4 ms·
You can't train someone to be good at something they fundamentally don't want to do, and you can't train them to be passionate. I've been hacking since middle s
by freehunter 13y ago
You can't train someone to be good at something they fundamentally don't want to do, and you can't train them to be passionate. I've been hacking since middle school, and I'm a terrible programmer, even after a couple dozen programming classes ranging from Visual Basic to C++. Anyone would be able to see this within five minutes of talking to me. Fortunately, programming isn't what I do for a living (at least not today). I'm much more interested in breaking things than building things.
The point is, if you want to understand how computers work, you'll put in the time and effort and experimentation that's required to learn that. And you'll be better for the experience. If you aren't comfortable experimenting with your computer, you won't have the experience of doing something really cool with it. You won't have the experience needed to understand at an innate level what is going on. I couldn't explain half of what I know about computers. It's just simple familiarity. It can't easily be taught except through trial and error and experience.
Give a man a fish, teach a man to fish, or give a man a fishing pole and let the man figure out how to fish on his own. Which one embodies the hacker spirit more?
- rayiner 13y agoYou're making a basic logical mistake, which is that the fact that someone didn't hack in middle school means that they wouldn't enjoy being a programmer. That's a logical hole that let's a lot of sexism through. It enshrines a status quo where we consider it acceptable to have dramatically fewer women in the profession simply because of gendered socialization at earlier stages of education.
- freehunter 13y agoI never stated that, or even implied it. I'm not the original person you were talking to though. I actually stated that just because you do something in middle school doesn't mean you'll be good at it later on (I'm not a good programmer, remember?). I'm just saying you're missing the point. The point is, passion can't be taught, only encouraged. People hacking since middle school are probably passionate about it. That doesn't make them better than someone who became passionate in college, minus the decade head-start. It's not about teaching people to become programmers, it's about getting people interested in experimenting and learning on their own.
- varelse 13y agoI agree 100% that you can't teach passion - that has to come from within. However, we certainly can do awfully better at encouraging that passion when it emerges rather than dutifully stuffing it back in the bottle and turning a promising college career right back into the pursuit of an MRS(tm) degree. And if that takes a degree of well-meaning but mostly awkward affirmative action until the majority of brogrammers have either retired or drank/snorted/driven themselves to destruction, that's just the price of changing the status quo IMO. I used to think otherwise, and all of these heavy-handed efforts to pull women into Computer Science once made me roll my eyes at their ineffectiveness, but all I had to do was listen to how a lot of my younger co-workers still judge women. Same $h!+ new decade alas...