5 ms·
Note: this is satire. Not the good kind of satire, but satire nonetheless.
by minimaxir 13y ago
Note: this is satire. Not the good kind of satire, but satire nonetheless.
- steveklabnik 13y agoGenerally speaking, satire is used to mock the powers that be: > Satire is a genre of literature, and sometimes graphic and performing arts, > in which vices, follies, abuses, and shortcomings are held up to ridicule, > ideally with the intent of shaming individuals, corporations, and society > itself, into improvement. Although satire is usually meant to be humorous, > its greater purpose is often constructive social criticism, using wit as a > weapon and as a tool to draw attention to both particular and wider issues in > society. > > Historically, satire has satisfied the popular need to debunk and ridicule the > leading figures in politics, economy, religion and other prominent realms > of power. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satire http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satire This is often summarized as "punch up, not down." Therefore, this isn't satire. This is a person who is a part of the aforementioned group in power attempting to mock those who would be employing satire as a means of critique. Satire would be an essay written by a non-tech person, in the voice of a tech person, in order to lambast what tech is doing to San Francisco. To make this more concrete: I just moved to the Mission, and now commute to SOMA. You can pretty much extrapolate everything else out from there. This blog post is like me writing one laughing at all the people staring at the Google Bus, but satire would be one making fun of me.
- minimaxir 13y agoI should have included a source :P https://twitter.com/bgoldberg/status/419177954631901184 https://twitter.com/bgoldberg/status/419177954631901184
- azernik 13y agoUmmm... where in that definition does it say that only one side in a social dispute is allowed to call its mockery "satire"? It says "shaming individuals, corporations, and even society", not "shaming The Man". Say you disagree with it and think it's obnoxious if that's what you feel, instead of making up definitional disputes to hide behind.
- steveklabnik 13y agoI think the power dynamics are pretty clear in this situation. If you really, really, really want to claim that the tech crowd is being trampled by everyone else in the Bay Area, I'm not sure we're going to be able to come to any kind of reasonable discussion.
- theorique 13y agoIn this case, it's using satirical attacks to mock those mobilizing collective/people power who are attacking low-level people in the SF tech community. The people riding the Google Bus may have a few creature comforts and make a nice middle-class salary, but they aren't powerful billonaires.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoThe problem with this definition is that it assumes that a person seems politics as a struggle between the powerful and powerless. I would say good satire is satire that correctly mocks an argument or action that is wrong, hypocritical, etc. now matter who is saying/doing it. In this case, it is mocking people who claim that people in tech (A) don't deserve their salaries and (B) shouldn't be spending them the way they are. Both these criticisms are unreasonable (although not necessarily for the reasons given in the article) and deserve to be made fun of. First, all salaries are a matter between the employer and employee. There is no other basis for deciding what salary is fair. Something similar applies to lifestyle choice. How people decide to spend their money is not anyone else's business. The attitude of "I'm privileged so you can say anything about me, and I have to interpret it as valid criticism" is not reasonable.
- j2kun 13y agoI think the appropriate term is caricature.