10 ms·
I remember hearing an interview with a civil engineer about why highways have all these "unnecessary" curves in them. Why can't engineers build highways that ar
by bane 13y ago
I remember hearing an interview with a civil engineer about why highways have all these "unnecessary" curves in them. Why can't engineers build highways that are more direct and straight?
After going on a bit about requirements for different kinds of terrain, the kind of strata the road needs to go on etc. and how those were difficult and expensive to surmount (so curves were often chosen to deal with it instead of a more expensive solution). He lamented that the most difficult and expensive aspect of new road construction was right of way through existing developments and other properties. Most of the curves we experience on highways are apparently the result of somebody, or a block of people, simply not wanting to give up their land.
- stephencanon 13y agoHmmm; maybe in some parts of the world. Around here (NH/VT) the curves are pretty obviously imposed by geology (if they didn’t follow narrow valleys, they would constantly be going up and down 1-2k ft ridges, and river valleys are not straight).
- maaku 13y agoThere is the concept of eminent domain which lets the government force-purchase land for this purpose. However it's typically only done in cities or where the geography / geology requires it. Out in California's central valley where it is flat as far as the eye can see, it's sometimes better politically to do a curve to follow edges of property lines than to piss off some big wig ranchers.
- bane 13y agoWell, that's what he was talking about, terrain isn't a problem if you don't mind blasting and clearing things or building lots of tunnels. It's expensive, but it's technologically possible.
- kalleboo 13y agoAnd this is what Japan does to build high speed rail in a mountainous country where all the land that's possible to grow or build on is already owned. On some Shinkansen routes you spend half your time going in an out of tunnels
- burgessaccount 13y agoAnother reason for the "unneccessary" curves is, at least according to historical legend, to help keep drivers alert/awake: http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/faq.htm#question30a http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/interstate/faq.htm#question30a
- omegant 13y agoI've seen this from a plane in the Namibia's roads in the middle of a big plain with no towns in sight from 35k feet.
- MartinCron 13y agoMost of the curves we experience on highways are apparently the result of somebody, or a block of people, simply not wanting to give up their land That reminded me of the story of a (now empty) house that's right next door to my new office: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edith_Macefield http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edith_Macefield
- lelf 13y agoYet another example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gate_Tower_Building https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gate_Tower_Building
- BrandonMarc 13y agoThat's really neat. Thanks for posting the link. Regarding the parent post about Edith Macefield, that's a neat story, too. It doesn't always turn out that way ... in Asia, there are many homes which have been cut off from all services (water, electric, sewer) and then the actual land is removed such that the occupants can barely get in or out of the house. "Nail house" is what they call it in China. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nail_house http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nail_house http://io9.com/unbelievable-nail-houses-around-the-world-892781747 http://io9.com/unbelievable-nail-houses-around-the-world-892...
- BrandonMarc 13y agoFatigue, boredom, and monotony are a factor, too. I watched an episode of Modern Marvels on the History Channel [0] which gave interesting details about the highway system. They mentioned something they called "highway hypnosis" [1], a trance-like state which they wanted to avoid. There's been some discussion of whether this phenomenon is to blame for the train derailment in New York about a month ago [2]. Most of the curves we experience on highways are apparently the result of somebody, or a block of people, simply not wanting to give up their land. Nor should they have to, if they don't want to (or disagree on the price). ---------------------------------------- [0] http://www.history.com/shows/modern-marvels/episodes/season-3 http://www.history.com/shows/modern-marvels/episodes/season-... ... see "Paving America" for the episode [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highway_hypnosis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Highway_hypnosis [2] http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/12/05/deadly-new-york-train-derailment-could-be-case-highway-hypnosis/ http://www.foxnews.com/us/2013/12/05/deadly-new-york-train-d...
- dalore 13y agoYou should try the Desert Bus game.
- jpatokal 13y agoContext: http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/07/the-worst-video-game-ever-created.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/07/the-w...
- oleganza 13y agoIf you can make a 1000 km straight road somewhere in Nevada, it'll be cheaper and more efficient to do exactly that. Neither drivers nor investors would like increased travel time and costs because of the fatigue and boredom. The real improvement would be to make wider lanes and allow driving 200 mph. Or even better, put a high-speed train or a hyperloop.
- Groxx 13y agoThey do like decreased death due to fatigue and boredom, though. Highway hypnosis is nasty and dangerous.
- gaius 13y agoRight, why shouldn't people give up their homes and businesses to make this guy's job easier? Talk about a sense of entitlement! The truth is in a civilized society the interests of different groups of people must be accommodated. Next time it might be your house they want to flatten so people from one place you've never been can get to another place you've never been one minute quicker.
- dragontamer 13y agoHowever, the issue here is that Hyperloop was theorized without any consideration of people's homes or businesses. The high-speed rail system on the other hand, minimizes the amount of disruption. (and is also a proven technology)
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoIts all about the speed. If the high-speed is high enough, it'll have to do much the same thing. If it isn't high, then why build it.
- dragontamer 13y agoIts more about bandwidth and you know it. The system needs to transport thousands of people per hour, and Hyperloop (as designed) only has 40 pods carrying only 28 people each. We're looking at a (theoretical) $8 Billion system... that is probably grossly underestimating costs at that... that can only support 1120 passengers at a time, max. On the entire system. Hyperloop may be fast, but it transports very very few people. A single-train will transport more people. Frankly, when looking at mass-transit, the #1 concern is moving people, lots of people and quickly. Just like people today care about the "bandwidth" of their internet connections, I guarantee you that city planners are more interested in the "bandwidth" of a high-speed system.
- cbr 13y agoThe Hyperloop, if it were possible, would have about three times the current capacity of the Acela. At an 80min round trip running 20hr a day that's 15 trips per pod per day. So we have 40x28x15 = 16,800 daily round trips. The Acela holds 360 people per train with 16 round trips per day. That's 360x16 = 5,760 daily round trips. A high-speed system with dedicated track could run more often, and you could use longer trains than the Acela does, so the potential maximum bandwidth of high-speed rail is higher. But 16,800 daily round trips is large enough to be taken seriously. (Why do I say "if it were possible"? http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy-ideas-are-fine-if-youre-an-entrepreneur/ http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy... )
- nicholas73 13y agoIs there a similar explanation for poor design of merge sections which IMO cause the vast majority of traffic jams? Heck, on 880 in San Jose the highway goes from 3 lanes to 2 lanes and back to 3 again. WTF!
- hrasyid 13y agoMy hometown in Indonesia has a lot of such unnecessary merging and widening. And they are because some guys don't want to sell their land / the government not offering them enough money (depending on whose side you're on)
- nodata 13y agoInteresting, but if you RTFA... It seems that the first 295 miles of the route can be accomplished .. without .. encroaching on private property.