4 ms·
Ask HN: Would a "truth" search engine be viable commercially?
A "truth" search engine would be one that only returns web pages containing accurate information.
For example, when searching for the age of the earth, only web pages indicating an accurate age would be returned.
Would such a search engine be viable commercially?
Sometimes the truth can be unpleasant.
- alex_c 17y agoWhose truth would it return?
- amichail 17y agoAs a start, it would include all well-established scientific truths such as evolution. It would also include recent history where there is little doubt about what happened. It would not include any web pages that present the other side of the debate. It would exclude all conspiracy theories.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoPlaying Devil's Advocate, (and for the record I believe in evolution) "Evolution" is a big, broad weasel word. If you mean species variation due to natural selection pressures? Sure. Intra-species changes? Okay sorta, although such things are really hard to observe. The origin of life, the universe, and everything? Probably not. At least not in such broad and vague terms. Evolution is more of a general idea of how things work which is then honed and applied specifically in different circumstances. It's not truth in the sense that Newton's Laws are truth. The broad term is much too vague to be included in a truth engine, in my opinion. It's not that it's false -- I believe the correct phrase is that it's not even false. And you would understand this if you weren't part of the evil cabal that lives in my bathroom sink! Ok. Sorry about that last part.
- amichail 17y agoThe search engine would return only those aspects of evolution that are known to be almost certainly true. See for example this video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUxLR9hdorI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUxLR9hdorI Newton's laws are not truth but merely an approximation that suffices in most cases.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoThat Newton's Laws are not "truth" is exactly my point. I kind of set you up for that one, sorry. Programmers and technicians deal in booleans -- yes or no answers. I know a couple of times I've heard people around here get frustrated when we start talking about the meanings of words. They just want simple declarative statements: evolution is true, detractors are wrong. Global Warming is true, detractors are wrong. etc. Analysts, or people who have to translate from human languages to programming on a regular basis, understand that truth is such a slippery concept as to be almost meaningless. I can have three people in a room and have them discuss what a program is going to do until everybody is happy, and then still there are misunderstandings. Language is just too slippery for universal truth operations. Or put another way, save universal truth for the philosophers.
- aberman 17y agoIt would be WAY to arbitrary, and the harder you tried to make it work, the more it would look like what we have today. Ultimately, a human (or multiple humans) would have to decide what was true, and what was false. I would almost be amused to see somebody ATTEMPT to do this job.
- alex_c 17y agoHow do you define "well-established"? What about well-established scientific THEORIES (i'm not sure what is the definition of a scientific truth) that turn out to be false or inaccurate after decades of being well-established? What if such a well-established theory is in the process of being disproven or replaced with a better theory - which happens to be "the other side of the debate" today?
- amichail 17y agoIf a theory turns out to be false/inaccurate, it would no longer be included. If a theory is not the truth but is good enough in practical cases, such as Newton's Laws, then that's fine.
- alex_c 17y agoBut how do you decide that a theory has turned out to be false? Once a certain percentage of qualified scientists agree? What percentage? And how do you define a qualified scientist? Think of all the FUD around climate change research. Do YOU know exactly which studies are valid and which ones aren't? Do you just hire climatologists to tell you? WHICH ones do you hire? How do you define "good enough in practical cases"? I could keep going like this. I'm not even worrying about commercial viability, I'll make the assertion that what you're proposing to build is impossible to build. My reasoning is that you're trying to fit things without a universally accepted definition - "truth" or "scientifically accepted" - into an absolute, binary system - "include" or "exclude". That is impossible to do correctly or completely. At best, you either end up with something fairly arbitrary, or you end up with a system which only includes the "facts" accepted by everyone, and excludes anything controversial. This ranges somewhere between useless and downright harmful, in my opinion (if this system is accepted as "truth", then new ideas have that much more of an uphill battle to be accepted).
- amichail 17y agoIt would include controversial topics where there is nonetheless scientific consensus that one side is correct.
- eli 17y agoSo humans have to review each page (and periodically re-review them)? No, that doesn't sound commercially viable at all.
- amichail 17y agoSuppose it were possible to construct such a search engine. Would many people avoid it because it doesn't support certain belief(s)?
- eli 17y agoHonestly? I think I can figure out which pages to trust on my own. But if you somehow came up with a way to show results that look like Google minus the crap, I'd use it. That's a big "if" though.
- amichail 17y agoPerhaps you would, but a huge number of people are being misled by nonsense all the time.
- eli 17y agoI don't think limiting them to a pre-approved subset of the web is a good idea (though that hasn't stopped Hasidic Jews, Mormons, or the Chinese government from trying similar plans) If anything, I think the opposite approach would work better. Expose people to all viewpoints including ones that disagree with their world view. To paraphrase Justice Brandeis, the best answer to bad speech is more speech.
- gojomo 17y agoMaybe a knowledge base that helps clearly lay out all the competing factional 'truths' would be better? See for example the 'UberFact' proposal: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2007/08/uberfact-ultimate-social-verifier.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2007/08/uberfac...