10 ms·
'This is what an IED looks like. I took this photo near Kandahar.'
- torpor 17y agoHow to not get blown up by an IED in Afghanistan: Go home to your own country and fix its problems.
- kirubakaran 17y agoUS vehicles have cell-phone jammers What if they wire it to detonate on a jam? I hope the army has taken this into account (seems obvious that they would have.)
- sailormoon 17y agoThat would probably require a more advanced manipulation of the phone. When they trigger on ring, it's probably just using the power to the speaker or something built-in.
- jacquesm 17y agocell phones have this neat little 'buzzer' in them to alert you during meetings. It's a little motor with an excentric weight attached to them, when the motor spins the weight will cause the phone to vibrate. This is almost tailor made to set stuff off by remote. Beta test using the ringer, when it's all good make it hot by switching your profile to 'silent'.
- sailormoon 17y agoAh, good explanation! That certainly seems like the path of least resistance.
- stcredzero 17y agocell phones have this neat little 'buzzer' in them to alert you during meetings. It's a little motor with an excentric weight attached to them, when the motor spins the weight will cause the phone to vibrate The favored method of IED detonation was just to have the attach a small spool of thread to the motor and have it pull a thread to activate something. Not sure what the favored method is now.
- jacquesm 17y agoThat was a pretty lucky guess then. I swear I never blew anything up, but I love to tinker with stuff. Hooking up a small relay to the motor outputs or using the motor directly seemed like the obvious thing to do.
- kirubakaran 17y agoWell, won't some easily accessible electrical parameter about the phone change on a call getting cut? Voltage across the battery / speaker output / resistance of mic / something ? They can make a call after setting up the IED, they can just wait for the call to get cut for the IED to explode.
- jacquesm 17y agoman that would suck if the call got broken early for some other reason... "This is cingular, your credit is 0, terminating call"
- sailormoon 17y agoWhat if the call gets cut off just because it's a bad line? What if the jammer takes effect 500m before the first vehicle? What if the phone runs out of battery, which it will within hours if it's active on a call? Not to mention that finding the IEDs would be much easier if they were radiating like a mobile phone. All just guesses of course.
- jackdawjack 17y agoSeems like that would entail something in the phone that could see if it's connection to the base stations had unexpectedly fallen to almost zero. Assuming this is how being jammed works. This is probably quite hard to do on any non-sdk'd phone, so it might not have come up yet. Iphone prices probably need to drop a bit more... Cleary a dedicated radio detonator could be programmed to work like this, but then we are talking improvised here.
- stcredzero 17y agoRadio detonators are not so easy to improvise. So you end up buying off the shelf parts. But since there are many fewer radio controlled devices, this means your signal is a lot easier to trace. The nice thing about cell phones, is that there are a lot of them. And activation can be on a ring. How do you distinguish a hostile call before it has even been answered?
- gurtwo 17y agoYou just need to temporarily setup the network to block incoming calls to the phones in the patrolled area. This does not mean the 'signal' will drop to zero at any time, from the phone point of view. The phone will have absolutely no way to tell a blocked call from a lack of calls.
- run4yourlives 17y agoIt's probably a lot cheaper and easier just to wire it directly and go find a house to camp out in until the vehicles pass. Not all IDE's are designed the same way. Hence the "I". The easiest one would just be 3-4 AT mines linked together. This one looks to be anti-personnel/light vehicle, as fuel/air won't really defeat most armour.
- krschultz 17y agoYea, but then you would be nearby when a few dozen pissed off Marines jump off the other trucks in the convoy. Plus air support, tanks etc. The last thing insurgents want to do is be anywhere near the actual fight.
- run4yourlives 17y agoYou'd be nearby looking like every other civilian. And very few shots are fired during an IED strike unless there is the accompanying ambush (That does happen occasionally) inbound. Even Marines don't shoot randomly at things. SOP on an IDE strike is to secure the area and evac the wounded. That won't involve shooting unless there is reason too. All you have to do is sit there and relax.
- olihb 17y agoUnless it's a suicide mission.
- ErrantX 17y agowell you have to be fairly close anyway to make the call (further than a wire I guess, yes, but still)
- sp332 17y agoThe jamming equipment has a much larger effective range than an IED. They would go off well out-of-range. (Hopefully there are no civilians in-range!)
- stcredzero 17y agoAn even better option: work with the cell providers, so that the US has a back door to deactivate cell towers, but not completely -- just keep them from ringing phones. Then, the US just needs to have software that deactivates ringing of phones hear convoys. If there aren't to many convoys, then this will only be a minor inconvenience.
- JimmyL 17y agoSo they'll find a new way - timer after loss of signal, FRS radio, long-range cordless phones, IR sensors, etc. Worse comes to worse, they'll do it manually and blow themselves up in the process. This isn't the kind of problem that you can solve with technology - sure, you can make it more difficult, but the people who make these things do nothing else during a day but make IEDs; they'll find a new way to blow things up. Nothing encourages people to tinker with electronics like the perception that their country is being invaded and that they can fight back with bombs. So take control of their cell system (which, by the way, will do wonders for the perception that the US doesn't run the country) if you want, but don't expect that to change much. The way to beat IEDs is to make it so they don't want to set IEDs, or at least so that you've got enough people who don't want them set that they can report when others are.
- vaksel 17y agoSo why don't they get a few planes in the air, loaded up with cellular transmission equipment, and have them "call" every cell phone in the area? Would blow up all the hidden IEDs and all the IEDs that are being worked on. Would clear out a lot of the area, and might blow up a number of terrorists in the process.
- kirubakaran 17y agoThis is an awesome idea. But planes are not needed. Just get the cellphone company to ring all phones in the area at once, every one hour or so.
- stcredzero 17y agoIf you can get the cellphone companies to cooperate: develop a system that inhibits cellphones ringing in the vicinity of moving convoys. You can use a system that sends GPS coords to a computer, which then sends (encrypted challenge-response) inhibit messages to the towers close by the convoy.
- Femur 17y agoAlthough this solution and the solutions mentioned in the above threads are technically sound, I am aghast at the sincerity with which they were suggested. It is not appropriate to interfere with such a crucial piece of infrastructure. In developing countries especially, cell phones are the only link many people have. They run their small businesses, allow people to call family to see if they have been hurt, etc. Would you tolerate something like this in your Country? Shut down the internet for a little while to prevent a terrorist threat?
- Semiapies 17y agoJudging by most American's acquiescence to security demands since 2001, probably.
- Kadin 17y agoIn many cities, specialized police units either already have or are in the process of being issued cell phone jamming units. They are being issued with these sorts of scenarios specifically in mind. If the police think there's a bomb somewhere, set to be triggered via cell phone, damn right I'd want them to block the cell phones in the local area to keep it from going off. The problem with cell jamming technology isn't when it's being used to stop bombs from going off, the risk is that it'll be used for more trivial purposes.
- deutronium 17y agoRather than using a jammer I wonder if it'd be possible to use an EMP to fry the cellphone's semiconductors. I'd also be worried if using a jammer, if the device was programmed to detonate itself, after prolonged lack of contact with a cell tower.
- pmorici 17y agoWhat would keep you from frying your own equipment?
- deutronium 17y agoApparently specially hardened vacuum tubes aren't that susceptible to EMP pulses
- ramidarigaz 17y agoSo you're saying we should switch all the electronics that the military has on the ground over to vacuum tubes?
- gurtwo 17y agoStanding outside the beam? (Assuming there is a 'beam', of course. I ignore the radiation pattern of an EMP)
- JimmyL 17y agoI'm sure the Iraqi people - let alone the Russians and the Chinese - would love it if the US set off twenty or thirty EMPs every day as they went about their daily business.
- deutronium 17y agoI was was thinking some kind of small electromagnetic pulse, not a nuclear powered one.
- hyperbovine 17y agoI hate to be all Ron Paul-y here, but I can't help but point out that a much simpler solution to this problem than anything posted thus far is to simply not invade countries in the first place.
- alexgartrell 17y agoAfghanistan was the war we started to get rid of the Taliban and cripple Al Qaeda after they (Al Qaeda) blew up the towers. People pretty much universally agreed (and continue to agree) that going there was a good idea. edit: I don't mean to sound rah rah about war, it sucks that we're there and it sucks that we will be for a while. All I'm saying is it wasn't unjustified and there's no reason to sit back with the benefit of hindsight and say "We never should have gone in in the first place." Time is better spent figuring out how to fix the problem and get out. Any suggestions there?
- andreyf 17y agoPeople pretty much universally agreed (and continue to agree) that going there was a good idea. I don't. Most of the 9/11 hijackers were from Saudi Arabia, not Afghanistan, and the links between Al Qaeda, the Taliban, and OBL were tenuous at best and hugely overblown. As far as I can tell, our invasion seems to have affected an enormous increase in world opium production more than anything else. I don't know whom that benefits, but it sure isn't what I pay my taxes for.
- hyperbovine 17y agoNot quite: there was one person in the House who voted against the authorization of force in Afghanistan. She is my representative :-) And people continue to universally agree that going in there was a good idea? I mean, really? I grant you that nearly everyone was for it in the weeks after 9-11. Even I said something to that effect. But, hey, I was 19 and naive. Were the same thing to happen again tomorrow, I would not be so quick to judge, for what seemed liked a good idea at the time looks a lot more questionable 8 years later. Bin Laden is free, Afghanistan's cost to us in terms of lives and treasure grows by the week, the Taliban still rule large parts of the country, and Al Qaeda is not crippled. I am not asserting that the invasion was unjustified, but you have got to admit that it's highly debatable whether the benefits outweigh the costs in this, the eighth year of the war.
- omouse 17y agoSmall correction: should say just "NATO" not "US and NATO". US is part of NATO isn't it? I'm tired of Canadian and other NATO countries getting the shit end of the stick. The US didn't start to pull its weight until this year because they were side-tracked by Iraq...
- jwb119 17y agoi think its referring to the command structure rather than making a political statement. if the US troops are operating apart from NATO command then they should be referenced that way
- omouse 17y agoThey're operating as part of NATO, but this NATO mission just happens to be led by a US commander. Canadian troops go on missions alone too, and I assume the same is true of the other NATO members.