3 ms·
I think this is a very interesting question, but there's a pretty strong tendency in the human psyche to assume that the answer is more or less to replicate $MY
by jerf 13y ago
I think this is a very interesting question, but there's a pretty strong tendency in the human psyche to assume that the answer is more or less to replicate $MY_CLAIMED_MORALITY out to the rest of humanity, which this essay does nothing to avoid. ($MY_CLAIMED_MORALITY stands in contrast to $MY_ACTION_MORALITY, i.e., how one behaves, which this essay does discuss there being a difference in, to its credit.) Fiddling with morality may have large potential benefits, but it can also cause catastrophe, yes, even worse than what we have now.
"Increasing empathy" sounds great, right? But it can cause excessively local decision making brought on by a particular case of acute pain, while missing the greater good that may be done elsewhere. It may allow a morality-parasite leader to come to power to manipulate everybody via their increased empathy to do something awful. (Indeed, I'm sure many people here have found that even in current society, there's certain areas that you must deliberately reduce your empathy in; you simply can not afford to be manipulated by every picture of a starving child you come across, or you'll become broke... and with no guarantee that your donations are doing anything but lining a pocket somewhere, if you're too busy giving to do background checks on who you're giving to....) And of course it's not a knob; what "increases empathy" in the lab may in the field "increase empathy for my tribe", as we are so wired for that.
Tribalism is bad, right? Perhaps so, but "let's just turn down the tribalism" does not clearly work. We are tribal for a reason. Unless you can flip the switch all at once, you run the risk of the selfless a-tribals getting parasitized by the still-tribal, meaning it may not be stable. It may not be stable even if you could flip the switch all at once; you still have to worry about morality parasites.
To say nothing of what happens once you have the power to twiddle with human morality, and then those of altered morality start twiddling the knobs themselves, which would be inevitable.
Yes, it is likely that some morality changes will have to occur for human survival... no, it probably is not the case that you can predict them trivially now, no, it probably isn't as simple as "Why can't we all just love each other?", and I very strongly suspect that if we could get a preview of that new morality, we'd all probably find it repulsive in some way... it's simply inconceivable that the answer is as easy as taking somebody's modern morality (which does not come from any magically better morality source, it's as broken as everybody else's) and stamping it out on everyone else.
- jal278 13y agoI agree completely that this is a delicate issue; my main hope is to raise some awareness that the disconnect between technological progress and progress in morality/ethics deserves greater research focus. I am not in favor of blindly imposing anyone's particular and likely flawed understanding of morality universally, but that this could be an urgent issue for our species' survival.
- maroonblazer 13y ago1) At the risk of seeming trite, I liken this to your typical change management program. That is, simply rolling out a new tool across the organization and expecting people to use it in accord with the the vision it was conceived is unrealistic. People need to be educated and, depending on the circumstances, given incentives for using the new tool. Ask anyone who's been involved in one of these projects on a large scale and they'll tell you it often takes longer to realize the behavior change than it takes to develop the tool. 2) The field of moral psychology tackles these very types of problems, by, among other things, surfacing our moral contradictions and forcing us to consider why seemingly equivalent moral outcomes are not considered so (take the Trolley Problem as one, now nearly cliched, example). i.e. I think there's more work being done in this domain than perhaps the author gives credit. That said, I don't disagree that more could be done.
- humanrebar 13y ago> Tribalism is bad, right? One person's tribalism is another's cultural heritage. I think the case has been made that stamping out unique cultures needlessly is immoral. The biggest problem with this whole discussion is the idea that everyone even agrees on one morality. On top of that, even if everyone shared a common morality, it's questionable that it could be approximately quantified and graphed in a meaningful way. To underscore this point, OP and many of the comments here state that there has been moral progress lately. Again, I'm not sure you can quantify morality like that, but I do know that a respectable amount of people believe that Western culture is regressing morally.