7 ms·
Opinion: U.S. Military Aircraft Fly Toward A Waterfall
- pilom 13y agoI worked for one of the big defense contractors until recently. One of the most enlightening things I got to see while there was a tour of the F-18 assembly line. While the fear about what would happen to the jobs and the facility after the end of production was palatable, it was amazing to see the facility. The challenges faced by big assembly line manufacturing were so foreign to me coming from a computer programming background. For instance while as a programmer, my bugs might crash a computer, for them, an unused rivet hiding in the bottom of an engine might clog a fuel line and crash a plane. Made me appreciate the manufactured goods in my life more.
- Spearchucker 13y agoIt's an educational experience for sure, and has some bearing on how we build software. Imagine using scrum to develop an F18. Or a heart monitor you strap to your wide to monitor your kid's heart beat during labour. How stable or even coherent would Excel be if it was built using eXtreme Programming?
- icebraining 13y agoYes, but the hypothetical wife wouldn't ask for the monitor to be improved with new features. While she was in labour.
- Spearchucker 13y agoShe'd be asking(?) for drugs, you're right. However the hapless father who can't do anything but look on would.
- bane 13y agoWhat's interesting is that in the early days of the jet age, fast protyping and testing was the norm when designing new aircraft. The dozens of experimental planes from that age are fascinating stuff.
- Spearchucker 13y agoPrototyping is a technique that addresses some of the shortfalls in waterfall. Amusingly, other than names for things there is nothing new in agile methodologies like scrum and XP. They've been around since the early '80s. If you're into process, try and get your hands on a copy of (it's a mouthful) - Wicked Problems, Righteous Solutions: A Catolog of Modern Engineering Paradigms: A Catalogue of Modern Software Engineering Paradigms (Yourdon Press Computing), by Peter DeGrace and Leslie Hulet Stahl. http://www.amazon.com/dp/013590126X http://www.amazon.com/dp/013590126X.
- anigbrowl 13y agoPalatable means tasty. Palpable means you could feel it. /nitpick, unless you were being especially tongue in cheek.
- pilom 13y agoWhoops thanks for seeing that. My bad.
- Patrick_Devine 13y agoThe difference is that there is a lot more complexity in software than there is in hardware. As a software engineer you make a million tiny decisions every day. As a riveter, you follow a blue print and put the rivet in the same designated places on every every machine over and over again. The fewer decisions made on a production floor, the better. That said, the thought process which goes in to designing an assembly line is fascinating. The techniques you can use when you're producing 5 parts a day vs 50,000 parts a day are quite different from each other. You have to balance those various costs and take into consideration your supply chain and the quality of one technique over another (yay linear algebra).
- a_c_s 13y agoIsn't buying things for the military out of concern for industrial needs rather than strategic need the definition of the military-industrial complex? The sooner this 'post-Cold-War day of reckoning for military aircraft' happens, the better.
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoThe industrial capacity is strategic. A large, well integrated fleet of F-22s with highly trained operators and support can ensure a war with a technologically advanced adversary doesn't start in the first place. Peace through superior firepower. The cancellation of the F-22 program goes along with the strange idea that bombing brown people in far off places will continue to be the problem going forward.
- Theodores 13y agoTrue. When you have bribed politicians the world over to spend their taxpayers money on F15's and F16's (instead of schools and hospitals) you do need the F22 to have that peace through superior bombing ability.
- 001sky 13y agoDoes this mean more f 35s? Even a worse decision ! The NSA has compromised communication and political speech in the Domestic USA, and unchecked its a far worse threat to freedom around the world. The US military is thankfully strong enough that it does not act out of small d!@k syndrome, which is why it is the most respected branch of the us government. Its approval ratings are >70%, while congress is ~10s and the media is ~20's. Insecure beuracracies are typically the most evil entities on the planet. Just like insecure b-team middle managers at work.
- Theodores 13y agoEyes roll! http://www.gallup.com/poll/163052/americans-confidence-congress-falls-lowest-record.aspx http://www.gallup.com/poll/163052/americans-confidence-congr... 76% of Americans really do 'approve' of the military. What next? Turkeys approving of Christmas!
- ryanackley 13y agoUm...anyone ever heard of the term "military-industrial complex"[1]? I would opine that the decline of this is a good thing. You might be able to trace a bunch of evil things to it. For example, NSA spying and the invasion of Iraq. I assure you that the chances of the defense industry running out of things to produce in the USA are wildly exaggerated. The article sounds like a shill piece for the defense industry. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military%E2%80%93industrial_complex http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military%E2%80%93industrial_com...
- brazzy 13y agoIf I understood it correctly, the concern raised by the article are not about overall reduced military production, but about the reduction being managed badly with the possible result that at some point specific stuff that is still needed cannot be produced anymore while lots of money is spent on programs that don't meet current requirements and end up getting cancelled.
- javert 13y ago> You might be able to trace a bunch of evil things to it. For example, NSA spying and the invasion of Iraq. That is hand-waving. You might be able to. You also might be able to trace JFK's assasination to a jilted lover. The problems you speak of are more likely ideological, although the NSA issue might just be pure careerism (as there is no modern ideology that claims that 1984 is a utopian book).
- ryanackley 13y agoI think it's reasonable to assume that some of the political pressure to go to war or fund overreaching government programs is based on the corporate interests of government contractors. I didn't think I needed to connect the dots between corporate interests, federally funded jobs in legislators home districts, and American policy. It should be obvious but that is just my opinion.
- javert 13y agoSo you are saying that a majority of the legislators and the executive are all pursuing foreign wars... because some voters in their districts work for defense companies? I don't think that argument holds water because it's not true that defense employs an overwhelming number of people in the average legislative (Senate or Congress) district. Or are you saying they are directly being bribed large sums of money to do it? If so, please provide evidence. That doesn't seem plausible in the US where direct bribes are rare and can be caught. > It should be obvious but that is just my opinion. Oh, right. The reason your argument is not specific and empirical is because you are appealing to the "obvious" i.e. "your opinion." And I must be stupid to not see that your opinion is just obvious.
- chiph 13y agoFrom a strategic sense, we would want to have (at least) 2 competing aircraft makers so that they compete against each other and innovations continue to be made. However, the cost of new aircraft is absurdly high, to the point where this might be unsustainable as a nation. In a way, we have become victims of our own success. During the 1st and 2nd Gulf Wars, we lost very few aircraft. Mostly because of their superior technology and design, and ability to counter the threat of Iraqi defenses. In the future, we might face a more challenging opponent - either because they produced better air defense systems, or because we allow our aircraft to become obsolete. Because our aircraft have been so good, it's tempting to mission-overload them. Build fewer, more-capable aircraft (or now, drones). But that increases the percentage loss of capability for each aircraft that is destroyed. Lose one plane out of two hundred, that's 0.5%. Lose one plane out of 50, that's a 2% reduction in airpower. So it might make sense to build more planes/drones, each of which costs less (and is individually less capable), and run the assembly lines at a slower pace. The cost then becomes more predictable and more even over the years (no huge expenditures in one year, and nothing the next). It'd take longer to fully staff a squadron, but would also ensure that new aircraft enter service each year so that the entire force would be, on the average, fairly new.
- velodrome 13y agoThese companies can re-purpose themselves to fill other needs. For example, Boeing lost an important military contract to build a heavy transport plane. Looking for another source of revenue, they ended up building the Boeing 747 - one of the most popular airplanes on the planet. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_747
- a8da6b0c91d 13y agoModern fighter aircraft need large single piece titanium parts, and this is essentially the only demand for the pressing facilities. If you don't support the presses somehow, the capacity goes away. This is just an example of how military industrial needs are specific.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bonemachine 13y agoYet the past few months have seen stark harbingers of looming pain. Strange notion of "pain", there. Coming from an industry whose main purpose, basically, is to drop fire on people.
- ars 13y agoNo, that's not the main purpose. It's the stated ability, but the main purpose is to scare others into not even thinking of attacking, and the secondary purpose is to provide jobs.
- bonemachine 13y agoWell, its real, main purpose is to provide a gravy train to its various first-tier stakeholders (elected representatives, and white collar defense contractors). As a side effect, it creates a lot of blue collar jobs, also -- but these are of secondary importance (i.e. they don't wag the hound nearly as much as the first tier). After that its purpose seems to be to make Americans feel "awesome" and "safe", in approximately equal measures. In that sense "kicking ass" (i.e. dropping fire on people for no good reason) seems to be about as important as making "feel safe." Whether the industry actually keeps us safe from external violence to any appreciable degree (i.e. that would be anywhere near worth the expenditure of blood and treasure devoted to that industry) seems to be highly debatable (and as a benefit, of at most tertiary significance, in this scheme).
- bane 13y agoThe best part is how, after the production runs are terminated, all of the specialized equipment needed to build those aircraft are also destroyed, so the lines can never be resurrected. This results in a new competitive bid for an all new aircraft design when the existing aircraft get too old. It takes a couple decades to bring a new modern aircraft from blueprint to regular production run. The F-22 program, started in a competitive process in 1981. It's literally the very best of late '70's mature technology with some very early 1980's hi-tech tossed in. Another point, the South Korean acquisition of the F-35 (called the F-X 3 in the article) may be one of the dirtiest acquisitions that's ever been publicly reported. Before the competition was even let, Lockheed had greased enough palms and secured a sure "win". Unfortunately, South Korea put in place an independent agency (DAPA) and legal framework to control defense acquisitions and the Lockheed bid lost badly (overbudget, not enough extras to juice it, they were sure of the win why not gouge the customer a bit?). The award went to Boeing and an all new custom variant of the F-15 that offered greater mission capability at a lower price, and involved significant technology transfer to South Korean industry (the aircraft would be majority built in Korea ramping up domestic expertise for future home-grown aircraft design). It was underbudget, more mature and featured several nice extras in the purchase package. There were so many positive points in favor of the F-15 acquisition that only an idiot would have turned it down and it would still be generations ahead of anything North Korea or China could throw at it. I believe they met every single one of the RFP requirements to the letter or better. I think they would have even gotten 20 more aircraft under the Boeing deal! The original officials who were bribed for their approval of the f-35 created all kinds of chaos and essentially overwrote the acquisition agency's legal award. They then setup a new "competition" and of course the award went to Lockheed. I've been following the story for a while and it's interesting that now that Lockheed won the final contract, the previous dirtiness of it all is barely reported. http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/Latest-News-Wires/2013/0924/F-15-Silent-Eagle-Why-South-Korea-rejected-this-jet http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/Latest-News-Wires/2013/092... Boeing's F-15 Silent Eagle had been in the box seat to win the 8.3 trillion won ($7.7 billion) tender - as the only bid to fall within budget - but former military top brass and even the ruling party's lawmakers had criticized the plane as it lacked crucial stealth capabilities.
- throwaway374658 13y ago
- mcguire 13y agoI seem to recall an adage about "you don't get to fight a war with the army you want; you fight a war with the army your predecessor wanted", probably to fight the previous war. The next war the United States gets into (and I mean "war", not "trivial intervention into some random third-world country") is going to be a lulu. Someone ought to hope that it lasts long enough to build up the army that is actually needed. Unfortunately, any solution that starts with "prioritizing industrial-base concerns" is unlikely to improve the situation.
- DanielBMarkham 13y ago"... Rather than procuring 48 planes per year for 10 years, why not 36 per year for 13 years? .." Or how about forcing military aircraft producers to use smaller domestic partners to do subassembly, thereby "unbundling" the purchase? This would also create higher unit costs, but would also create an ecosystem of small manufacturers. I agree there is a strategic problem at play here, but the answer is forcing more competition instead of paying more to huge conglomerates. Manufacturing is set to take off over the next decade or two, and it's not going to be BigCo manufacturing. If we wish to address this strategic problem, we need more emphasis on mom and pop manufacturing.
- protomyth 13y ago"use smaller domestic partners to do subassembly" That's actually a problem with government projects. Every congressional district needs to supply a part it seems. Unbundling is basically a bribe and corruption in our system.
- khafra 13y agoIs this why Skunk Works announced they're 5 years away from practical fusion? Is Lockheed Martin looking to make up their revenue shortages by switching from the DoD to the DOE?
- jgeada 13y agoIf the US would just stop procuring "perfect" aircraft that are all things to all men, the aircraft might just be cheap enough that we could afford to buy them. As it is we end up in a cycle of funding too-expensive aircraft with never-before combined features, fail expensively and require an even more ambitious program to fill the gap. A great recipe for the industrial complex that feeds off this cycle, but not so great for our defensive capabilities or our budget. To be honest, right now, I couldn't give a damn if we didn't buy any more toys for the damn armed forces to play with. We already nearly outspend the rest of the world combined and it isn't enough? Give me a break.