3 ms·
As pcrh hinted there is a bit of an echo chamber effect in academia. I noticed it as well. Many professors will advocate and encourage students because they the
by rdtsc 13y ago
As pcrh hinted there is a bit of an echo chamber effect in academia. I noticed it as well. Many professors will advocate and encourage students because they themselves chose that path. Some just see it as a good career, some want postdocs and TA students to help with grading and TAs.
One professor I had I heard telling the student, you can have a stable teaching job, good vacations, good life. It wasn't about contributing to science, about advancing research, being interested in the subject it was about trying to coast and mooch of the public university system.
- VLM 13y agodenigration of "... stable ... job, good vacations, good life... " = Stockholm syndrome victim. Let me make a wild guess, that whoever convinced you those are bad things to be avoided, personally financially benefits from your lack of a stable job, lack of vacation and lack of a good lifestyle? I wanted to go into physics when I was about 17... I couldn't figure out why ruining my theoretical future families life by grinding poverty would contribute to science, so bye bye physics. I can read a book if I want to.
- rdtsc 13y ago> Let me make a wild guess, that whoever convinced you those are bad things to be avoided, personally financially benefits from your lack of a stable job, lack of vacation and lack of a good lifestyle? It wasn't me, it was someone else that was being convinced. I was encouraged but not as directly. The idea is that at least public universities, should probably be spending resources grooming students who intent on advancing particular specialties or fields not just mooch off of tenure system. And I guess I would have expected them to make that a bit more veiled and not as direct. That is why perhaps tenure is harder to acquire and what separates average and below average schools from top tier ones (this wasn't a top one, just an average state college).
- VLM 13y agoThe Stockholm Syndrome thing is related to the language choice. Being able to take a vacation, or having a good lifestyle, does not equal "mooching".
- dnautics 13y agoLet me make a wild guess, that whoever convinced you those are bad things to be avoided, personally financially benefits from your lack of a stable job, lack of vacation and lack of a good lifestyle? I think you're missing the point that most PhDs will never attain that state via the 'conventional pathway' in any case, and the professor is seeing the outcome for the student as being some sort of entitlement just because the professor had it easy. It's borderline fraudulent behavior.
- gopher1 13y agoHaving a stable job with good vacations is mooching? Wow...
- rdtsc 13y agoHow is not doing research, not wanting to teach, and hiding behind tenure and sucking money and time for 25+ years not mooching? Wow...