2 ms·
A thousand times, this. But in addition, we need to get politicians to wait for the experiment to finish and look at results before pushing policies. For exampl
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
A thousand times, this. But in addition, we need to get politicians to wait for the experiment to finish and look at results before pushing policies. For example, basically no states have changed their plans to expand Medicaid as a result of the Oregon Medicaid Experiment, in spite of the fact that the results surprised everyone.
A truly depressing fact - the best experiment in public health policy since 1974 was an accident, caused solely by the fact that Oregon didn't have enough money to expand Medicaid for everyone. Depressing, no?
- kijin 13y agoThe real world isn't a perfect laboratory, so sometimes you must make do with data supplied by accidents and coincidences ;) Having said that, yes, it's truly depressing that politics can't seem to wait for proper results. As one of the most influential papers in my field of study (STS) says, "the speed of political decision-making is faster than the speed of scientific consensus formation." Sometimes this is forgivable -- if global warming is real, we can't afford to wait for its ill effects to become obvious, can we? -- but in other times, big-P politics just gets in the way of a good research program. Throwing in a bunch of confounding factors halfway through an experiment and whatnot.
- calinet6 13y ago> The real world isn't a perfect laboratory, so sometimes you must make do with data supplied by accidents and coincidences ;) You must also understand statistics, and build an experiment that isn't affected by them.