11 ms·
High-end CNC machines can't be moved without manufacturers' permission
- robabbott 13y agoSure, we'll use the embargo clause to explain this. The real reason is that, when you have machines capable of making new machine parts, you want to know when they move around and start building Skynet.
- toufka 13y agoWhat happens when a GPS satellite fails? Or if you have an earthquake? Seems like precisely in those times of national need that one's most sophisticated technologies might be sorely out of commission. A seemingly pretty nice way to inflict 'collateral damage' on one's self. Especially if such a precautionary set of rules were put into more and more machines.
- superuser2 13y agoThe interlocks aren't permanent - they can be bypassed by the manufacturer.
- Udo 13y agoI'm not sure you actually meant it as a joke, but that's hilarious in a cynically-detached kind of way. So these machines are not bought but licensed and they will fail as soon as the manufacturer becomes unable to continually grant usage rights, i.e. during a region-wide catastrophe.
- superuser2 13y agoI'm merely pointing out that GPS outage would be no more than an annoyance. . If the machinery experiences significant acceleration in an earthquake, it's not necessarily intact or safe to operate afterwards. The enclosing machine shop is also not likely to be in any state to continue operations if something as large as the pictured CNC machine has been thrown across the room. I don't buy that this issue is a big deal either. From a software freedom standpoint, yes, this is terrible. But I don't think it's as much of a problem for the owner as the parent suggests.
- yaddayadda 13y agoI have no idea how many of these machines are in a given area, but assuming it is an IMU [1] triggered lockdown, an earthquake could lock down many (10?, 100?, 1,000?) in a single geographic area very, very quickly. That seems like a big problem. If the lockdown mechanism is GPS, then it should be clear where the actual machine is, so there shouldn't be any need to lock it down unless it's in a black zone. And what happens if the manufacturer goes belly-up? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_measurement_unit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_measurement_unit
- AlexDanger 13y agoConsumer GPS devices have some interesting lock-down rules built into them. They shut themselves down if they detect you are travelling around Mach 2 or above 18000 metres altitude. The reasoning is fairly obvious - they dont want to see dumb missiles getting upgraded to a DIY guided ballistic missile thanks to a $100 Garmin gaffa taped to the side and a cheap flight control computer. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CoCom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CoCom
- mct 13y agoThey shut themselves down if they detect you are travelling around Mach 2 or above 18000 metres altitude The intention was for a GPS device to disable itself if it was traveling faster than 1k knots AND above 60k feet, not traveling faster than 1k knots OR above 60k feet. Unfortunately, many GPS devices improperly implement this as an OR condition, rather than an AND condition. This becomes problematic when using a GPS in a high-altitude weather balloon to determine altitude and location, which a few friends and I did a couple years ago. We had to be very careful when selecting the GPS we used to avoid this pitfall.
- AlexDanger 13y agoInteresting, I did not know that. Which GPS did you end up using?
- wyager 13y agoWhich GPS units are acceptable for this? I'm working on a HAB and I'm worried about this CoCom bullshit. The one I'm thinking of uses a SiRFstarIII or IV; any idea of those use || instead of the proper &&?
- nknighthb 13y ago> What happens when a GPS satellite fails? The receivers use other satellites. They have to anyway: You can't get a fix with only one satellite.
- baddox 13y agoI would imagine you normally need three. If I'm visualizing the geometry correctly, the intersection of three spheres is two points, and it should be easy to guess which of the two is the more likely location of your device.
- mutagen 13y agoBecause relatively cheap GPS receiver clocks drift, typically 4 satellites are needed for a position. You can assume an elevation, especially at sea level, and solve a position with three satellites but this introduces other factors (ellipsoid vs geoid, satellite constellation geometry, etc) that can make a good position difficult to obtain. In practice there are enough satellites that these considerations are theoretical. Most situations that would involve limited satellites also introduce stuff like multi path reflections that further degrade position accuracy.
- tinkerdol 13y agoHere is a graphic to add to that explanation if anyone is curious: http://gis.stackexchange.com/questions/12866/why-does-gps-positioning-require-four-satellites http://gis.stackexchange.com/questions/12866/why-does-gps-po...
- avn2109 13y agoIn North America your GPS probably connects to between five and twelve satellites.
- joncp 13y agoThere's a legitimate use for GPS spoofing.
- IvyMike 13y agoShutting down a competitor's machine shop, for one.
- nobodyshere 13y agoA little earthquake or nearby explosion of some kind and all factory machines shut down. Aaand wait for a code, but first compose a request with all machine numbers.
- mhb 13y agoThey're not gong to be receiving GPS signals in the type of room in which these machines are found.
- alan_cx 13y agoI might be missing a huge point here, but aren't very high precision, high end cnc machines virtually vital for the production of nuclear devices? If thats the level of machine we are talking about, I can well understand this.
- mbreese 13y agoThat's not a bad point. I can see the desire to keep these away from certain places, but if that's the case, why geo-lock them so much? Why couldn't you allow a large region of GPS coordinates and add a mandatory blacklist of locations? Instead of solving the "problem" (stop the machines from working in Iran), the manufacturer turned this into a profit center. Blocking a company from rearranging their work floor seems a bit much.
- ewoodrich 13y agoI would guess that part of the problem is that relying entire on GPS would not be practical, considering the likelihood that many machines would be located within large warehouses or industrial buildings that block a GPS signal. The article mentions that gyros are also used, so I suspect that the company prefers to have a defensible list of purchasers, with the confidence that this would not change without their knowledge. Similar in results to a blacklist, but somewhat more reliable from the manufacturer's perspective.
- jey 13y agoGPS by itself could be easily spoofed. It's a well-known protocol that is broadcast in the clear.
- danpat 13y agoModern, fancy nuclear devices, perhaps. But I suspect that the machining to make something that goes boom is probably well within the means of a traditional machine shop.
- bd_at_rivenhill 13y agoActually, my understanding is that the tolerances, at least for implosion-type weapons, are extreme and required scientific advances to achieve during the Manhattan Project, not to mention the fact that Uranium and Plutonium are much, much denser than any material that would be encountered at a typical shop.
- scottoreilly 13y agoThis seems incredibly brittle - just like software DRM that needs to phone home. What happens 15 years from now when they shut down their servers?
- krasin 13y agoThey don't connect to the company server. They just shut down and display a message to the operator. It's up to the operator to receive an unlock code from the manufacturer. So, there's no server involved. It's all human-to-human interaction. But again, in 15 years all these codes will be lost by the manufacturer itself, so your main point is valid.
- al2o3cr 13y agoUm, you stop using the machine? The sort of business that is buying these CNC mills isn't going to be interested in using an out-of-support machine (too much risk) and likely depreciates the machine to $0 value in 5-6 years anyways.
- letstryagain 13y agoI don't think this uses GPS. A high-end CNC machine would have about 0% chance of seeing any GPS satellites. Even the linked thread said it uses gyros without mentioning GPS.
- yaddayadda 13y agoThe linked thread actually does have a couple, albiet tenuous, mentions of GPS: - "All of our Citizen swiss lathes have the same GPS feature." (http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-maho-cnc/mori-ellison-gyroscope-unlocking-273841/#post2141101) - "Why can't they simply check for "Out of USA" or "in $BannedCountry now"? They do have GPS, right?" (http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-maho-cnc/mori-ellison-gyroscope-unlocking-273841/#post2141382)
- spyder 13y agoI agree, and if it would use GPS then they could do the blocking only if it leaves the country, so probably the sensor is just a simpler accelerometer.
- venus 13y agoThat is a rather misleading headline. A better one might be: "US arms export regulations force CNC manufacturers to implement anti-relocation lockout mechanisms" Of course it's not just the manufacturers being dicks; they implement that or they can't import to the USA.
- jey 13y agoReally? I thought the vendors just can't sell to Iran, not that they have to build in lockouts that enforce compliance by their customers.
- venus 13y agoAccording to the thread the story is taken from, the machines are now under the purview of ITAR: http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-maho-cnc/mori-ellison-gyroscope-unlocking-273841/ http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-m...
- karthikb 13y agoManufacturers of ITAR controlled devices typically have to enforce compliance by their customers. If there's a method to enforce compliance and it isn't present, the manufacturer can be held responsible for the export. Some things (such as mirrors for lasers) can't really be enforced while others (large machines, aircraft) can be.
- vacri 13y agoIran is in another corner of the installed workroom?
- nraynaud 13y agoWith the irony being that the only ever country to use nuclear weapons is enforcing something on the only ever country to receive those weapons, in the name of nuclear weapon control.
- 001sky 13y agoa situation that the manufacturers have turned into a business-opportunity by using the technology to assist in repossessing machines from delinquent lease-payers -- and requiring permission for privilege of deciding where to place their key capital assets. Yikes. Classic Holdup Problem. There are certainly ways to force inventory checks without GPS software locks; this must have been implemented because of the desire to have actual remote 'kill' capability. What I don't understand is the line of sight issues with (actual) GPS sensors. If the machine is blocked from the birds...like it would typically be indoors...something seems odd.
- cpenner461 13y agoA rather interesting/insightful comment from the article: http://bbs.boingboing.net/t/high-end-cnc-machines-cant-be-moved-without-manufacturers-permission/18591/33 http://bbs.boingboing.net/t/high-end-cnc-machines-cant-be-mo...
- caprad 13y agoNot really. There is a lot of logic failure in this comment. What does the fact they don't install them on US machines have to do with them not using it as a business opportunity? This is a non-sequitur. Since this guy hasn't heard of them being used to enforce finance deals means absolutely nothing, how could anyone cancel out a point because of that? And his third point skips out on the fact that adding this functionality to the machine can cause extra problems.
- analog31 13y agoThis is completely beside the point of the article, but I work for a company that makes fairly large precision equipment. A potential service nightmare is when the customer moves the equipment and screws it up. A lot of this equipment is designed to only be installed by the supplier, due to the amount of documentation and training that would be needed for customer installation. And something like a big CNC may have some fairly detailed site and installation requirements. Maybe the GPS is so it can receive targeted ads. "Customers who machined this part also ordered..." ;-)
- alan_cx 13y agoWell, I know it took me ages to get my half decent hobby lathe (Myford) perfectly setup for my own hobby use, which is possibly the least accurate form of machining out there. (No, Im not making bombs, I'm making parts for silly, RC usually, models!!!) So, I can well see high end CNC machines having to be very precisely set up, and I can also see that being a fairly long, PITA job. Frankly, if we are talking maintenance on CNC machines worth $100k, or whatever, I'd want some lock down and historic data. Does make sense. So, I think where contracts are in place, they have every right to lock the machine down. Which is probably part of any contract. But, putting aside what I was saying about nukes, I can't see why, if there is no contract, an owner has to have his machine bricked if (s)he wants to move it. Again, unless these machines are specifically restricted by law or international treaty type things.
- vacri 13y agoReminds me of a story from the other end of the skill ladder - as a student, I had a short-term job in a hosiery factory, ostensibly to help move a couple of very heavy machines around, with the rest of the time doing stockroom work. The Day came, the crane operator came along and told us to keep clear, and we didn't lay a finger on the machinery. Us hired meat just went back to the stockroom, fine by us. Incidentally, if you're looking for easy stockroom work, a hosiery factory has no heavy lifting...
- Cthulhu_ 13y agoYeah that sounds like a valid reason, too. These things work with millimeter accuracy; jolt them and the accuracy may be off. Position them just slightly off-level and they might be off.
- tantalor 13y agorequiring permission for privilege of deciding where to place their key capital assets Owners should have this right. I'm interested in the security implications of this What does gyro sensor lockdown have to do with malware? the mills are designed to be opaque to their owners You're not really the owner if somebody can lock you out. lest they disable the gyro/GPS Disabling the sensor would probably trigger the lockdown.
- gaius 13y agoOwners should have this right. Like many things, it depends. If the device is supported by the vendor, and requires very high precision such that jarring it could un-calibrate it, then this is perfectly reasonable, otherwise support costs would become prohibitively expensive for everyone. Why would they care if you've bought it? Because they are protecting their reputation. Consider the situation of the typical Windows desktop that becomes more and more unusable as the user installs more and more toolbars and other malware. Windows takes the blame for it, but the problem would just go away if it prevented random stuff being installed.
- EvanMiller 13y agoAnother possibility that hasn't been mentioned is that the purchase agreement might include some kind of first refusal for the manufacturer to repurchase the equipment if the original owner wants to sell. This kind of provision prevents the emergence of a used-equipment market, the existence of which would cut into the manufacturer's pricing power on new equipment. Requiring the manufacturer's consent to relocate the equipment would be one way for the manufacturer to enforce such an agreement. tl;dr if you sell expensive machinery then do everything in your power to prevent buyers from reselling.
- hkmurakami 13y agoWasn't there a YC company whose business is to resell semiconductor capital equipment? Must be a bit of a goldmine business. edit: Found them. http://www.asseta.com/ http://www.asseta.com/
- fsck--off 13y agoThe market isn't small enough for these tactics to work. It's much more likely that this was a response to the very real and well documented problem of illegal exports. Another Japanese company, Mitutoyo, was caught several times illegally exporting these machines to embargoed countries, including North Korea and Iran. Some of Mitutoyo's executives were jailed for this.[1] Adding tamper-proofing and tracking is a great way to make sure that regain confidence and avoid prison. Edit: I'm not sure why this was downvoted. A representative from Mori said something similar on the board linked to by the original article: "Regarding the device, Weapons of Mass Destruction. Worst case for a negligent violation would be Dr. Mori himself spending time in the slammer. That along is enough motivation for DMG MORI to follow the regulation very carefully. Other reasons include all of those stated above! btw, no need to waste time on bypassing it. It is pretty solid. We have to make it so Iran, N. Korea, etc's best can't bypass it." [2] I think that this is a perfectly plausible explanation and don't think that the real ulterior motive is controlling resale, especially when other foreign competitors do not have the same restrictions. [1] http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2006/09/02/news/mitutoyo-tied-to-iran-north-nuclear-quests/#.UmWKRlPp47k http://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2006/09/02/news/mitutoyo-ti... [2] http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-maho-cnc/mori-ellison-gyroscope-unlocking-273841/ http://www.practicalmachinist.com/vb/dmg-mori-gildemeister-m...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 13y agoWhen the CNC mills from Toshiba made it to the Soviet Union in the 1980's, it had a significant impact on submarine warfare: http://www.auilr.org/pdf/4/4-1-8.pdf http://www.auilr.org/pdf/4/4-1-8.pdf THE TOSHIBA-KONGSBERG INCIDENT (pdf)
- forktheif 13y agoIf you did want to stop CNC machines being used in Iran or North Korea, why not just use the GPS chip to disable the machines if they're inside those countries? I don't see what's to be gained by causing the machines to fail if they've been moved to the other end of a factory.
- skriticos2 13y agoMaybe they'd put the machines in facilities with bad GPS reception?
- karthikb 13y agoNo GPS inside of a metal box (like a shipping container). You can also spoof GPS since it's a one-way passive signal.
- belorn 13y agoWe should not be too surprised at this. As long that property laws can be circumvented with technology, more companies will get into the business of retaining full control after sale. With practically no drawbacks and only benefits, it goes against economics to not do it. It doesn't matter if its a CD, game, website, a car, a high end CNC, or a coffee maker. Retaining effective ownership after sale is just so useful from a corporation point of view. Never again does a product need to escape into the control of an customer. That this story might be explained with regulation is not much of an surprise. No US politician would dream of publicly stand for the view point of taking down private ownership and giving the control to corporations, even if regulations then can easier be enforced. They would be called communist and fascist, and any political career would be over. However, circumvention of property law is not the same thing, so it enables many new way to control what previous was hard if not impossible.
- jasonwatkinspdx 13y agoSome of the highest precision CNC manufacturing equipment for particular processes is subject to nuclear non-proliferation arms controls as it can be used to make key components in uranium enrichment equipment. So for machines relevant to those laws, a GPS lowjack might be a sensible precaution. North Korea has been picking up this machinery from someone, so I can imagine Japanese industry and government being very paranoid on the issue.
- Cthulhu_ 13y ago> A subtly weakened or defective part from a big mill like the NV5000 might find its way into a vehicle or a high-speed machine, with disastrous consequences. Which is why - at least according to those awesome TV shows - parts in high-end vehicles and machines are checked via precise 3D measuring instruments as part of the quality control process. Just pointing that out. Pretty sure few companies fully trust CNC machines to deliver perfect results all the time.
- walshemj 13y agoYes thats why they have QA/Test departments where do you think the ISO9000 and BS5750 quality standards came from?
- bpizzi 13y agoSlightly off topic, but I'm working in that field, and those high-end CNC run nothing more elaborated than windows XP. They do ship some linux distro, but that's very seldom, much more than... windows nt4. The CNC must be reachable from the programmers computers as well as from the remote connections that manufacturers sells as maintenance. Needless to say, it's a nightmare for any decent CISO. Of course the CNC manufacturers' don't make it easy nor encourage the installation of third party securing tools. Very big companies spend a lot of time thinking on how to secure such machines on their network without touching the OS, and I've not yet heard of someone having found a simple and powerful securing policy (not involving a complex vlan implementation). The result is that, with some hacker abilities and a known target, one could worm its way threw the CNC OS of a lot of companies who don't know nor want to secure their network. If one fellow colleague working on the manufacturer side happen to read that comment, I would be happy to push the discussion further.
- ihnorton 13y agoSame for medical equipment. The Windows XP EOL is a major problem because all of this kit has been "certified" to run with XP, and re-certification is costly. There might be a market for a $50-100, two-port firewall/DMZ solution built on one of these ARM chips: http://www.freescale.com/webapp/sps/site/prod_summary.jsp?code=VF6xx http://www.freescale.com/webapp/sps/site/prod_summary.jsp?co... http://www.ti.com/product/am3357 http://www.ti.com/product/am3357 I have yet to find such a solution for sale.
- nknighthb 13y ago> a complex vlan implementation How exactly are they setting this up that it's complex? Isolated VLANs with VPN access are a routine solution to this kind of problem. A decent network engineer would probably have it done before you finish telling him what you want. (If instead of a decent network engineer, I had to do it, I'd just be finding the password for the switch I hadn't logged into for a year. The configuration would be done about 15 minutes later.)
- bpizzi 13y agoFrom my experience, there's a tremendous lack of decent network engineer in those companies (mechanical industry, family business, ...). Devil advocate: people in charge of IT stuff there are project or support guys, almost never network engineers. Either they don't care about serious security or they simply have no clue on how they should do it. And when they outsource their IT security, they're so bad at choosing that the solution implemented is worst than doing nothing. When I have the chance to chat with them about those subjects, the common position is almost always "we don't get why the machine manufacturer don't sells us a secured solution".
- jheriko 13y ago> Effectively, this means that machinists' shops can't rearrange their very expensive, very large tools to improve their workflow from job to job without getting permission from the manufacturer (which can take a month!), even if their own the gear. Have you ever seen such a workshop being rearranged? The people doing it might - for instance - not place the machine on a good enough quality of flooring, or they might be moving to a facility that is totally inappropriate (no good foundations) because they aren't talking to the right people and have a dim and naive view of machinery... Also my experience of such rearrangements is that they are not to improve workflow, but more usually to satisfy some new management type's desire to have an impact on the workplace. In short, I think this is prudent - it at least prevents a classic engineering management cock up - and protects the machine manufacturer from having their name tarnished by the sloppy practices of their customers. The case where people know what they are doing is the exception and not the case in my experience...
- freejack 13y agoTwo things: - a GPS lock can easily be defeated by the earnest with a GPS simulator, about a $2k fix. This isn't a great solution for the honest buyer, but anyone with ill intention could easily activate these in Kansas and re-export to a controlled state. (edit: a GPS sim can't help with the gyros, so maybe its a better "lock" than I originally reckoned ;-) - there are excellent "open-source" substitutes available. The Mechmate community is thriving (http://mechmate.com http://mechmate.com) and these plans make it possible for a DIYer to build their own 4 axis CNC with tolerances to a thousandth of an inch or better. My father-in-law is a a cabinet maker (http://woodforyou.net http://woodforyou.net) who built one of these for his business a few years ago, here's a demo video showing his results... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU3-6AapV3I http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lU3-6AapV3I (Edit 2: I wrote this before I had an appreciation for the difference between a CNC mill and a CNC router. The Mechmate is a CNC router and used for very different purposes than a CNC mill. Anyways, comment might still have some value for some. Sorry for the noise ;-)
- danielweber 13y agoThese aren't widgets sold to people on the street. These are very sophisticated buyers of extremely expensive stuff who can afford to pay someone to read the fine print.
- thejteam 13y agoI don't know about the one mentioned, but I've used very high end CNCs. The ones that I used are VERY carefully calibrated by the manufacturer on site. A slight change in the slope of the floor could throw the calibration off. They wouldn't want to spend time troubleshooting a problem caused by somebody moving the equipment. That said, we didn't have anything like a GPS on the thing that would shut it down if moved.
- wolfgke 13y agoThen better implement something like the "tainted mode" in the Linux kernel: if you load a closed-source (tainted) module, you can continue to use it, but the vendor (in this case the kernel developers) will refuse to give support.
- exarch 13y agoInformation wants to be free. Eventually, everyone who wants to know will know how to build a CNC machine like this, without any interlocks. If we've given up on growing up as a species, and now believe that humanity's only hope of survival is to limit the spread of information, then we're well and truly doomed. And, sadly, it's probably for the best. After all, who wants to live in a dystopian, nerfed society full of imprisoned intellects? Who wants a bunch of angry apes who're all one bad day from unleashing Armageddon loping around with warp engines and antimatter bombs and black hole generators? As a side note... reading the commentary on this story is both intriguing and disheartening. The "hacker" mentality that apologizes for, and is comforted by, this sort of manufacturer-imposed limitation on an owned product, this denial of the right to tinker, is a very different mentality than was common when I earned my stripes. Have legally-imposed culture changes like the DMCA really corrupted our community so much? Have constant, overblown reminders of the threat of terrorism rendered us so fearful of each other? Could an individual raised in a community with this mentality ever produce open, populist-enabling technologies, PGP and P2P and DeCSS and modchips? IP itself? Are we still hackers, or are we all just consumers, now?
- w_t_payne 13y agoInteresting attack vector ...