6 ms·
I don't get it. According to the article, Basic Income causes working hours to drop 9% in the American controlled experiment. They try to explain it away by act
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
I don't get it. According to the article, Basic Income causes working hours to drop 9% in the American controlled experiment. They try to explain it away by acting as if 9% is small, and providing anecdotes suggesting in some cases it might be a good thing.
For comparison, the great recession resulted in a 3.4% drop in GDP. Now, a 9% drop in work will result in less than a 9% drop in GDP (wealth is increasingly produced by machines, not people, resulting in a lower labor share of income), but even so, 9% is big.
By the way, as I always ask when this topic comes up, can someone link to actual studies? I.e., hard data rather than an innumerate reporter breathlessly advocating a proposal because it sounds cool?
Incidentally, a back of the envelope calculation (http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/basic_income_vs_basic_job.html http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2013/basic_income_vs_basic...) suggests that it would be vastly cheaper to adopt FDR's employer of last resort policy. If we are going to adopt a radical overhaul, lets consider the full search space.
[edit: some sources about the third world are cited on the right, not the bottom, and I missed them on first reading. Thanks davidx.]
- bandushrew 13y agothat is a very narrow way to look at it. the 9% 'drop in work' will be offset by the increase in consumption caused by a large range of people suddenly having more purchasing power, businesses will have to increase production, and hire more workers to do so. they will have to pay the workers more to entice them in, and provide better working conditions. this will generate more work, and higher consumption.
- spurgu 13y agoAnd artists will have more time/freedom to create and thus inspire people, and from that create more happiness for the general population, which cannot directly be measured in terms of money, but is still very valuable.
- lazyjones 13y ago> businesses will have to increase production, and hire more workers to do so. they will have to pay the workers more to entice them in, and provide better working conditions. this will generate more work, and higher consumption. The problem is, noone has tried to see the complete picture by adding up these effects. The net effect is probably negative, unless this is introduced all over the world simultaneously. Businesses will hire more people and pay them more => prices will go up, purchasing power for domestic products will go down (i.e. the same income will afford fewer domestic products). Imports will go up because those products will be cheaper than before in comparison. Exports will go down for the same reason. Therefore, a large part of the expected higher consumption will go to imports / foreign profits. Due to reduced exports, domestic production will go down instead of up. Since jobs cost more now, there will be even fewer of them than expected. Overall, countries which introduce this, will suffer.
- jeza 13y agoWhat happens if a basic income were adjusted for those price increases? One would think it would be linked to CPI and living costs.
- lazyjones 13y agoI'd expect people to buy (more) imported products rather than (the same amount of more expensive) domestic products. It would probably be worthwhile to give people part money and part vouchers for certain eligible (i.e. domestic but some international treaties might not allow this discrimination of imported goods) products, in order to keep the purchases of domestic goods at a high level.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWe'll have less wealth created, but more people will be willing to spend money consuming it. All that means is prices will go up. Your Keynesian story may eventually play out - the real value of the BI might be inflated away, resulting in people going back to work. Perhaps that will completely mitigate the problem, or perhaps it will merely result in a new equilibrium which only hax 0 < X% < 9% fewer people working. But why create the problem in the first place? If 100 people produce 10 apples each, you have 1000 apples. If 9 of them quit, you have only 910 apples.
- barrkel 13y agoHowever, with 9 people free to quit making apples, the chances of one of them producing oranges increases. I don't think we have good information on second and third order effects.
- davedx 13y agoI think a more apt analogy is: If 100 people produce 10 apples each, and 99 robots take over the job of producing apples, there will be 99 unemployed people with no money to buy your 1000 apples.
- damon_c 13y ago... unless the owner of the robots who profits by selling all the apples to wealthy people in other countries is forced to redistribute the wealth in the form of a basic income.
- PavlovsCat 13y agoIn reality however, OWS and other activists are under surveillance to avoid exactly that outcome.
- rayiner 13y agoBecause is a developed economy, total production is an increasingly irrelevant measure.
- 13y ago
- thedufer 13y ago> they will have to pay the workers more to entice them in, and provide better working conditions. Source? Widespread BI is usually proposed alongside abolishment of the minimum wage. This means that you'd expect wages at the low end to start reflecting job comfort more - crappy jobs (trash pickup?) would have to be paid more to entice people, but cushier jobs may well see pay go down.
- maxk42 13y ago> the 9% 'drop in work' will be offset by the increase in consumption caused by a large range of people suddenly having more purchasing power That money didn't come from nowhere. There is an equal decrease in purchasing power for others due to the increased taxes needed to fuel such an expensive scheme.
- davedx 13y agoThere are links to the studies in the right hand side alongside the text. Here you go: Homeless study: http://www.jrf.org.uk/publications/support-rough-sleepers-london http://www.jrf.org.uk/publications/support-rough-sleepers-lo... Experimental evidence from Uganda: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2268552 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2268552 An Experimental Assessment of the Women’s Income Generating Support (WINGS) Program in Uganda: http://www.poverty-action.org/sites/default/files/wings_full_policy_report_0.pdf http://www.poverty-action.org/sites/default/files/wings_full... OECD study "Just Give Money to the Poor - The Development Revolution from the Global South": http://www.oecd.org/dev/pgd/46240619.pdf http://www.oecd.org/dev/pgd/46240619.pdf It's a bit harder to find as they're not at the bottom of the article where they usually are. But the author of the article did cite several studies. Did you choose to ignore them?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI missed them, thanks. But the main studies I was interested in are still not there. Specifically, the US and Canada controlled experiments from the 70s (the one it claims reduces labor by "only" 9%). Given how radically different the first and third world are from each other (one example: in the third world the poor usually work, in the first world they usually don't), I don't see much sense in extrapolating Uganda experiments to the US. The closest they ever come is citing the same newspaper article about Mincome that everyone else cites: http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/dauphins-great-experiment.html http://www.winnipegfreepress.com/local/dauphins-great-experi...
- jhaglund 13y agoI think you should reconsider the assertion that poor in the US usually don't work. Minimum wage jobs leave you just above the poverty level if you're single, below if you are supporting someone. Considering cash based, under the table, transient work that poor people accept is under reported (for fear of loosing benefits which fall off steeply as a recipient's income increases) I think even finding statistics on this would be difficult. There are sociopaths on welfare (http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2013/12/linda_taylor_welfare_queen_ronald_reagan_made_her_a_notorious_american_villain.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/history/2013... ) as surely as there are sociopaths in power. But what this article is saying is most people who need assistance are going to do good things with the assistance.
- jhaglund 13y agoIf we can have an increasing GDP while most of America experiences stagnation (as with the recent recovery) who's to say we can't have decreasing GDP coupled with improving quality of life? (at least for a short period) As you point out, machines are doing far more of the work that workers once did. Another policy of FDR's New Deal was the creation of the 8 hour day (many people still worked 12-14 hour days until then: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_Day#United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eight-hour_Day#United_States). Perhaps reduced hours allowed more laborers to move into the workforce, and could be a more competitive and cheap way of supporting a broad middle class.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoMost of America has not experienced stagnation. They have experienced a consistent increase in employment compensation and a consistent increase in consumption. http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECICOM http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/ECICOM http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=qG0 http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=qG0 The only "stagnation" that has occurred has been a shift in compensation from taxable wages to untaxed non-wage benefits. The fundamental problem is that with a drop in labor we will have fewer goods and services. No matter how you slice it, that's a drop in (real, not necessarily nominal) consumption.
- jhaglund 13y agoWhat about this labor drop? http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CIVPART?rid=50&soid=22 http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/series/CIVPART?rid=50&s...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoWhat about it?
- keithnoizu 13y agoYou can reduce working hours while increasing revenue if workers are using this to train in and land better paying careers that complement their skill sets better.
- mattmanser 13y agoI certainly don't think a 9% drop in working hours is a 9% drop in GDP. Doesn't make a single lick of sense to me. The real world simply doesn't work like that at all. Not everyone in a country contributes exactly the same figure to GDP. Also, a couple of lines down listed a huge number of cost savings and higher earnings and new employment created. So.... Did you just not read on a paragraph more?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI certainly don't think a 9% drop in working hours is a 9% drop in GDP. From my post: "Now, a 9% drop in work will result in less than a 9% drop in GDP..." The next few lines cite no stats. They just quote someone saying the decline was "undoubtedly compensated in part by other useful activities". As I said, "can someone link to actual studies?" (Note: I realize studies in Uganda are linked, but I'm talking about the US and Canada studies, which had a 9% and 13% drop in hours worked according to uncited numbers in this article.)
- ronaldx 13y ago* Why do you think GDP is the most significant stat? I suggest that GDP primarily represents the status of the wealthy, and that working people may not be sensitive to GDP. Why is GDP your KPI, rather than, the status of the poorest in society? * Why do you think a drop in working hours would cause a drop in GDP at all? I would assume the working hours lost would be at least below average productivity, and could be negative productivity, as the false incentive for people to create 'work' for themselves is reduced.
- epsylon 13y agoRemember the homeless guy who coded an app? Imagine what a basic income could do to the millions of people whose brainpower is mostly dedicated to surviving day to day, week to week, month to month. (Because indeed, poverty taxes our brain [1]) The article provides really strong examples in why a 9% drop in working hours does not necessarily mean a drop in "created wealth". (In fact, I'd argue that many European social democracies work on average less than US workers, yet still maintain a very high GDP) [1] http://www.theatlanticcities.com/jobs-and-economy/2013/08/how-poverty-taxes-brain/6716/ http://www.theatlanticcities.com/jobs-and-economy/2013/08/ho...
- makomk 13y agoAt least some of those working hours were probably spent doing work that, if supply and demand actually functioned normally in the job market, could not exist because the employers valued it at less than the cost of supplying that work in terms of keeping the workers fed, housed and capable of work.
- scotty79 13y ago9% drop in work might result in no drop in GDP, increase in work efficiency or even raise in GDP because this 9% goes somewhere, pesonal development, smarter consumption better care for the children or often long overdue maintenance of belongins. In recent recession US industry shed a lot of workers with no intention of hiring them back and yet production and revenue already exceeded prerecession levels. Work does not create wealth. Tools create wealth. There's always plenty of hands wanting to grab the tool and brains eager to learn how to swing it and modern tools require less and less of both.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> it would be vastly cheaper to adopt FDR's employer of last resort policy The employer of last resort policy is perhaps a useful emergency policy for dealing with mass unemployment in an industrial-era economy, but its a rather bad long-term policy because make-work inhibits, rather than enables, risk-taking, entrepreneurship, and skill realignment, and it has serious limitations in an increasingly post-industrial economy. Progressive automation means that era of wage labor is waning -- what we need is a transition to an economy of microcapital, and viewing a substantial share of taxation as being rents on the commons that are redistributed equally to the citizenry is probably the best way to get there. Pointless make-work wage-labor for a growing undercapitalized underclass while the overclass lives on larger and more concentrated capital stocks is not a good alternative.