4 ms·
I don't really know what the fuss is about since the simplest solution is the most obvious one. Masking should be optional, it should be enabled by default and
by huhtenberg 17y ago
I don't really know what the fuss is about since the simplest solution is the most obvious one. Masking should be optional, it should be enabled by default and controlled by the checkbox next to the entry field.
- mhansen 17y agoThat's the simplest solution in terms of people, but it adds another layer of complexity to whatever technology you're working with.
- ErrantX 17y agoNot if the browsers implement it (which seems the best solution)
- pclark 17y agosounds awful. So now you're putting a checkbox next to any password field? Designers have to be aware that in some browsers there'll be a checkbox next to password fields.
- dchest 17y agoHow a tiny button inside the password field like the "Browse" or "Choose file" in file upload field?
- pavel_lishin 17y agoThat button isn't tiny, and is in fact very obtrusive. It makes creating designs and layouts hard enough as it is, and the file dialog isn't even used very often. I'm pretty sure you can implement something like this on the web with some simple javascript, dynamically changing the input type from "text" to "password" and vice versa.
- calcnerd256 17y ago...thereby breaking the semantics of the password input type. If it's going to be changed by Javascript, it should be a CSS style called "masked" or something.
- dchest 17y agoI mean, tiny button. Not a huge button that is used by file upload field. Something like this: http://i30.tinypic.com/34f0knt.png http://i30.tinypic.com/34f0knt.png Or you can put this option in menu or status bar or whatever. By the way, I don't understand your complaints about design and layouts. I've never had problems with designing forms. Maybe this is because I didn't try to replace native controls with some uber-fancy things? (which is a good thing)
- ErrantX 17y agocheckbox? if the broswer implements it you dont need a checkbox (icon in the field, menu option, context menu option - plenty of neater ways to implement it than a checkbox)
- wmeredith 17y agoIck. Since you don't see what all the fuss is about, you're going to put another doodad between your user and conversion. Ask an online business that does any sort of volume at all: this is bad. Web forms are where the usability rubber hits the road online. When adding an item to your form you should always be of the mind set that this extra step (optional or not) will lose you conversions, but you have to have it because of X. This forces you to justify placing item X, which in this case is the unmask password option. Is having an option to unmask the password field going to gain you more conversions than not? I have no data, just anecdotes and experience, but those all tell me no. Putting a check box next to the entry field is putting GUI decisions on your user because you can't figure it out, and it will lose you conversions. EDIT: Re-reading this it sounds like personal attack on the OC. It's not. I'm using the universal you.
- zcrar70 17y agoThere is no 'universal you' - but there is 'one', which exists for exactly that purpose...