2 ms·
> Thought experiment: what could that disruptive niche be? Someone needs to write/buy a search engine and then build a really rich API into the internals of it
by erikpukinskis 13y ago
> Thought experiment: what could that disruptive niche be?
Someone needs to write/buy a search engine and then build a really rich API into the internals of it that lets 3rd parties write customized search engines. How about an auto parts search engine, or a search engine for spanish-speaking people living in southern california? What about a Christian search engine, or a meme search engine?
When someone can empower 3rd party developers to make the same kinds of decisions as Google does, but with different tradeoffs, and they really put the full institution behind supporting that, I think:
A) Google will have a hard time competing because they won't be able to give the personal attention to the needs of what is, effectively, a community of modmakers.
B) This new company will capture the long tail of search. Only a sliver of that is covered right now, with a scattering of niche search engines (Google Scholar, etc).
C) The number of users could be VERY large. It could be the cable to Google's broadcast television.
D) Getting started wouldn't require any massive technological achievements. Just find an underserved niche where even a really really stupid search engine would work better than Google. Write it, figure out how to make money off it it, grow. Start with something that requires only a small index. Slowly expand into additional niches according to what will help keep the company and the tech moving forward.
Google's bet is that any information you can glean from someone coming to a niche search engine can be reasonably approximated with contextual information in the query. That's proved true for many queries, but the key is to find the queries where it's really not.
- Isofarro 13y agoSounds like Yahoo Boss: http://developer.yahoo.com/boss/ http://developer.yahoo.com/boss/ And that's been around for years already. Essentially, you get the Yahoo results, and decorate, filter, reorganise, improve, combine as you wish. So you get the organic results, which you can then innovate upon. And it has survived the transition from Yahoo-powered search results, to Bing powered search results: http://searchengineland.com/yahoo-boss-moves-from-yahoos-index-to-microsofts-adds-pay-structure-64140 http://searchengineland.com/yahoo-boss-moves-from-yahoos-ind... Which means you have API access to the second most-used search engine in the industry. So what better way to voice your discontent with Google by supporting a competitor. Running a successful search engine is expensive, it needs continuous investment into R&D. That's why Yahoo took a step back and partnered with Bing instead. The level of investment needed just to hold status quo with the existing market runs into billions of dollars a year, something Yahoo baulked at. Microsoft, however, were still strongly inclined to invest that every year.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoIt's a step in this direction, yes. But doesn't seem to allow you to do write your own indexing, ranking, and querying algorithms, which is the kind of thing I'm talking about.
- nashequilibrium 13y agoYahoo screwed up so bad here, read the research papers coming out of labs.yahoo.com back then and you realize they were onto knowledgraph before Google and actually had a head start, but they shattered their research division and lost a lot of those search people to microsoft and google. They just didn't have faith to create their own path and also lost their identity by deciding to become an entertainment company.
- saurik 13y agohttp://aws.typepad.com/aws/2005/12/alexa_web_searc.html http://aws.typepad.com/aws/2005/12/alexa_web_searc.html