12 ms·
Personally I'm still worried about the claustrophobia issues. And I'm not even really claustrophobic. There's just something about being in a small seat in a
by mrfusion 13y ago
Personally I'm still worried about the claustrophobia issues. And I'm not even really claustrophobic.
There's just something about being in a small seat in a concrete tube with no exit for 100's of miles that really freaks me out.
- FatalLogic 13y agoPerhaps good design can help deal with some of that fear? Most people can handle being in elevators OK, despite being in claustrophobic box full of people, hanging on a cable, inside a vertical tunnel. They just don't think about where they are.
- aestra 13y agoI'm claustrophobic. Elevators are fine, they are plenty big enough. MRIs are not. There are different levels of claustrophobia though, some people need to sit next to an exit in a room, for example, and not in the back for easy escape.
- athanasius 13y agoI didn't realize I might be more than very slightly claustrophobic until I had an MRI recently. I wonder if there might be a greater incidence than most people consider.
- aestra 13y agoAnywhere between 4–20% of patients refuse to go through with the MRI due to claustrophobia. Sources in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claustrophobia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claustrophobia
- derekp7 13y agoWhen you are entering it in the station, you have a lot of open space until the hatch closes. So what about instead of having windows, make them 3D holographic displays that look like you are peering out an airplane window? There is still the mental knowledge that your are in a tube (like a subway tube) but it might be enough to fool your subconscious.
- jonknee 13y agoAre you afraid to fly? An aluminum tube with no exit for thousands of miles and a much longer time in the seat.
- ceejayoz 13y agoPlanes have windows and the ability to get up and walk around to some extent. Likely makes a difference for most claustrophobics.
- blowski 13y agoDoes the design of Hyperloop make it impossible to walk around? In terms of no windows, sounds similar to the Channel Tunnel. You're typically in the tunnel for close to 30 minutes.
- deletes 13y agoYes, in the passenger version you can't even stand up. You would probably have a huge interactive flat screen in front of you to ease the tension.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoWindows and space behind them could be faked with some tricky display setup.
- ceejayoz 13y agoI've yet to see a display that's truly indistinguishable from reality, and claustrophobics are unlikely to be soothed by something they know to be an illusion.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- saraid216 13y agoAt this point, there should be enough research on claustrophobia to provide the necessary knowledge for the design.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoHm. I hadn't realized that Elon's basic spec has no room for aisles--seats are two abreast in a 4.5' wide tube. On the other hand, "Beautiful landscape will be displayed in the cabin," so that may help relieve claustrophobia. He also allows for a larger version that can carry cars (with their passengers)--presumably the passenger-only compartments on that model would be roomier.