3 ms·
Clearly, the government department is wholly responsible for putting up a rubbish website, but from another article on the story, "He first contacted PTV by ema
by onion2k 13y ago
Clearly, the government department is wholly responsible for putting up a rubbish website, but from another article on the story, "He first contacted PTV by email on Boxing Day..". I wonder if the "white-hat hacker" didn't time his notification quite intentionally knowing there was a much lower probability of action being taken promptly. If they'd just patched the security hole he wouldn't get any exposure. It makes me wonder if there's more to this story than we're hearing - that he actually found the security flaw much earlier and sat on it for a while for example. Or that he downloaded all the available information first.
As ever, a couple of short articles may not be giving us the big picture.
- Fuxy 13y agoBy that logic why would he even bother reporting it and have security experts poking around the logs and potentially find traces of his download. Personally i would have sold it to the highest bidder. Being "white hat" gets you in trouble more often than not. Il stick to "gray hat" thank you very much. If i ever choose to disclose any vulnerability to the owners i will not reveal my identity and after arbitrary amount of time say... (1 month) if it's still present sell it to the highest bidder let them deal with the consequences. You have to be strict when teaching people and this is no different. If you let them set the rules they could choose and unreasonable length of time like 1 year before they allow you to disclose anything. You are the one in the position of power never let them take that away from you. By revealing you identity you give away all your power. If you're not a threat people don't take you seriously.
- mike-cardwell 13y agoYour statement: Being "white hat" gets you in trouble more often than not. Is beyond absurd.
- andyhmltn 13y agoI would argue that your reply is the one that's absurd. Why is the quote you mentioned unreasonable?
- windexh8er 13y agoMaybe more pointedly - white hat and in high school, OR independent and not well known, OR when dealing with any sort of organization affiliated with government, banking, telecommunications or retail. I think that covers 80% of this type of story cropping up quarterly in mainstream media.
- mike-cardwell 13y agoBecause "Being white hat gets you in trouble more often than not." is so obviously untrue to anybody with even the vaguest relation to the industry. It implies that more than 50% of the time, when you disclose a vulnerability responsibly you get in trouble. When it's more likely much much less than 0.1% of the time. People getting in trouble for reporting vulnerabilities is highly rare. Show me 100 cases of it, and I'll still tell you it's rare.
- Fuxy 13y agoMost of the industry wouldn't characterize themselves as "white hat" just ask them and they will say their more "gray hat" then white hat. At least in private anyway if you ask them in public their force to keep up appearances. Now we can argue about the percentages all day but you have to agree being "gray hat" and keeping the power on your side by not exposing your identity is the safer way to go about it unless you want bragging rights which is whole other level of psychology. I'm not after the attention I'd rather be the guy who nobody notices.
- aaronem 13y ago> Being "white hat" gets you in trouble more often than not. Granted. I've lost clients this way, despite having been actually invited to do work on their systems; such experience has taught me that the political concerns around unsolicited vulnerability reporting dwarf the technical considerations involved, and that trying to navigate such minefields is worthwhile only when the status quo is utterly untenable. > Personally i would have sold it to the highest bidder. Well, that's a wholly different consideration, isn't it? Saying nothing is one thing. Gravely violating the ethics of your profession, and possibly criminal law as well, is quite another.
- pavel_lishin 13y ago> if it's still present sell it to the highest bidder let them deal with the consequences. Them, and the innocent victims of this breach - the people who just wanted to buy a bus pass. Why not disclose anonymously and publicly, instead of selling the data off?
- windexh8er 13y agoI'm not sure timing matters, ever. Why should it? Large organizations will pay millions of dollars for canned 'assessments' that create far more noise and operational problems than reports like this - yet the knee here reaction to responsible disclosure is "well you didn't send it to us on the third Sunday of the month after a blue moon". Get a clue. If someone responsibly discloses then suck it up, fix it and when you don't expect to hit the front page of the local news. That's how reality works today, and as stated in the article, if this young researcher has found it it's either already known or the sands of time were close to running out on malicious use case. I believe that if an organization wants to incriminate responsible disclosure then they have to have a public ToS stating any disclosure is subject to just that. Then they will dissuade any free help in a public fashion and left to their own devices. In that case there should be non-retaliation protection available via the state to anonymously submit without fear of being penalized. If there was a big hole in the side of a bank and it was illegal to talk about it do you just accept it and move on? Do you continue to bank there? There's inherent risk with providing Internet based services. Deal with it instead of being ignorant about it.
- skeletonjelly 13y agoI agree it was a bad day to email PTV, but in another article I read on it he was simply trying to find out some info on Myki (the current travel card). Unfortunately I can't find it though. Assumptions are the mother of all fuckups.