3 ms·
I keep hearing this meme of "inflation is always great, deflation is always bad" with nothing to support it but the same tired "inflation makes you spend money"
by wyager 13y ago
I keep hearing this meme of "inflation is always great, deflation is always bad" with nothing to support it but the same tired "inflation makes you spend money" argument.
Inflation encourages spending money but discourages earning it.
Deflation encourages earning money but discourages spending it.
People need to eat, so in the end these competing interests will always balance out, whether your currency is inflationary or deflationary.
- msandford 13y agoWhat a concise way of stating the tradeoffs, and in a fairly value-neutral way to boot!
- ewoodrich 13y agoSure, but we have a economy that's extremely reliant on consumer spending, in fact it's about 70% of GDP these days [1]. Major deflation of the USD and the resulting decrease in spending would be devastating to the national economy [2]. Moderate inflation, however, serves to stimulate economic growth (while a similar degree of deflation would have a proportionally negative effect on growth). Is this an ideal economic system? Maybe not, who knows. It's what we have though. And it is a direct consequence of an economy driven by growth, and one that encourages liberal individual consumption. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_economy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumer_economy [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1837 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1837
- wyager 13y ago>Sure, but we have a economy that's extremely reliant on consumer spending, in fact it's about 70% of GDP these days What a meaningless statement in this context. "Consumer spending" refers to private sector spending. This is as opposed to, for example, Government spending, which might also fluctuate with changes in monetary policy. What percentage of the GDP is estimated to come from consumer spending has little bearing on the effect changes in inflation rate might have on the economy. You are trying to oversimplify a vastly complex system. If what you are implying (that there is a causal positive relationship between inflation and production) were true, it would be economically advantageous to adopt zimbabwe-style inflation. >...would be devastating to the national economy Please actually read the article you linked. "Speculative lending practices in western states, a sharp decline in cotton prices, a collapsing land bubble, international specie flows, and restrictive lending policies in Great Britain were all to blame." Deflation was a result of this panic, not the cause of it.
- dllthomas 13y ago"If what you are implying (that there is a causal positive relationship between inflation and production) were true, it would be economically advantageous to adopt zimbabwe-style inflation." "A little is good, a lot is bad" is in no way an inconsistent position - it's true about most things.
- DennisP 13y agoConsumer spending is extremely reliant on consumer earning. Unless you rely instead on borrowing, which doesn't tend to end well.
- legutierr 13y agoTo dismiss concerns over deflation as a "tired argument" is to ignore a good amount of serious academic research (which has been conducted over nearly a century) about the role that deflation has to play in exacerbating (and possibly triggering) economic depressions. Although the point is contested, many economists believe that the competing interests you describe will not balance out. Some Wikipedia links: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Deflationary_spiral http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deflation#Deflationary_spiral http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_deflation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debt_deflation
- wyager 13y ago> is to ignore a good amount of serious academic research Economics is perhaps second only to psychology in the amount of internal inconsistency it experiences as an allegedly somewhat scientific field. >(which has been conducted over nearly a century) Is this supposed to convince me? Half of contemporary economic theory gets thrown out the window every few decades. >Although the point is contested No shit. Equally legitimate disciplines of economics reach completely different conclusions on the matter, which doesn't say much for the legitimacy of overarching economic theory in general. Just as a very basic overview, here's some of what Wikipedia has to say about it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price/wage_spiral http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price/wage_spiral http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stagflation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stagflation
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]