3 ms·
Are you saying American fiction overplays how effective violence is compared to other options? Because it's clear (and you may be acknowledging) that violence
by humanrebar 13y ago
Are you saying American fiction overplays how effective violence is compared to other options?
Because it's clear (and you may be acknowledging) that violence is the best option in at least some circumstances. Otherwise, prisons, soldiers, and police officers wouldn't be necessary.
- jaimebuelta 13y agoYes, my perception is that, in general, in American fiction, the way to go is with a violent solution! (Again, that's makes great spectacular movies, don't get me wrong, and it's a general thing compared with movies from elsewhere, not something that happens all the time) For example, if you want to stop a meteorite hitting Earth, do not use rockets attached to its surface, explode a huge nuclear bomb! If you have to start the nucleus rotation, do not make any chemical reaction or engineering project, just explode a huge nuclear bomb! If you are a multibillionaire that wants to solve crime, just personally punch criminals in the face! And we're talking about fiction, not real life. I'm ok with spectacular, but I can't help noticing it :-P
- zeidrich 13y agoViolence is harming a person or living thing. Blowing inanimate things up is just physics.
- andrewflnr 13y agoEh, true. But on a basic level, with empathy turned down (and it is, after all it's just a show and no one is really getting hurt), it's basically the same thing. "Other people" can just be meat that's in the way.
- supersystem 13y agoThere are significantly less prisons, soldiers and police officers in countries which to a lesser degree favor violence as a solution.
- alan_cx 13y agoWell, that whats you have been taught to believe, sure. See, how do you know you dont think that because of decades of the media tell you to think that? Not just that but American culture is gun culture rooted in the Wild West way of things. Look at how the gun nuts can even consider life without guns. Something weird, amusing and scary to many civilized countries.
- vacri 13y agoThose two comments don't disagree. "overplay" and "works in some situations" are concepts that agree quite readily.