5 ms·
Why Charles Stross Doesn’t Know a Thing about Bitcoin
- dllthomas 13y agoThe point about efficiency increasing seems wrong. Yes, efficiency of hashing has increased, but it's an arms race. When Visa buys more efficient computers, we use less electricity to accomplish a goal. When I buy a better ASIC I still pour as much juice into it as I can afford to churn out hashes - and if the network is producing too many hashes they up the difficulty. As efficiency increases, with bitcoin we keep pouring the same amount of electricity into mining, but we're also pouring resources into building single-purpose chips that will be useless when bitcoin migrates to a different hashing algorithm.
- analog31 13y agoDoes anybody know how much energy, i.e., Joules or whatever per Bitcoin earned through mining?
- dllthomas 13y agoNot much more than 1 bitcoin's worth...
- analog31 13y agoBut possibly less, if there's some sort of arbitrage going on. Also, the energy requirement can't fluctuate as much as the price of bitcoins does. Note I'm not trying to be argumentative. I'm actually genuinely curious. Even just order of magnitude. Folks in the media talk about the energy cost, but never with any attempt to quantify it.
- maxerickson 13y agoIt looks like the best ASICs are at around 1.5 gigahash / joule. Certainly less than 2. So 13 million gigahash per second translates into at least 6.5 megawatts. But 2 is a pretty aggressive figure, it's probably easily above 10 megawatts.
- dllthomas 13y agoFor sure. It can especially be less due to short term capital constraints. If power gets cheaper, people want to produce more but it takes time to make more ASICs. To give a real thorough answer, though, takes more numbers and possibly more expertise than I have.
- bushido 13y agoI have been curious about this too. Unfortunately though, my guess is that it is very very tough to estimate due to the sheer variety of hardware that is being used. I am sure that a large number of people are still mining with GPUs which consume more power/mhash than ASICs. I came across someone last week who was mining with a CPU, I am confident he's not the only one.
- cma 13y agoJust make sure to only mine during a polar vortex. If only there were a bitcoin heatpump.
- salient 13y ago> but we're also pouring resources into building single-purpose chips that will be useless when bitcoin migrates to a different hashing algorithm. I don't get this argument. Why do they have to be used for something else after "you're done with them"? You've made your profit with them (since if you aren't going to make a profit with them, you aren't going to buy them in the first place), so what else would you use them for? The ASIC's serve a purpose: mining Bitcoin and maintaining the Bitcoin network. I don't get why there has to be "something else" they need to be useful for. Bitcoin is the point.
- ChristianMarks 13y agoThere is the opportunity cost and the social cost. And there is no canonical, singular "point" about mining that one could refer to that would obviate those questions. But maybe the social cost is low, e.g., many miners and Bitcoin speculators would otherwise have been unemployed, and would have contributed at least as much carbon to the Earth's carbon budget had they done something else.
- lukifer 13y agoI see no reason to anticipate Bitcoin moving to a new hashing algo, given the investment in existing hardware, and that the hardware owners are the ones who vote with their gigahashes on how the network functions. However, even if it were to change, there are several altcoins that use the same hashing algorithm (PeerCoin being the biggest), and/or someone will invent a new blockchain service to take advantage of the existing hardware. While I think there is great merit to ASIC-resistant hashing algorithms of ProtoShares/PrimeCoin/etc, that ASICs would ever become useless seems highly unlikely.
- dllthomas 13y agoAttacks against cryptographic algorithms only get better. If SHA256 is weakened sufficiently, bitcoin (and altcoins that use SHA256) will need to move. Which it can, but that makes existing ASICs worthless.
- apw 13y agoIts worth nothing that as this arms race proceeds, the historical record of Bitcoin transactions becomes harder to undo, and 51% attacks become too costly for even some nation-states.
- DennisP 13y agoThe total cost of mining a block will approximate the block reward plus transaction fees. To see how much of that cost is electricity, compare the cost of the hardware to the electricity it uses. For example, on Amazon right now I see a Bitmain AntMiner U1 USB miner. It costs $70 and they claim it uses 2 watts and is a recent chip. Let's say it has a lifetime of three years. Three years of two watts is 26 kWh, which will cost about $2.60, which means that for this chip, the electricity is only 4% of the total mining cost. Of course the rest of the computer uses power, I'm assuming that either the computer is being used for something else as well, or a large operation has a special chassis holding lots of these chips and not wasting power on much else. Anyone who's not so efficient won't be able to compete. The fact that bitcoin's mining cost is becoming dominated by hardware rather than energy is a very positive development, in my opinion.
- wmf 13y agoRight now the ASIC vendors seem to be capital-constrained and are not producing enough ASICs to meet demand. At equilibrium we should expect that the cost of mining will equal the rate of BTC generation and a significant fraction of the cost of mining will be power.
- DennisP 13y agoProbably. On the other hand if chips get as optimized as they can get aside from further advance of Moore's Law, and they're produced in mass quantities, maybe people will start using them as heating elements in home water heaters. A lot of the emerging currencies are focusing on memory-constrained hashing algorithms. RAM has price/energy ratios similar to what I mentioned for ASICs, and is already in mass production and about as optimized as major industry is able to make it.
- analog31 13y agoJust a ballpark, how many bitcoins would be earned by such a machine per unit time?
- maxerickson 13y ago
- kordless 13y agoI'm really pleased to see someone else hitting on the value of the blockchain data. One of the reasons I think Bitcoin itself will become more valuable over time is the amount of big data being added to the system via the transactions taking place. For the first time in the World's history, we actually have a completely transparent system financial system we can observe and use to make decisions. Very exciting stuff. I'm glad to be part of it.
- _delirium 13y agoI also think that aspect is interesting, but I wonder if it will really reveal as much interesting information as one hopes. If everyone used a single wallet (or small number of wallets) and made only "real" transactions, it'd be a transparent (if pseudonymous) data set about how money is flowing around in the Bitcoin universe. And that would actually give hard data for understanding an economy, of the sort that one has to estimate very imperfectly in other currencies. But it's pretty easy to purposely foul the data if you want, especially given the ease-of-use of mixers. I would guess if Bitcoin usage gets more important, obfuscating schemes will only get more sophisticated and widespread.
- drakaal 13y agoThe value? No. The more data you have about where money flows the less privacy we have and the more control you give law enforcement. Think about all the Friend of Friend wire taps. Suddenly the $20 bill you bought starbucks with gets given as change to a drug dealer and you are on a known associate list. You also have all sorts of issues where if 50% of the world's transactions were done in BTC the blockchain data would be too large for 90+% of nodes to store.
- DennisP 13y agoLuckily there are solutions to both. For example, at least two currencies are coming out using zero-knowledge proofs to break the links between transactions, and the "finite blockchain" idea would reduce the long-term blockchain storage to a constant few bytes per block, regardless of transactions per block.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- akkartik 13y agoI was mystified about how infinite divisibility addresses the deflation argument. Then I found the author make this priceless statement in the comments: "I agree with folks that I basically dodged the argument about deflation. I did it deliberately. Talking about deflation is like talking about God. Basically as soon as you mention the word all dialogue stops. People already have an idea in their head about whether it is good or bad and nobody listens any more. I admit I am no economic expert." http://bitcoinmagazine.com/9359/charles-stross-doesnt-know-thing-bitcoin/#comment-1193079788 http://bitcoinmagazine.com/9359/charles-stross-doesnt-know-t... That pretty much answers the question of whether he's a libertarian. At this point does anybody besides hard libertarians like the mises institute think deflation can be a good thing?
- javert 13y agoFirst, I agree that libertarians are intellectually embarassing, and I am sad to see them arguing poorly for so many things I agree with. Second, addressing deflation. From the point of view of production: deflation would get priced into the value of the currency so that it wouldn't at all be clear that holding onto deflationary currency will net you more than actually investing it in productive activity. From the point of view of consumption: Arguing that people will hold onto currency to eek out a little more value is like arguing that people in an inflationary economy will withohold selling goods and services to eek out a little more value. It just doesn't happen that way. In an inflationary society, consumption can't and won't be deferred indefinitely (the rich would rather have their new boat now and the poor don't have an option to wait and buy food later). Same goes for production in an inflationary society.
- mwsherman 13y agoYes, these are good insights. If consumers hoard currency in a deflationary economy, we should expect producers to hoard in an inflationary one. (I’d also argue that there is nothing special about “zero”, that slight inflation or deflation are not different in kind.) Further, the tech industry fits every definition of deflationary – your dollars will buy more next year, and consumers hold expectations of same. But it has grown in wages, revenues, consumer benefit, persistently.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- geuis 13y agoI really love this article. The author puts so many solid points forward. I would like to offer a possibility about Stross. Hasn't anyone considered that he's simply trolling? I've read all of his books and even met him once in SF. It seems much more likely to me that he is playing a game here and his recent comments do not reflect his actual thoughts.
- chasing 13y ago"Being a sci-fi author is about being open to possibilities. When a writer loses that ability to see what might be, maybe it’s time for him to step aside and make way for a new generation of authors who still can." What an insulting way to conclude an article. "If you lack the vision to agree with me about Bitcoin, maybe you're old and terrible at your job."
- mccr8 13y agoIt should be noted that Charles Stross wrote a book, Neptune's Brood, where a bitcoin-like currency is used to finance interstellar colonization, so a lack of vision is not really a problem.
- polarix 13y agoI suspect Stross may have been trolling, just to try to ward off the existential risk that bitcoin and autonomous economic entities edge us closer to. Either that or he's holding btc himself and figures that fomenting debate will be good for the value levitation.
- rxp 13y ago"Slow money" in Neptune's Brood is a digital currency, and is confusingly referred to as a "bitcoin" a few times, but it's actually a really fascinating idea that's very different from BTC. The gist of it, if I remember it right, is that all transactions are authenticated by an interstellar 2-phase commit handshake. The distances involved keep the value of the currency stable, because transactions can take decades to process, and the direction of the signal is actually used as a form of authentication, to guard against (literal) MITM attacks. The goal of slow money was to have a currency that was stable enough to finance multi-century interstellar colonization projects.
- wyager 13y agoIndeed, that was some unnecessary ad hominem. However, it shouldn't detract from the blog post's other points, some of which were well-reasoned. As we watch out for fallacies, we need to be careful not to invoke the fallacy fallacy :)
- wyager 13y agoThe "wasting energy" argument is idiotic. The amount of energy "wasted" by the Bitcoin network will always be approximately the amount of energy that can be bought with the Bitcoins mined in a given period. If the cost of energy is higher than the value of the Bitcoins the miners earn, miners will stop mining. Some miners don't care about cost (people who get free electricity) but they are not a significant factor. Miners also have to cover the cost of their hardware, so they want to leave a significant margin for profit. The cost of power for the Bitcoin network is very small compared to worldwide power usage.
- bagels 13y agoThe unstated and assumption here is that the recipient of the bitcoins is the same as the person who bears the cost of mining them. Stealing computing resources is one way for this assumption to be violated. I don't know though, that this amount of theft is significant compared to the bulk of resources spent on bitcoin. Bitcoin mining, from my cursory research however, doesn't really consume much electricity compared to the aggregate of all usage across the world, as you've stated.
- msandford 13y agoIf you could let me know where I can get illicit access to ASIC miners I'm all ears. From what I can tell those fucking things are guarded by all who own them in a severe way. EDIT: I'm not actually interested in stealing time on people's ASICs to mine bitcoin. I just think it's effectively impossible to do so. But I'm genuinely curious to know if there's a plausible attack vector.
- wyager 13y agoNo one steals computing resources to mine Bitcoins. Bitcoin ASICs made Bitcoin botnets completely unprofitable. On the other hand, a small number of miners (none of the big mining groups) steal (if you want to call it that) electricity from, say, dorm rooms or apartment buildings. However, I doubt these people contribute even a percent of the network's total hashing power.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoproof of work is inherently wasteful in a way that other systems are not. Exactly how wasteful they are is yet to be determined. This depends on how much value a successful attack on the blockchain could be to an attacker. The greater the value, the greater the cost of the proof-of-work system needed to prevent it.
- NateDad 13y agoWhat's funny is that this article pretty much exactly mirrors my comment on the Stross article: http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/12/why-i-want-bitcoin-to-die-in-a.html#comment-1837445 http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2013/12/why-i-wa...
- DennisP 13y agoThe argument about deflation is moot, since Bitcoin isn't the only digital currency. At this point there's a website that lets you create your own with a few clicks. Rather than a single deflationary currency, what we have is a lot of privately-issued competing currencies. Hayek advocated a system like this, arguing that it would result in stable prices and economies without need of a central bank.