4 ms·
Agreed. This is just how normal people, err, construct structs. You are not an advanced C programmer until you have grasped it. You are not a master of C until
by gaius 13y ago
Agreed. This is just how normal people, err, construct structs.
You are not an advanced C programmer until you have grasped it. You are not a master of C until you could have written this document yourself and can criticize it intelligently
In other words, a "hacker" is someone just like ESR. More blowhardery. I for one don't claim to be a master...
- hobs 13y agoTo be fair, he didn't claim that by writing this document he was a master of C, or that a master would only know this document, just that it was a piece of knowledge a master would should definitely have. Phrasing I guess.
- hdevalence 13y ago"A master of C must have the same views of what's important and the same writing style that I do" i.e., 'a hacker is someone who looks like me'.
- philh 13y agoThat is not a charitable interpretation of what he wrote. Try, "A master of C must already know about structure packing deeply enough to teach it".
- gaius 13y agoTry reading some more ESR, that is a common theme in his writing, unfortunately.
- philh 13y agoI agree that "people being uncharitable about ESR" is a common theme.
- mwfunk 13y agoNo, seriously. This is a common theme in just about everything ESR writes. For example, for some inexplicable reason, the Jargon File used to have an entry stating that hackers tend to be libertarian. This, of course, was written when ESR self-identified as a libertarian. Later on (post-9/11), he decided that he was a neocon instead. Strangely, the entry in the Jargon File was then updated to state that hackers tend to be neocons. That's just one particularly egregious example. There are a gazillion others. Pretty much everything the guy has ever written has similar implications, where he defines a hacker as being whatever he sees himself as at the time. He really really wants to believe that there is a very specific hacker subculture (in his words, "our tribe"), and that they have a shared culture, heritage, and beliefs about things, and that they have some sort of meritocracy where certain members of that subculture are universally agreed upon as being wise and correct about everything (in his words, "the elders of our tribe"), and of course, that he is one of those people at the top of the imaginary meritocracy in this imaginary subculture. Also, for bonus douchebaggery points, as if he needed them: http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=208 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=208
- philh 13y ago> For example, for some inexplicable reason, the Jargon File used to have an entry stating that hackers tend to be libertarian. This, of course, was written when ESR self-identified as a libertarian. Later on (post-9/11), he decided that he was a neocon instead. Strangely, the entry in the Jargon File was then updated to state that hackers tend to be neocons. The current entry: > Formerly vaguely liberal-moderate, more recently moderate-to-neoconservative (hackers too were affected by the collapse of socialism). There is a strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that hackers tend to be rather anti-authoritarian; thus, both paleoconservatism and ‘hard’ leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either (a) be aggressively apolitical or (b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day. archive.org says this was the same in 2003. (Possibly it changed and changed back, but I assume not.) From march 2000 (v4.2.2 at http://jargon-file.org/archive/ http://jargon-file.org/archive/ which I selected somewhat at random, I didn't try to find the earliest "politics" entry): > Vaguely liberal-moderate, except for the strong libertarian contingent which rejects conventional left-right politics entirely. The only safe generalization is that hackers tend to be rather anti-authoritarian; thus, both conventional conservatism and `hard' leftism are rare. Hackers are far more likely than most non-hackers to either (a) be aggressively apolitical or (b) entertain peculiar or idiosyncratic political ideas and actually try to live by them day-to-day. ESR in 2008 ( http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=301 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=301 ): > I am not and have never been a conservative. Much less a “neocon”, whatever that means. "Hackers tend to be libertarian" and "hackers tend to be neocons" are not sentiments expressed by either variant. "He decided that he was a neocon" just seems to be plain false. Whatever the merits of the changes he made, I claim that you are being uncharitable towards him. I'm not necessarily defending ESR himself, I just think that you're attacking someone who isn't ESR and calling them ESR. And I think this is a common theme when people talk about ESR.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 13y agoNot just 'hacker', but 'human being': http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=5001 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=5001
- caf 13y agoThat is not a fair characterisation of the comment. For one thing, it says "could have", not "would have" - this strongly implies that it's a reference to the technical content, and not the existence or style of the report.
- pjscott 13y agoElapsed time until someone used this article as an excuse to complain about the author, derailing the thread into non-struct-related flaming: about two hours. That's longer than I was expecting! I think 2014 is going to be a good year!
- FedRegister 13y agoYup, ESR is the embodiment of the American exceptionalism, white, male, heterosexual privilege resident in the hacker community, and the sooner that we move beyond his worldview (while still observing he is technically astute) the better.
- mcguire 13y ago> while still observing he is technically astute Is he? I'm not trying to be insulting, but I honestly can't think of anything that he's done that I might be impressed by.