3 ms·
Considering that every 3D game qualifies as an app that renders correctly under arbitrary multipliers, that argument seems a little suspect. The real answer is
by ajross 13y ago
Considering that every 3D game qualifies as an app that renders correctly under arbitrary multipliers, that argument seems a little suspect.
The real answer is that there is an industry of designers accustomed to doing per-pixel tuning of their art assets and this work is worthless if the assets are going to be scaled anyway. Selecting integer multipliers (so far: "2") allows those assets to continue to render as designed on retina displays.
Surely there are aesthetic reasons to prefer this in many cases, but it's not nearly as cut and dry a point as some people tend to think. Most recent Linux desktop themes are using vector assets, for example, with quite good results.
Whether the Mac/iOS world is a community of pixel-exact perfectionist artistes or a bunch of dinosaurs who refuse to use modern tools is a flame war for a different thread.
- mortenjorck 13y agoThe real answer is that there is an industry of designers accustomed to doing per-pixel tuning of their art assets and this work is worthless if the assets are going to be scaled anyway. That's an effect, but not the cause – the roots of the raster-based paradigm of modern GUIs are far more technical. I would point to the tradeoffs between speed and memory limitations in early GUI systems: If you look at the original Macintosh UI, you'll see a system more constrained by rendering speeds than by RAM, and thus a high emphasis on bitmaps versus vector rendering. Look at this Folklore.org story on the origin of the roundrect in System 1: http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Round_Rects_Are_Everywhere.txt http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Round_Rects_Are_E... It was only through a combination of Jobs' perfectionism and Atkinson's ingenuity that such a simple thing as rounded rectangles could be accomplished on the original Macintosh; can you imagine how long it would have taken to render a Finder window full of vector icons?
- gcr 13y agoAnd yet Linux machines have been drawing SVG icons and SVG widgets for years. This limitation doesn't exist any more. Look at Display Postscript, which was created by NeXT in the late 80s and carries through to much of Apple's Quartz rendering system today. Why are we still limiting ourselves to pixel graphics?
- mbreese 13y agoLet's be reasonable... 3D games and traditional desktop environments have a very different set of HCI expectations. You aren't often clicking an icon in a 3D game. While, I'd probably prefer to have vector graphics for desktop assets just for the flexibility, hand-tuned scaled images usually look better than their vector scaled siblings.
- simoncion 13y ago> You aren't often clicking an icon in a 3D game. Maybe I'm misunderstanding what you're saying. In case I'm not, here are some counterexamples. Check out the first two pictures in this thread (most things on that UI are clickable): https://forums.station.sony.com/ps2/index.php?threads/leaked-esamir-and-amerish-lattice-pics.136040/ https://forums.station.sony.com/ps2/index.php?threads/leaked... Clickable chat UI (Planetside 2): http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/6746/planetside2201302131837.jpg http://img138.imageshack.us/img138/6746/planetside2201302131... Clickable UI within a 3D world (Doom 3 had a bunch of these): http://static.gamespot.com/uploads/scale_super/gamespot/images/2004/reviews/589717-469881_20040811_022.jpg http://static.gamespot.com/uploads/scale_super/gamespot/imag...