4 ms·
Are you really claiming that creating a fake facebook account is "abuse"?
by ForHackernews 13y ago
Are you really claiming that creating a fake facebook account is "abuse"?
- jamesaguilar 13y agoIn the sense that it violates a social contract? That is, WIFI access in exchange for repping this spot to your friends in however minor a fashion? In the sense of behavior that you as a service provider wish to prevent? Yeah, in all those senses, it is "abuse."
- ForHackernews 13y agoTo me, "abuse" is a term with pretty strong connotations, and in some cases legal ramifications (e.g. "Computer Fraud and Abuse Act"). We're living in an environment where "exceeding authorized access" (whatever that means) carries the potential for decades-long prison sentences. If I think about how we use that word in other contexts: "spousal abuse", "drug abuse", "sexual abuse", I find it quite a stretch to apply the same term to giving a bogus email address to a marketing firm.
- jamesaguilar 13y agoI am sorry that you do not like how the term is used, but it is a fairly common way to phrase it among internet companies.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoI think you overlooked that they violated the social contract first by requiring you to submit to surveillance, so all I am doing is to protect me from their abuse.
- jbigelow76 13y agoThe "social contract" now includes wifi?
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoNo, the social contract includes not snooping in other people's private lives, and not co-opting unsuspecting third parties for doing so.
- diminoten 13y agoSo they have to give you free WiFi with no strings, stipulations, or benefit to them? You're free to not get on the WiFi if you don't want to, and frankly if you're hopping on any public WiFi, you've more or less lost any practical claim to privacy in the first place.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 13y agoThat might be your opinion, but I think you are wrong. And not only that, but where I live you would even be legally wrong. If you open your access point for public use here and you then go and look at other people's traffic, that is illegal and you can go to jail for it. And no, they don't have to give me free WiFi - they just have to not snoop on me. Just try to transfer your argument to a scenario that doesn't involve WiFi or facebook, but rather, say, tap water and as a prerequisite you have to confess belief in Allah. Illegal? Certainly not. Totally inappropriate? I would say so. You see, this is not a legal argument, it's about ethics, about what makes a society worthwhile to live in, not about what the minimal standards are that we enforce using state power.
- diminoten 13y agoThey are legally and morally permitted to make snooping on your Internet traffic part of what you have to agree to in order to use their WiFi. The ability for a person to set the terms in which others interact with his private property is what makes this society worthwhile to live in. People can't force their way into your stuff without you setting conditions for that use. And you're correct that looking at other people's traffic is illegal. It's illegal where I come from too. So is speeding.