6 ms·
Life After Amazon
- kawsper 13y ago> ... because it had effectively become a “showroom” for Internet retailers—people would see books in the store and then buy them online. Which is what all the real-life stores are facing right now. I don't claim to have the solution, but I tend to buy in stores because I enjoy to have my product today, with better service in terms of refund policies, and that I can talk with a human being face-to-face if the thing is faulty. I live in Denmark where we have pretty good consumer protection, I suspect the difference between Amazon and a store in the US might be a lot different.
- w1ntermute 13y agoIME, Amazon US's customer service has never been an issue.
- lostlogin 13y agoDitto for New Zealand.
- blazespin 13y agoThe solution is that they should (at least in part) become showrooms for Internet Retailers and manufacturers pay them to show off their merchandise.
- dsr_ 13y agoStaples -- one of the largest surviving brick-and-mortar chains -- announced recently that they were going to reduce the size of their stores, reduce the number of types of products carried on shelves, and (unspoken) focus on their web business. If you're buying a known product, there's no reason to go to a store except immediate availability.
- kybernetikos 13y ago> because it had effectively become a “showroom” for Internet retailers—people would see books in the store and then buy them online. I think there might be room for some retail outlets to embrace this. You could imagine a bookshop that was an amazon affiliate, stuck QR codes with their affiliate link to the book over all of the barcodes, had a nice cafe and environment for browsing the large numbers of books they have in stock, but don't actually sell any themselves. They could even arrange to be close to an amazon drop/warehouse so you could get things delivered super fast to the store itself for a small convenience fee.
- harpastum 13y agoAmazon is partially targeting this using its Amazon Source program: https://source.amazon.com/#/welcome https://source.amazon.com/#/welcome . At this point it's only for kindle books (not physically shipping), but booksellers get paid for ebooks that customers buy.
- pyoung 13y agoHmm, seems like this could be useful for more than just books. I bought some camping gear from amazon, and I recall that my biggest hesitation was not being able to evaluate the physical product, and therefore unsure of the construction quality. The Amazon reviews help a lot, but I was still left with some uncertainty. Realistically, the amazon income is much too small for a business to be viable. I think the commissions are around 5-10%, whereas the traditional retail markup is around 50%. Seems like there is too big of a gap there to make things work, even if using this business model resulted in lower storage and stocking costs for the retail outfit.
- _delirium 13y agoAnother factor in Denmark is that Amazon's convenience and prices are not as good as in the US. There's no amazon.dk, so you have to order from .co.uk or .de, which makes the order take 3-4 days. And it costs ~$10 to ship one book! (No free shipping on international orders.) The only case in which I consider it worth it is when I can find a book used on Amazon Marketplace for >$20 below list price. But since the Amazon UK/DE marketplaces have worse used selection than Amazon US Marketplace, that's also not that frequent.
- tzs 13y agoThere was a story a year or two or so ago about a bookstore in Boston (I believe, although it might have been some other major East Coast city) that managed to turn things around on Amazon. They bought a high quality book-on-demand printer that can print and then very nicely bind a book in a few minutes, and that is backed by a very large catalog of books. They put in convenient computers so that customers could use Amazon from right in the store to search for books and read reviews. The customers could go home and order from Amazon, of course, or they could buy from the bookstore, and then go have a drink or snack in the in-store coffee shop while their book was printed.
- dredmorbius 13y agoOddly: I reverse-showroom often. I'll research purchases online, make them in stores. Possibly old school. There's a greater convenience and generally far better returns policy. And there's now a #surveillancestate argument. I don't know if it was Jacob Applebaum's recent C3SO talk or elsewhere, but the story was of a security-conscious hacker who's taken to walking into an arbitrary storefront for his electronic purchases to avoid having it intercepted and backdoors installed by the spooks.
- cdcarter 13y agoPlus, you can choose to support local vendors run by community members, or who have less oppressive employment practices.
- fps 13y agoAmazon's return policy is amazing. They give actual refunds instead of store credit, cover return shipping, and there's never any open box/restocking fee. Stores frequently require arguments, pleading, or the threat of a credit card chargeback to properly accept returns. I buy from Amazon specifically because I know what I'm getting.
- dredmorbius 13y agoI've never been chatted up by a pretty girl whilst browsing the electronic shelves at Amazon.
- mindslight 13y ago> I can talk with a human being face-to-face if the thing is faulty In the US, most "customer service" people are actually just human-looking facades for a computer system. Of course there are shining exceptions who apply their brain and even have domain knowledge. But most of the time dealing with a "person" actually takes more work than directly with the computer as you've got to prepare your request carefully. Companies wanted workers to be interchangeable cogs, and they got what they wished for.
- nicholassmith 13y agoIt's an interesting problem space, I actually quite like retail as I grew up around it and it's fascinating as it's constantly under threat so what do you do to push on. Beating Amazon prices is almost impossible, unless you like to work for free, but it does seem there's a push towards smaller independents that don't need to compete on price as they sell an experience. There will always be people willing to pay a little extra for a perceived value, and always people who'll try and find the best price possible. I have nothing but respect for people willing to follow their principles, but Amazon is here to stay and contains a huge customer base so leaving is cutting your nose off to spite your face. Work out what you can do better than Amazon to earn your premium, there's plenty of places to go with it.
- alan_cx 13y ago"so leaving is cutting your nose off to spite your face." Well, according to the article..... "It has been nearly two years since the Amazon decision and I can proudly report that our company is still alive, well, and prospering. Our direct-selling division has recorded seven consecutive months of year-over-year growth, and new sales force hires are up 25% over last year as well. And, thanks to our loyal retail customers, we recorded the largest ever sales month in the history of that division in October—and we did it without Amazon!" .... clearly not.
- rayhano 13y agoIf what is relayed in this story is factual (most intent to purchase a book, discovery, happens offline), then surely bookshops still have a lot of power a should refuse to stock books distributed on Amazon. It's not realistic, but would be an interesting controlled experiment.
- huxley 13y agoI can't imagine the Big Six publishers are eager to cross Amazon after the last run-in with the DoJ
- nowarninglabel 13y agoIt's not without hypocrisy, that a company in the educational book publishing industry can complain of unfair business practices, while knowing that the industry is responsible for $200 textbooks. Textbooks that are not only $200, but where publishers have given kickbacks to professors to ensure they require a new version every 2 - 4 years, so generations to come will continue to pay $200. While this particular publisher, EDC, may only be publishing children's education books and not textbooks, it has to understand the absurdity of such a one-sided argument. I for one applaud Amazon, celebrate Amazon, for making it so I could afford to work myself through college buying cheap used textbooks rather than being forcefully impoverished by the publishing industry's duplicitous actions.
- IBM 13y agoGreat straw man.
- nashequilibrium 13y agoIn my first yr, the accounting 1 professor released a new book each year, so the book i got from a friend the yr before was useless and I remember being pissed about that. He would change it up, add new tutorials and change up the workbook that goes along with it. Nobody ever questioned it but we all thought that was not right.
- dredmorbius 13y agoWithout absolving the textbook industry (prices are nuts, have been for ages, dig up Supreme Court Justice Stephens' essay on the topic from the 1960s/1970s), this is in some ways a problem of the market-capitalist system. It's similar to the issues of equitable pay, automation, labor displacement, and business models for the arts, music, newspapers, and publishing in general. Oh, and this little thing called software. In order to produce material, a certain amount of resources are necessary. The mechanism we've adopted for allocating those resources is the market. For much of present production, the fixed costs of production are high -- writing a book (particularly a textbook) is a large initial investment. Same goes for software. The marginal costs of production are low -- hell, you can download a 400 page text off of Project Gutenberg or stream a movie in a few seconds with a decent broadband connection. Amortize the costs of your laptop (a few hundred dollars for a basic model, a grand or two for high end), less for tablets or eBook readers), and a broadband subscription, and it's still cheap. Textbooks generally do have to be updated every so often, though annual revisions are pretty ridiculous, and much of the industry is a fat scam, especially where the professor teaches from his own text. Rental schemes, "authorization codes" (required to access other materials), and the like factor into this as well -- they're akin to various tack-on fees for air travel. And there's a whole burgeoning movement for producing DIY book scanners and the like (pretty fascinating, do a quick DDG search or hit up Fixyt.com for videos). One thing I've come to realize about many commercial opportunities is that they require a control and toll-taking point. Revision updates, exercise questions, registrations, rentals, and the like, all create an arbitrary tollgate. Great for the publisher, for the student, not so much. And the model requires that for a new or continued revenue stream, new books have to be published. I'm beginning to strongly suspect this is a market failure -- of externalities (the educational value of those books benefits more than just the reader) and perverse incentives. The question is: what's the better way? Online we've been experimenting with vastly democratized publishing, and the result is Upworthy, Buzzfeed, HuffPo, and numerous other viral sites, which with time are finding their way into my hosts file with '0.0.0.0' entries, and search-engine blocklists. It leads to what Clay Shirky recognizes as a problem, not of data overload, but of filter failure. There's also the problem within the publishing world, including academic publishing, of so much material being produced that not only is it not possible to keep up with it, even within a discipline or sub-specialty, but that good content is getting buried. That's the real tragedy of broken filters -- not the crap spewing everywhere, but the gold nuggets that don't float up.
- cgrubb 13y agoAn interesting claim in the article is that Amazon isn't doing its fair share of helping people discover books. The primary source of the research doesn't appear to be public. An excerpt from a July 2013 Salon article: According to survey research by the Codex Group, roughly 60 percent of book sales — print and digital — now occur online. But buyers first discover their books online only about 17 percent of the time. Internet booksellers specifically, including Amazon, account for just 6 percent of discoveries. Where do readers learn about the titles they end up adding to the cart on Amazon? In many cases, at bookstores. Why couldn't we be told what percentage of books are discovered in physical bookstores? The idea that 83% of books are not discovered online seems wild. Who did the Codex Group survey? http://www.salon.com/2013/07/19/amazon_could_be_a_victim_of_its_own_success/ http://www.salon.com/2013/07/19/amazon_could_be_a_victim_of_...
- crucifiction 13y agoProbably because that number is actually less or equivalent, otherwise I am guessing they would have published the number. I would posit that most people find books not through stores, online or physical, but through friends/family reccomendations or television (e.g. Oprah driving book sales).
- WalterBright 13y agoI've discovered many interesting books by simply buying a large box of random used scifi books from ebay.
- hga 13y agoWell, Amazon sure tries, and I've certainly benefited from "People who bought/looked at/whatever the book your're looking at/bought also liked" selections. And if I have a topic I want to come up to speed on, I've found it pretty good for that, when combined with its invaluable reviews. And echoing user crucifiction in another reply to your posting, I can make the very best book recommendations for the friends I know well. If word of mouth, amplified to the Nth degree by the net, is still powerful, then a simple "what fraction does what" metric may not tell us very much, except for methods with negligible share.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoIt has always been an interesting discussion as to which was better, wide reach or focused sales. If you get an MBA you'll spend a few weeks talking about the pros and cons. In the case of an established vendor, with an accessible set of target buyers, controlling the channel is generally considered the right choice, and when you can't easily talk to all of your potential customers, generally a wider sales channel is merited. "baby books" (which is the market here) are actually mostly sold to pre-schools and other child care facilities so its pretty straight forward to sell them one on one. Contrast that with programming books where your choices are a programming class, or Amazon. The other shoe is of course going to be tablet books. Which we'll have to see where those land. I've not seen them yet but I expect at some point one of these $39 tablet vendors is going to try a largely indestructible tablet which can be used to entertain/educate toddlers. Something with that plastic e-ink display technology which was show with a person slamming a shoe on it while it worked. Something like that is going to hurt Edubooks if they can survive longer than the paper/cardboard form for a lower net cost.
- AJ007 13y agoA market I have found very interesting is pen & paper role playing games. There has been an explosion of self-published content in the past three to five years. A good portion of it quite high quality, often coming from authors who previously had written titles for "big" publishers (Even in its glory days TSR was hardly a titan.) The channels users are both finding out about these self published RPGs and purchasing them is not Amazon. Instead it starts with blogs, forums, Kickstarter, and Indiegogo, and is sold directly on the author's website, through Lulu, and Drivethrustuff (RPGNow etc.) I was pleasantly surprised to see Wizards offering old Dungeons and Dragons books on RPGNow. Other "big" publishers have been doing the same. As an unknown underdog, you want scale and recognition over paltry margins. Amazon does this for unknown authors by providing mass market distribution. The author still needs to get some initial traction, but the author never loses sales because the consumer couldn't find the book, or didn't have time to travel to the store while he or she was ready to turn over money in exchange for an unknown book. Bookstores and publishers are the losers here. They are middlemen who do distribution and scaling using methods from the pre-Internet era. As more content becomes digital only it is hard to see retail stores faring well. That may be an understatement, considering that this trend has been well underway for a decade. For now I'm positive on the prospects for retail clothing stores.
- gumby 13y agoI also consider Amazon predatory and find my products elsewhere. Usually it is more convenient for me to shop locally (but I don't live in the sticks) and even when not, I try to get locally or else a smaller, specialized vendor. But I have friends who operate small businesses and use Amazon for fulfilment. Their shops appear integrated into Amazon, so this distinction is no longer clear. With books, however, the distinction is clear and so if I do recommend a book to someone I ask them not to buy it online but instead to get it from a small independent bookshop. Amazon: a moment of convenience, but a lifetime of regret.
- Taek 13y ago" But buyers first discover their books online only about 17% of the time." Buying merchandise online is often far more convenient and less expensive than buying merchandise in the store. But discovering products is much more convenient when you can handle it, read the first chapter, etc. Brick-and-mortar storefronts may become outlets for marketing. Instead of making their money by generating sales, they make their money by charging book owners to have a copy on the shelves. Customers get the convenience of discovery, bookstores stay in business, and authors get their material out into the world. Online retail is probably going to change the way we consume goods over the next decade in larger ways than it already has.
- bryanlarsen 13y agoI'm willing to bet that bookstores would be willing to give more prominent placement to books which aren't available at Amazon, as well as steering customers towards those books when they ask for recommendations.
- larrys 13y ago"to give more prominent placement to books which aren't available at Amazon" Ask any "old timer" about how "stereos" used to be sold. At the start there were specialized shops (and of course there still are but "back then" that was the channel) where you went to get a stereo and got knowledgeable advice and good service. Then mass retail came about and all those good brands (that could) just went mass retail and forgot about all those small fokesy sales channels. Once again, because they could and someone dangled the opportunity. This happened with Apple as well which (as all computers were) was originally offered through small computer stores. My point is giving prominent placement is great but don't assume that if something becomes popular it won't automatically go where the money and opportunity is and quickly forget the people who first gave it an opportunity (mainly because new sales people get hired that aren't rewarded for the past loyalty).
- sam-mueller 13y agoFTA: "But, for all intents and purposes, Amazon does not make money" This is a very myopic view on Amazon's current business model. They are choosing to break even/lose money in exchange for growth. They use profits to expand their business and break into new markets, which is evidenced by initiatives like Kindle Fire and Amazon Instant Video. At any time, Amazon could change this growth strategy, and profits would flow like the Niagra. Investors understand, and that is why their valuation is sky high at over 150x future price to earnings.
- nostromo 13y agoThis publisher was selling books at a high price point to schools and a low price point to Amazon. Then, when the school discovered this, they bought them through Amazon. Umm, duh? Alternative title suggestion: Amazon made it hard for us to fleece schools.
- pingswept 13y agoI don't think that the pricing structure you describe is mentioned in the article. Maybe the books were the same retail price in both cases and the school chose Amazon because (for example) it made the accounting easier. Kind of weakens your argument, I think.
- baddox 13y agoNot really. It's perfectly reasonable for the school to choose the better seller, whether the advantage is price, shipping speed, ease of accounting, etc.
- hollowworld 13y ago"Amazon is a charity". You should do charity on your money. You are not supposed to steal it from other people give it to people and get a good name out of it. I don't see any difference between microsoft giving IE for free and this. This is a cut throat competition. They just don't know to play fair. This country always butchers petty thiefs and lets powerfull people escape with anything. Like people like king.
- pmr_ 13y agoOne interesting thing I learned from this article is that the US does not have a VAT, but a sales tax on a state level. It took me a while to understand this as most countries in Europe usually have only a VAT on the nation state level. I guess the US system does have some benefits but it seems shockingly insufficient in the face of online retailers. Wikipedia also tells me that there have been pushes to introduce a national VAT in the US, but they have failed. To me that only seems to have benefits: less administration, less rules, less loopholes. Could someone outline the arguments against it?
- showerst 13y agoIn the US it's actually more insane, we can also have different sales taxes at the county (a smaller administrative unit w/in states, there are a few thousand of them nationwide), and the city level. We also have different tax rates on different kinds of products (restaurants vs clothes vs gas, for example.) This reasoning behind this is giving individual areas the flexibility to tax based on their individual needs, so a county could vote to raise sales taxes for (X) years to fund a new high school or something. I believe they usually do this by other methods (like bonds), but want to keep taxes as an option. I live in Washington DC, which is tiny and close to 2 other states, so there are days when I can end up going to DC, MD, and VA and buying food and gas, so I pay 6 different tax rates in the same day. It's all transparent to me of course, and most people only pay attention to income taxes when they think about moving somewhere.
- aestra 13y ago>a sales tax on a state level Some states have taxes, some don't. Some states allow cities or counties to have taxes, some don't. Some tax different items differently. Most places have no tax on food in grocery stores, but tax restaurants (as it is a service). One city can tax clothes, but one does not, etc. For example, in New York City, there is a small tax on most/all (a fraction of a percent) taxable items to fund the mass transit system there, the MTA. Some places make up for lack of/lower sales tax by larger property taxes, or other types of taxes (lotteries, etc...) High tourist areas can tax things like rental cars and hotels. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_taxes_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_taxes_in_the_United_State... I think it's more part of the United States culture, with things being done on a more local level. It's in the long run, confusing.
- rahimnathwani 13y ago"Our direct-selling division has recorded seven consecutive months of year-over-year growth, and new sales force hires are up 25% over last year as well. And, thanks to our loyal retail customers, we recorded the largest ever sales month in the history of that division in October—and we did it without Amazon!" Huh? The direct sales division and retail division each increased sales after they stopped selling via Amazon. That's what you'd expect, as long as _some_ of your would-be Amazon sales turn into direct/retail sales. It would be more interesting to know if their overall sales have gone up.