3 ms·
"Yes it does." No, it doesn't. You proved it yourself. You had to do some math to figure it out. The reason taxes don't appear on this U.S. government publi
by edw519 17y ago
"Yes it does."
No, it doesn't. You proved it yourself. You had to do some math to figure it out.
The reason taxes don't appear on this U.S. government publication is the same reason that they take withholding out of your check. If you actually saw what it cost you each year, it would piss you off so much you might actually get off your butt and do something about it.
- Xichekolas 17y agoThe less cynical explanation is that people are generally horrible at saving money, so withholding is the only way the taxes would get paid by most people. It reduces risk to the government that people won't have the cash on hand at the end of the year and just declare bankruptcy or otherwise claim they can't pay. Businesses don't have withholding, but they have quarterly tax payments for the same reason I'd bet. This is the reason that withholding is used by individuals to fund their retirement plans and other rainy day savings accounts. It's too easy to fritter the money away if you actually get your hands on it. I would agree with you that it'd be helpful to see taxes as a section of the pie chart here, but presumably the focus here is what people choose to spend their money on, and taxes aren't much of a choice.
- bokonist 17y agobut presumably the focus here is what people choose to spend their money on, and taxes aren't much of a choice. Taxes are the rent you pay for choosing to live in the USA.
- TheAmazingIdiot 17y agoI didn't "choose" to live in this country. I was born here. And without open borders to make residence in multiple countries, we are not "free" either.
- bokonist 17y agoYou choose to stay. A person may be born in an apartment, but that doesn't mean they can live there rent free for the rest of their life. And yes, you are not just free to walk into some other country and live there. But nor are you are allowed to walk onto someone else's property and live on it.
- johnnybgoode 17y agoI'm not sure if your reasoning for this is the same as our mutual friend MM's, but I've been meaning to address it, so I might as well do that here. To take your position, I think you first have to admit that USG is the de facto owner of all US territory. You, MM, and I would probably have no problem admitting this, but most people would have trouble with it. But even after we admit this, we still need to ask if this ownership ought to be treated as legitimate, and there I disagree with MM.
- bokonist 17y agoI think that the principle of Adverse Possession applies ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession ). If USG is not the legitimate title holder of middle-North America, who is?
- johnnybgoode 17y agoWhy should adverse possession apply? One use for it is to establish who the de facto owner is, but that is of course unnecessary here. Another is to provide more security for property owners -- does the most powerful corporation in the history of the world need that from us? Third, since adverse possession is based on the doctrine of laches, if it applies here doesn't England have a stronger claim to ownership? Also, if we are applying common law principles, I contend that USG has in the past engaged in massive fraud by pretending it is not the actual owner, and continues to do so today. When we also consider the violent means it has used to acquire and maintain ownership, we have force and fraud -- enough to disqualify USG as a legitimate title holder. > If USG is not the legitimate title holder of middle-North America, who is? I admit, the answer is unclear, but it does seem clear that USG is not it. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems your reasoning is at least slightly different from MM's, then -- I don't think MM has much of an interest in this question or much of an answer to it, since he has criticized the "Rebellion" but now accepts USG's ownership.
- Xichekolas 17y agoWell yeah, but I mean you can't really choose you level of tax payments as an individual. I can choose to leave and not pay any, but I can't say "better cut back on my taxes this month to make ends meet". I'm not complaining about my taxes. I think there are tons of things we could do to improve how we spent tax revenue, but I wouldn't say we are overtaxed.
- chops 17y agoI couldn't agree more. Amazing how furious the population would get if they had to write those bigass checks every quarter. It's too bad. I'd love to see an organized effort by business owners to say "screw withholding" for employees (despite it's illegality) and watch the government scramble. You can't imprison everyone.
- yason 17y agoI think the point of the diagram is to show where people decide to spend their money, that is, the money they actually get. What they get is after-tax. They do not get to spend the portion that is taxed away anyway so it's not on the list because it's not their choice. By the way, don't you guys in the U.S. get a salary report for each paycheck you receive? Such a report in Finland would state your salary before taxes, after other deductions such as insurance, pension, union fees etc. each listed per row, and finally your salary after taxes. I think that producing such a report is required for all companies so at least in this part of the globe you wouldn't miss how much you pay taxes. I must say that personally I really don't even know my salary before taxes unless rounded to the nearest 500 euros or so. All I'm interested in how much I get transferred to my bank account each month.
- anamax 17y ago> By the way, don't you guys in the U.S. get a salary report for each paycheck you receive? Yes we do. Most people ignore it (just like you). They figure take-home is their income and that any refund that they get after filing is "free money" to them and not a zero-interest rate loan to govt.