3 ms·
Joseph Needham did gather a lot of interesting source material from ancient Chinese literature on developments in science and technology in China. I studied Chi
by tokenadult 17y ago
Joseph Needham did gather a lot of interesting source material from ancient Chinese literature on developments in science and technology in China. I studied Chinese and sinology as his lengthy book series was published, and have read many hundreds of pages of his books. The general view of the historians of China whom I know best is that Needham did a fair amount of axe-grinding with his primary sources to prove ideological points and bolster his theory of history that other historical sources would not support. The primary historical literature in Chinese (literary Chinese) is VAST--the usual statement is that ancient Chinese literature outnumbers all other ancient literature from all other world cultures combined in word count by a considerable margin.
What I find most disappointing in Needham's work is his too Marxist explanation for what historians of technology think is what is most remarkable about the historical comparison between China and the West. Until the late Western middle ages, China was plainly ahead of the West in technology, and arguably very much ahead in science. Historians of technology refer to the West in those days as having "precocious technology" that couldn't be explained at all by Western science of that day. But as the Western middle ages gave way to the Renaissance, there was an explosive growth of science in the West, and ever since the West has been ahead of China in both science and technology, for reasons that I don't think Needham explains adequately. And of course the development of political freedom in the West in the same period has very much been world-leading all that while.
- jacquesm 17y agoThe west is still ahead of China in both Science and Technology, but they're moving fast and we're slowing down. I would not be surprised if in another four or five decades the situation is going to be reversed. China has it's problems, but it has one thing that the west does not have, which is the power to make very bold decisions and to realize them. No such thing as turf wars between parties or coalition building to dilute any plans.
- aswanson 17y agoBut what if the bold decisions are idiotic and destructive? Turf wars and parties seem to be what gave Europe its advantage, as the grandparent states the rise of freedom was concurrent with the rise in technology. So perhaps more distributed competitive decision making results in better outcomes, and the reason you stated will be precisely the reason China will not achieve its potential. [EDIT: Corrected incongruent verb tenses in last sentence.]
- jacquesm 17y agoThere is a 'stereotypical' China, the communist country which just like Russia is soon going to implode and there is the real China, a very large country with a set of unique challenges and a very large amount of energy to try to overcome those challenges. Modern China is not to be compared with the country that it was 30 (or even 20) years ago, it is evolving rapidly and it has a very good shot at becoming the dominant power in the next couple of decades. It is by no means a certainty, but while western politics are centered around special interest groups and their lobbyists China is working very hard at becoming if not top dog then at least an equal. A friend of mine has just emigrated to China and the stories he tells me about life there and the level of economic and social change in the last 10 years alone are almost incredible. If they can keep that up they will be very powerful indeed.
- tokenadult 17y agowestern politics are centered around special interest groups Currently internal politics in China is centered around a much smaller segment of the country's population. The masses and their concerns are largely ignored. I don't think that is good for the future of China, as the future is with the masses.
- gjm11 17y ago"If there is hope, it lies with the proles." -- Winston Smith, in George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four
- scott_s 17y agoThat's similar to the argument Jared Diamond makes in his book Guns, Germs and Steel. In order to explain the obvious problem - China was clearly ahead of western Europe in terms of technology and science - he appeals to the political structure. China was politically unified around 300 AD, while western Europe was only recently politically unified (and not in the same sense as China was). Political unification has advantages, but it also gives you less people making decisions, with fewer competitors. So decisions to not pursue technology and science were magnified and unchallenged. In western Europe, if you didn't do something, your neighbors would. I felt this was a fair assessment. But I also though that, considering the path China is on now, western Europe being so dominant in the world might become a historical blip.
- donaldc 17y agoThe west is still ahead of China in both Science and Technology, but they're moving fast and we're slowing down. I'd say that China is moving faster because they're still catching up. Once they've caught up, I doubt they'll be moving any faster than the West. China has it's problems, but it has one thing that the west does not have, which is the power to make very bold decisions and to realize them. No such thing as turf wars between parties or coalition building to dilute any plans. When the way forward is very clear, as it often is when playing catch-up, this is handy. This isn't as useful once a country has caught up, and needs to figure out the way forward without somewhere else showing the way. At that point, the way forward isn't clear, and discussion and disagreement are useful for arriving at a better solution than one could get from top-down.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat's a good point. So you are essentially arguing that as they approach parity they will stagnate again.
- jerf 17y agoWhen I make that point, I make it even stronger: If China was merely growing at the same rate as an established country, that would actually be surprising. Undeveloped countries moving to developed country status should be expected to develop more quickly than developed countries. The reason China may exceed others as a world power is that the developed China will still be five times larger than the US. It will take longer than people who naively project a continuous trend for China think it will take, though. And then there's the matter of India, too, which doesn't strike me as a natural Chinese ally. If you have a hard time understanding why, imagine a time portal to the United States fifty years from now opened up in downtown Manhatten (and suppose they are causally disconnected, parallel universes, so forget sci-fi paradoxes and stuff). Trade would begin, and technology would begin advancing very rapidly in the developed world as we learned how to build fusion reactors (probably) and grabbed their computer tech, bought copies of their educational materials, etc. (Presumably we'd trade for oil or something.) That's the sort of situation the developing world is in; they can buy things essentially decades or centuries (in some sad cases) ahead of their "natural" technology for the price of money, and advance far faster than the people who were at the same level of tech, but were at the apex of the world, did.
- tokenadult 17y agoit has one thing that the west does not have, which is the power to make very bold decisions and to realize them. I don't think I would point to that as a friendly atmosphere for basic science research.
- sethg 17y agoThey may not have turf was between parties (since one political party controls the entire government), but don't they have turf wars among factions within the party? (I am not anything close to an expert on Chinese politics but this seems to be a feature of just about any large organization, no?)