4 ms·
>> OK. Now B: >> > B: Now I hunt among couples with two children >> > until I find one that doesn't have two girls, >> > and I ask: what are the od
by ColinWright 13y ago
>> OK. Now B:
>> > B: Now I hunt among couples with two children
>> > until I find one that doesn't have two girls,
>> > and I ask: what are the odds they have two
>> > boys?
>> Do you agree that it's 1/3?
> Yes, I apparently misread that one too.
OK, so you agree that this is 1/3. Now on to C:
>> > C: I hunt among couples with two children until
>> > I find one that has at least one boy, and I
>> > ask: what are the odds they have two boys?
Do you agree that this is 1/3?
Let's assume for fun that you do agree with that. The original problem was:
A: I met a man who said that he has two children,
at least one of which is a boy. What is the
probability that both children are boys?
Let's compare that with this one:
B: Among all the couples who have exactly two
children, and such that at least one of their
children is a boy, what is the probability
that both are boys?
Reading this:
> But again, I disagree on the issue of whether
> the form of the proposed analogue matches the
> original problem.
It seems like you're going to claim that these aren't the same problem.
I've made it very clear exactly what my model is for problem B. If you claim that problem A is different, then you need to provide me with a very clear model for your interpretation.