3 ms·
I will readily admit I don't fully understand the whole thing, but can't find a reasonable and non-partisan explanation anywhere (I'm not British and not even f
by bambax 13y ago
I will readily admit I don't fully understand the whole thing, but can't find a reasonable and non-partisan explanation anywhere (I'm not British and not even from an English-speaking country).
What are those facts exactly? If it's just something implemented by ISPs, how is Cameron's government implied?
What I understand is that the British government made it compulsory for all ISPs in the UK to implement that filter, and make it "opt-out", and left it to ISPs to decide the lists of things to "filter".
If that's the case then yes, it is a abomination.
If ISPs are somehow free to make it opt-in or opt-out it's less worse but still not good.
(And of course I have no problem with parents wanting to filter things on their home network if they so choose).
- IanCal 13y ago> What are those facts exactly? If it's just something implemented by ISPs, how is Cameron's government implied? Cameron has pushed the ISPs to make some form of parental filtering either default on, or what's called "active choice" (which is where it doesn't default to anything, you have to explicitly choose filtering or no filtering). This basically amounts to you getting two options when ordering for the first time, filter (and then options on what to filter) or no filter. There's an example of the signup screen for BT here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-25400009 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-25400009 This is not a legal requirement, nor is it compulsory. There are no new laws, that's very important to remember. Not all ISPs are implementing it, though the major ones are. A&A's stance is that your active choice is "if you want filtering by your ISP, don't buy our stuff". There is no particular filtering tech they're required to use, each ISP may use their own settings/lists of sites/etc.