2 ms·
> ... in the table, he DOES tell you that in the BG case. > Otherwise there aren't two spots; there's only one. He > introduces the older/younger thing, th
by ColinWright 13y ago
> ... in the table, he DOES tell you that in the BG case.
> Otherwise there aren't two spots; there's only one. He
> introduces the older/younger thing, then fails to apply
> the new information across all cases.
I'm having real trouble understanding you here. The explanation lists all the possibilities, and to do so it's necessary to distinguish between the children. The most obvious way to do that is to talk about the older and younger.
we know that in families with two children about half the time you have one of each sex. You only get that if you distinguish between the children in some sense so that there are four overall possibilities: BB, BG, GB, GG. If you don't distinguish between the children then there are only three possibilities: Both boys, both girls, one of each. Doing real world trials clearly shows that model to be flawed. We must distinguish between the children when enumerating cases.
Forgive me if this is all obvious to you, but I honestly can't see your argument, so it's necessary to lay down much more detail to try to find where your reasoning varies from mine.
So now consider the situation I laid out. Take all families with two children. There are four equally likely possibilities. Eliminate those who cannot truthfully say "At least one child is a boy." You are left with three equally likely possibilities. In only one of those do we have two boys. Thus one out of three possibilities has both children boys.
The probability of both children being boys is 1/3.
Can you explain where that reasoning is faulty?
Also, computer simulations clearly show that under this model of what's going on, the chance of two boys is 1/3. If you explain the faulty reasoning, you'll also need to explain why the computer simulation gives the same answer.
- gametheoretic 13y agoYeah, I actually deleted it before seeing your response because I thought it was unclear. My bad. >The most obvious way to do that is to talk about the older and younger. Exactly. The father doesn't talk about older and younger, but the table does. What it should look like, because you're correct that age is irrelevant: B (given) * [b|g] -> [Bb|Bg], or if you account for age: [B is first|B is second] * [b|g] -> [Bb|bB|Bg|gB]. But you have to pick one or the other! Either way, it works, but you have to account on both ends, not just one. He's calculating for BG as if age were relevant, but it's not. The computer "simulation" is wrong because it is grounded in the logic that one child's sex wasn't a given all along, when in fact it was. NB: if you're throwing results out, that's a bad sign. Yea/nay? Or, again, you can just step back and say: X is a boy. What is the probability that Y is a boy? Why on earth would it matter what X was? Do you meet 2/3 women because you are a man?
- ColinWright 13y agoAfter enumerating all the options and their respective probabilities, yes, you discard all those that are inconsistent with the information to hand. You bring up the Monty Hall problem. The options there are: [ c ] [ g ] [ g ] [ g ] [ c ] [ g ] [ g ] [ g ] [ c ] These are all equally likely. Then you choose a door. Let's assume you choose door 1. To keep things equally likely, let's suppose Monty flips a coin. Heads he opens the left-most unchosen door that doesn't reveal a car, Tails he opens the right-most. Now we have six options: Heads: [ c ] [ g*] [ g ] [ g ] [ c ] [ g*] [ g ] [ g*] [ c ] Tails: [ c ] [ g ] [ g*] [ g ] [ c ] [ g*] [ g ] [ g*] [ c ] As you can see, there are now 6 equi-probable choices, and in 4 of them it's better to switch. A: So now let's take another experiment. I tell you I'm going to flip two coins until at least one of them is heads. I do that. Now I ask you to bet on whether or not there is a tail. What do you think are fair odds? B: Now I hunt among couples with two children until I find one that doesn't have two girls, and I ask: what are the odds they have two boys? C: Finally, I hunt among couples with two children until I find one that has at least one boy, and I ask: what are the odds they have two boys? This last is how the question is usually interpreted. There are three options. 1: Your answers to A, B, and C are not all the same; 2: They are all the same, and not 1/3; 3: They are all the same, and all 1/3. If your answers to A, B and C are not all the same, I'd like to know why. If they are not all 1/3, I'd like to play game A with you. If your answer to C is 1/3, then you've agreed with the usually interpretation and contradicted yourself.
- gametheoretic 13y ago> To keep things equally likely, let's suppose Monty flips a coin. Aha! But he can't! Do you see? He can't open a door with a car, so he can't flip a coin in the event that the car is behind a door other than yours. He is bound by the rules not to do so. 1/3 your door is good; 2/3 your door is bad. If bad, he MUST leave you with the good door to switch to. So in 2/3 of scenarios, you have a 100% likelihood of winning if you switch. The answer to all 3 is 1/2. GG + "at least one is a boy" is not a possible world, but you are calculating the probability of the others, initially, as if it were, and then asking another question on top of it. You can't do that. BB is only 1/2 as likely as BG/GB if GG is a possible world for the question to begin with.