber barons.
While a central power can be abusive, it is almost always better than feudal oligarchy, at least if it is governed more-or-less democratically.
So while BitCoin is an algorithm intended to avoid a single organizing entity, it is no replacement for a social pact, enforced politically by some fair means. Perhaps a better algorithm could somehow prevent any sort of concentrated power, but I doubt it. The desire for power (even with the best of intentions) is so essential to humans, that it probably cannot be circumvented by technology alone.
[1]: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/12/19/111219fa_fact_batuman?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2011/12/19/111219fa_fact_...
- darkFunction 13y agoProof-of-stake attempts better enforcement of decentralisation, but I think the various implementations are pretty immature.
- unlimited_power 13y agoI encourage people to look at the paper Transactions as Proof-of-Stake & The End of Mining[0] defining a form of the idea. BitShares[1] (due out in Q2 2014) will implement this. [0] https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=1138.0 https://bitsharestalk.org/index.php?topic=1138.0 [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BV55IrZi7g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5BV55IrZi7g
- masklinn 13y ago> in any social system there will always be concentration of power in the hands of the few By default, subsystems can be put in place to diffuse power back into the realm (or at least attempt to)
- theboywho 13y ago> but the reality is that in any social system there will always be concentration of power in the hands of the few. Actually in this particular case, it's not in the hands of the few, it's in the hands of the majority.
- masklinn 13y agoNo, it's in the hand of the pool operator not in the hand of the pool's miners.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoWatch how fast the miners leave the operator if they disagree with his actions. It's the hands of the miners.
- masklinn 13y ago> Watch how fast the miners leave the operator if they disagree with his actions. 1. They'd have to be aware of the actions of an anonymous pool owner 2. The amount of damage the pool owner can do before people even have the time to start leaving is staggering > It's the hands of the miners. You're in denial.
- waterlesscloud 13y agoThe fact remains that the "power" of the pool operator depends on the miners, who can change pools in a matter of minutes. The instant it's known they're abusing their power, it starts to vanish. It's not a long, drawn-out process. It literally starts within minutes.
- monochr 13y agoAnd control of the block chain can be taken over in minutes too. As far as I am aware the network updates itself every 10 minutes. So unless the operator never has a period of more than 10 minutes of 51% control or more the network is vulnerable.
- huxley 13y agoYou might be interested in reading about The Iron Law of Oligarchy (an influential "social law" that was proposed in 1911 by Robert Michels) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_oligarchy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iron_law_of_oligarchy It is a pretty dismal assessment of the likelihood that a democratic institution can avoid becoming oligarchic (spoiler: Michels believed it was inevitably impossible as the institution grew in size and complexity, years later he abandoned his anarchist beliefs and became a fascist in Italy) There are a few historical counter-examples to the Iron Law of Oligarchy, but I don't follow the details of Bitcoin closely enough to know whether it is resistant to the factors Robert Michels described.
- pron 13y agoThank you for that! I guess it's sort of a reversed second law of thermodynamics.
- simbyotic 13y ago"In that period of unprecedented (and largely unregulated) growth, much of the US population became quickly enslaved by a few members of an elite group, later called the robber barons (Rockefeller, Frick, JP Morgan, Vanderbilt, Carnegie, Mellon et al.)" You ought to rethink what you define as "enslavement". As far as I am aware, neither Rockefeller, nor JP Morgan, nor Carnegie "enslaved" the US population when they helped transform the by then agrarian nation into the industrial and economic powerhouse it later became. They didn't use force, as far as I am aware, in their dealings and the wealth of their achievements certainly wasn't created at the expense of those who didn't.
- monochr 13y ago>They didn't use force, as far as I am aware Then you're not very aware. During the Gilded Age there were hundreds of strikes a large minority of which ended with the murder of the organizers and arrest of the leadership, an incomplete list thanks to wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_strikes#1850.E2.80.931899 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_strikes#1850.E2.80.9318...
- cwp 13y agoDid the robber barons kidnap people from Africa, ship them across the sea in chains and force them to work by whipping them if they didn't? No. Still, have you ever heard the song "Sixteen Tons?"[1] You might recognize the lines "another day older and deeper in debt" and "I owe my soul to the company store." It's about the life of a coal miner in Kentucky. Those lines refer to a system where the company paid its workers in vouchers that they could use to buy food and clothing from the company store. Prices at the company store were higher than the workers could afford on the wages they received, but since they didn't get cash they didn't have the option to buy elsewhere. So they'd buy on credit and gradually build up a debt to the company that they had no way to pay off. Is that slavery? Perhaps not technically, since the workers weren't owned by the company and couldn't be sold. But they didn't have many choices, either. They were basically stuck doing a fixed amount of work each day in exchange for food and lodging. Sounds an awful lot like slavery in practice. [1] Obligator wikipedia link - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteen_Tons https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sixteen_Tons
- notdrunkatall 13y ago...except you're wrong. Bitcoin participants have developed a solution to the 51% problem, without any regulation, without any government stepping in and telling anyone to do anything. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Getblocktemplate https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Getblocktemplate Your post is a poorly argued attempt to inject politics into a technical discussion. It reads like the top comment at /r/politics, not HN.
- pron 13y agoThe invention of a new currency is a highly political act; claiming it isn't is a political statement in itself. The discussion of any disruptive technology should quickly focus on politics and ethics, or risk being abused. You can't both claim to invent technology that seriously affects society, and at the same time dismiss talk of politics as irrelevant. A technology can either be irrelevant or be political (if you ever wish to understand technology, I suggest you read some of the many discussions of the politics of the washing machine; or the fork). What I find most fascinating about some of the less ideological BTC discussions is the belief that a neutral technology (a cryptographic algorithm) can replace social contracts. I'm not claiming it necessarily can't, I'm just saying that this belief shows not only disdain for government, but an Aspergerish rejection of social structures. It's like saying, I don't want to put people in charge because I don't trust them, and I don't want even to talk to others in order to resolve disagreement; instead, I choose to take all decision-making agency out the hands of humans and place it in the hands of an algorithm that can provably never be swayed, because that is the only thing I can trust. Regardless, there is nothing technical about a story of a small group attaining concentrated power over a decentralized currency.
- celticninja 13y agoBitcoin is more of a technology than a currency, as such it does not have to have been a political act to create it.
- mattzito 13y agoThat's an interesting variant on, "The personal is political" - "The technical isn't political". Some technologies are by their nature effectively neutral - the knife can be used to cut food, shave your face, kill your enemy. In a more recent example, the microprocessor is a neutral technology. But many technologies are inherently political - the Pill, for example, or ICBMs. I would argue that Bitcoin may be more of a technology than a currency, but it is an inherently political technology, designed as it is to provide an abstract, somewhat anonymized general ledger technology.
- true_religion 13y agoWait.... It has been a while since I studied this era, but my understanding is that Rockefeller, Frick, JP Morgan, Vanderbilt, Carnegie, Mellon et al. were the "good guys" like in the instance of Carnegie steel which gave back tremendously to the community. The named figures of this period, who still have visible fortunes today, were generally better than the grand morass that were known as the robber barons.
- pron 13y agoSome of them were great philanthropists who generously donated to causes of their choosing some of the fortune they had amassed by exploiting and disenfranchising vast populations. Those I named were chief among the robber barons, and some of their descendants, perhaps most notably the Rockefellers, tried to distance themselves from or atone for the means by which their forefathers had come by their wealth. This cartoon[1] shows "infant" Roosevelt battling the Rockefeller and JP Morgan "serpents". No, they weren't the good guys by any means, despite their philanthropic deeds. They most certainly industrialized the US, but so did Stalin in the USSR (though most would agree that the American robber barons were better than Stalin :)). [1]: http://newsjournalist.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/the-infant-hercules-political-cartoon.jpg http://newsjournalist.files.wordpress.com/2010/01/the-infant...
- dragontamer 13y agoA little bit of both. No one can deny the fact that Carnegie created the Steel Emmpire, etc. etc. that provided a baseline for American Manufacturing through the middle of the 1900s. Furthermore, many of these "Barons" became philanthropists and gave away huge portions of their fortune. However, they also had no morals with regards to child labor, unions, worker rights, and so forth.