3 ms·
The justification is not obvious to me. Could you explain in careful detail? Please start by listing any necessary moral premises. For example, collective guil
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
The justification is not obvious to me. Could you explain in careful detail?
Please start by listing any necessary moral premises. For example, collective guilt, individual freedom, and how to determine which collectives these principles apply to (assuming of course that these principles are what underlies your position). In the US there are 2^{300 million} possible collectives, but you seem to have it narrowed down to 1. How?
I didn't claim that it was self contradicting because it was non-libertarian. I claimed that it seemed contradictory without further explanation because early on she appeals to individualism (when it benefits women making her particular life choices) but later on appeals to collective responsibility (when it benefits women making her particular life choices).
There might be some consistent underlying principle and it might not be contradictory. I just can't figure out what it is, which is why I asked the question.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]