3 ms·
No-one will oppose this more fervently than those employed on very good wages in the present system.
by gaius 13y ago
No-one will oppose this more fervently than those employed on very good wages in the present system.
- smartial_arts 13y agoWhy would they? Personally, being taxed close to 37% (in Australia) already, I don't have any issues with my tax money being spent on that cause.
- gaius 13y agoBecause http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principal%E2%80%93agent_problem The status quo - a large, expensive bureaucracy, employing many civil servants, social workers, etc - suits the interests of too many people. Here in the UK we could sweep away the "welfare system", that spends nearly all of its effort making sure people get the "right" amount and replace it with some sort of basic income, for which we need 2 employees to maintain an automated system that pays everyone the same, a man to feed the dog, and a dog to bite the man if he tries to change anything.
- benmmurphy 13y agoDeveloped countries will probably eventually get some kind of basic income system but it won't be simple :) I'm sure it will be very complicated and there will be still lots of mean tested programs to accompany it to make sure a large bureaucracy is still required.
- erichocean 13y agoThen that system will be, by definition, not "basic". One of the features of basic income is that it removes politics from poverty. If you have a system that is political, you have welfare in another form, with yet another name. Basic income applies to the rich and poor alike, is identical for everyone, and carries no social stigma as a result, and offers no opportunity for political graft. IMO that is why adoption is incredibly unlikely—politicians would need to approve it, and by doing so, they'd be putting themselves (mostly) out of a job. It seems extremely unlikely to me that will happen.
- peterjaap 13y agoPersonally, being taxed close to 52% (in Holland), I don't have any issues with that either. Let's keep a close eye on the developments in Switzerland concerning basic income and take our lessons from that.
- finishingmove 13y agoYou might think that at first, and it's probably true to some extent, but ultimately they would not oppose it too much. It's good to see ideas of basic income resurfacing in Europe. Only a step towards a more distributed economy, but an important one for today's society -- which seems to be slowly crumbling for the most part.
- johnchristopher 13y ago> You might think that at first, and it's probably true to some extent, but ultimately they would not oppose it too much. There's a fierce and vocal opposition on HN though. Hard to tell what it really means without knowing everyone's country, political views and other various characteristics.
- davedx 13y agoI pay almost 50% in taxes here in the Netherlands, and wholeheartedly support this system. The current system is worse.
- peterjaap 13y agoI think those that are employed on very good wages have a decent set of brains, and thus they can see that this is a good idea and therefore will NOT oppose it.
- johnchristopher 13y agoNope, that is a well-known bias that wealthy working people are de facto more intelligent.
- keithnoizu 13y agoI was making a little over 120k a year when I was still in the states. (on sabbatical currently). Not a huge amount moneys sure but I can vouch for being more than happy to see a portion of that going to programs like this as I believe programs like this will have the best long term outcomes for the states economy and therefore myself as well.