2 ms·
Having the ability to produce heavy machinery IS a strategic need. The military will not let all those factories go under because it wants to ensure the domest
by ars 13y ago
Having the ability to produce heavy machinery IS a strategic need.
The military will not let all those factories go under because it wants to ensure the domestic ability to produce military equipment.
It's expensive though, you either pay factories to exist but not do anything, or you build unneeded machines, or you figure out how to make a "modular" factory that can be converted in a time of need.
- lmm 13y agoIf the military needs some factories, why don't they buy some factories, and run them as profitably as they can? Buying stuff they don't need from contractors is a strange, inefficient way to keep industrial capacity if that's what they really want.
- ars 13y agoIt's not strange at all. First the military is a military, it's not a contractor. It's just not what they do. Additionally privatization is usually pretty efficient. Among other things it also lets the factory owners do other things with the factory which can bring cost savings. And finally one of the unwritten goals of the military is the economy.
- Jtsummers 13y ago> Additionally privatization is usually pretty efficient. By some measures of efficiency. It also means that the military can't do in-theater activities they used to do. They can barely cook their own meals anymore. That said, they have no real role in the manufacture of systems other than as customers and future maintainers, that's where the private industry belongs. State-side, many bases are guarded by private contractors who had (for a time, this changed) the physical fitness requirement of having a pulse. Aircraft maintenance is a combination of public (military run depots, mostly staffed by a combination of civil servants and contractors) and private (NG or Boeing or whoever run facilities). Both have issues, but the latter is quite effective at lobbying to continue to get their incentive pay even after destroying an aircraft [1]. I'll note, FOD damage occurs at military run depots as well. But they don't get their incentive pay for destroying an aircraft, they risk being put at the top of the next BRAC list. [1] http://defensetech.org/2012/01/27/a-basic-mistake-that-trashed-a-jstars/ http://defensetech.org/2012/01/27/a-basic-mistake-that-trash...
- deelowe 13y agoThe government has near infinite resources. I don't think time, capex, or opex factors into these decisions. Whether or not the CEO of that hot new military contractor donated to your campaign or is a relative certainly does though. Also, there's a lot less legal liability when going through a contractor. I'm convinced that's why blackwater became Xe services, which became Academi. It's a lot easier to shut down a business and start anew than it is to change internal government operations.
- chiph 13y agoThis actually happened when they brought the Iowa-class battleships out of mothballs in the 80's. They found out that the 16" guns needed to be re-barreled. In order to make new ones, they'd either have to have them made in places like Japan or Germany (ironic, eh?), or rebuild a significant portion of the US steel industry (they had gone to mini-mills, which can't produce a forging that size). Luckily they found some in a warehouse left over from WW-II.