> consciousness is a macroscopic, emergent feature So far everybody agrees, but if you try to define emergent you get into trouble. So is consciousness weakly

> consciousness is a macroscopic, emergent feature So far everybody agrees, but if you try to define emergent you get into trouble. So is consciousness weakly or strongly emerging? Is there something special about qualia? So far, to the best of my knowledge, nobody has given a good definition, let alone a really good argument for either side.