3 ms·
The difference between Francis and his predecessors is that he actually started a shakeup of internal structures, rather than keeping the debate on a purely the
by toyg 13y ago
The difference between Francis and his predecessors is that he actually started a shakeup of internal structures, rather than keeping the debate on a purely theological level. This is what "progressives" like. His two predecessors could talk a good game, but when chips were down they would invariably nominate dodgy ultra-conservatives to take care of finances and would use Vatican Council II as a fig leaf over a de-facto structural alliance with US-sponsored capitalism, because Cold War.
This Argentinian fellow has made some remarkable statements (on priest weddings, among other things), and if he follows through on them, the Church could change radically. He's also dismissed part of the old guard, promoting more "liberal" figures; among other things, he's finally admitted that the shady IOR (the Vatican bank) will have to clean up its act, and nominated new managers to do just that.
In terms of economic doctrine, I personally don't see much of a difference in what he's saying, compared to his European predecessors, but I admit I haven't studied this closely. What is clearly changed is the willingness to harshly criticise the North-American model. In a way, this guy is the first post-Cold-War pope; US donations are faltering (because of pedo scandals) so their political weight is diminishing inside the Church, and Bergoglio himself represents a South-American view of the world which is much more critical of traditional US policy in all sectors, including economic ones.
- einhverfr 13y agoI don't know about shaking up internal structures. Certainly in terms of who has been excommunicated, there has been no change. What he has done is moved the economic teachings from a branch of Catholic social teaching into a more central role. I think that's easy to understate. But that's not the same as taking a new position on the issues. And I think the liberals have vastly overstated the way in which Francis seems to be one of them (he has excommunicated a bishop for calling for the ordination of women for example). > "What is clearly changed is the willingness to harshly criticise the North-American model." I don't know. Rerum Novarium, Centicimus Annus, etc. all included similarly harsh language. That's not something I see as different. It's just that Popes were ignored when they said this. In fact John Paul II complained heavily that such criticism of Capitalism were ignored by so many Catholics.... > "Bergoglio himself represents a South-American view of the world which is much more critical of traditional US policy in all sectors, including economic ones." I think that's an important point actually, and I think it puts his attacks on independent retirement as poisonous fruits of capitalism (i.e. a society that "throws away old people") in a certain context. But the corrolary here is that he has legitimated Dorothy Day's withering attack on Social Security and thus attacking causes even more dear to the American left than abortion.