4 ms·
Automation eliminates jobs - that's the whole point. One robot replaces 20 workers and you only need 1 person per every 20 robots to manage them. Sure, you've
by bluedino 13y ago
Automation eliminates jobs - that's the whole point. One robot replaces 20 workers and you only need 1 person per every 20 robots to manage them.
Sure, you've got jobs in robot building and such but when a robot shop with 20 employees turns out 200 robots in one year and displaces 4000 workers...
- ars 13y agoYou need to go to the next level. People automate things not to eliminate jobs (that's not the whole point), but to save money. So now the product is cheaper. So the buyers of the product have extra money to spend - which opens whole new fields of products and services for them, which will (at first) be run by humans and have jobs. It's a cycle that repeated many many times in history. It's just happening faster now. So if you want to always be employable (and you are not particularly skilled) be flexible - don't get stuck in a single field, but be willing to constantly learn new ones. (This is hard for some people, but some extra funding for adult vocational school should help.)
- wlesieutre 13y agoThe customers as a whole don't have more money, because half of them just got automated out of their jobs. Maybe enough new jobs come around that it isn't a long term problem this time, but there will come a time when essentially every job could be done by a computer. What then?
- VLM 13y agoArtisan economy? But it can't be monetarily based because only the few remaining capital owners and their very few labor jobs will have all the money. My artisan economy I mean handmade paintings, handmade food, plays with actors instead of CGI movies, musicians, bars...
- ahomescu1 13y agoThe artisans can create their own currency (even a digital one, call it ArtisanCoin) and only use it among themselves.
- jrs99 13y agoIf that point in time comes, and the computers still "obey" humans, yet still have enough control so that there are no wars between different computer groups, then nobody will have a job and we'll just ask robots to make us stuff and they'll mine other planets and make stuff for us, and we'll live in outerspace in spaceships and relax a lot.
- ameister14 13y agoThat's not really how things end up working, though; if you're living hand to mouth you end up spending all you make. If you're wealthy, you save much of your wealth. Yes, people have more money to spend, but no, trickle down economics doesn't really work out for the jobless.
- Daniel_Newby 13y ago> So the buyers of the product have extra money to spend ... Until they get spooked and cut back discretionary spending just in case. So-called service economies are not stable.
- batbomb 13y agoThe problem with this logic is that it assumes a zero-sum game, and a constant demand. Example: If we have 10 guys making hydrogen cells, and all the sudden we can replace them with one robot and one guy, and that takes an unviable industry to a viable one, well then they are going to need a lot more robots and guys, a lot more than the 10 they previously had.
- bluedino 13y agoExcept that never ended up happening. I live in a rust-belt city which was booming during most of the 1900's and ended up dying off when the 60's and 70's came around. Today I was at lunch in what's left of our downtown district, and there were old photographs on the wall of business that used to be in the area (mostly manufacturing). I was amazed that some of the photographs showed huge rooms of women sitting at work tables assembling parts, folding boxes, and packing items. That stuff is all gone. I could imagine a handful of machines replacing that group of people. When you go from a city having 50,000 factory workers to the 4,000 or so that we have now, it's a huge deal.
- batbomb 13y agoThe thing about economics though is it's about the average case, not the individual case. There's always going to be winners and losers, but as long as the winners beat out the losers things work okay. I think a future dedicated towards decentralized/distributed micro-economies relying on coordination and communication would be ideal, because it could prevent exactly what your town experienced. Automation in conjunction with networking could make your town a viable manufacturing micro-hub, for example, instead of those sorts of things being shipped off to Shenzhen. I'd argue The reason china is such a power house is precisely because we don't have the automation necessary to compete with them.
- krisdol 13y agoThe problem is that society's support system is nearly non-existent. If people have to do less work to create the same product, they should be awarded with more time away from work to enjoy their life. But without some ownership over the products of one's own labor, this is not an option. Rather than having a system where technology improves the lifestyle of the middle class, our status quo is a system where technology battles against the worker and puts her at risk of poverty.