4 ms·
"Crichton had little patience for scientists' complaints about ridiculous sci-fi plots and wild scientist stereotyping. In a 1999 lecture before the annual meet
by tokenadult 17y ago
"Crichton had little patience for scientists' complaints about ridiculous sci-fi plots and wild scientist stereotyping. In a 1999 lecture before the annual meeting of the American Association for the Advancement of Science, he countered such gripes with his own perspective on why scientists will probably never be very happy with the products of Hollywood. As Crichton advised, there are at least four important rules of movies that just don't mesh with the real process of research: '(i) Movie characters must be compelled to act. (ii) Movies need villains. (iii) Movie searches are dull. (iv) Movies must move.' Crichton argued that real science, with its long, drawn-out intellectual processes and frequent dead ends, simply can't be reconciled with such exigencies. 'The problems lie with the limitations of film as a visual storytelling medium,' he concluded. 'You aren't going to beat it.'"
The other important message of this article is that being smart doesn't prevent people from having mistaken ideas about science. Smart people can fall for plausible but scientifically incorrect statements about topics debated about in politics, because not all people, and not even all smart people, devote much time to examining evidence and making sure that conclusions are supported by evidence.
- DannoHung 17y agoPfft, Michael Chrichton was a hack that liked to write adventure books in a shiny techno jacket. Which is to say that it's more than possible to make a compelling film based on plausible science, but it's not going to be an adventure story.
- koepked 17y ago...not all people, and not even all smart people, devote much time to examining evidence and making sure that conclusions are supported by evidence. I'm extremely guilty of this, and it bothers me. But what bothers me more is knowing how much time and effort would be required from me to be capable of making evidence-backed claims about everything I'm interested in. You make time for what's important to you, and the truth is definitely important to me, but so is family, building my django skills, learning Scheme, reading GEB, considering ideas for a possible startups... The choice then is what/who to trust, the majority of scientists? The smartest ones (identified how?)? My own perceptions and ideas? The government-backed scientists? Sceince suffers because people don't have time for it, and because they can't necessarily trust those who do.