5 ms·
Burn it to the ground and replace it with what?
by pdonis 13y ago
Burn it to the ground and replace it with what?
- coldtea 13y agoIf you have a growth and the doctor advises you to remove it, do you ask him what will he replace it with? In any case, replace it with a system that doesn't do all that stuff.
- aidenn0 13y agoIf I have an unsalvageable organ and the doctor advises me to remove it, then I certainly will ask him what he will replace it with. As messed up as the system is, it does work marginally better than anarchy.
- okaram 13y agoMarginally ? Have you seen anarchy ? You get warlords, feudalism, that kind of stuff (see Somalia). I'm assuming the writer lives in the US; I think he greatly exaggerates the issues; the system works; most people live with enough food, enough necessities and without the threat of violence; we CAN make it better, but I'd much rather improve on it than try to come up with a new one. BTW, I haven't seen ANY system that works wholesale better than ours; have y'all ?
- stefantalpalaru 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchism
- scarmig 13y agoLow standards. The post Stalin Soviet Union also provided everything you mentioned. But I'm not happy to be a serf, even if a serf who is likely to have enough gruel for a comfortable existence. What's better? I don't presume to be able to build a new society from the fount of my head. But relentless, diverse experimentation, and creating the space for that experimentation, seems like a solid approach to me.
- pdonis 13y agoThe post Stalin Soviet Union also provided everything you mentioned. No, it didn't, at least not on its own. Even post-Stalin, the Soviet Union couldn't feed its people from its own resources; it relied on large food imports from other countries (including the US). And it still relied on violence to keep people in line, just not as overtly as Stalin did.
- scarmig 13y agoIt couldn't feed people on its own, except by manufacturing goods and trading them for food? That's hardly damning of the USSR (though it certainly is worthy of damnation, for other reasons); other countries do the same thing now, for both agricultural and manufactured goods. The point is, people had enough food to survive, which is the point I was addressing. Similarly, you could avoid state violence by accepting the system without complaint. A terrible way to eke out an existence, but not a difficult one if you have low expectations of human dignity.
- pdonis 13y agoIt couldn't feed people on its own, except by manufacturing goods and trading them for food? Where did I say it got food from the US (and other countries) by trading manufactured goods? How many Soviet manufactured goods do you remember seeing in Western countries? What the Soviet Union actually "traded" for food was concessions on treaty issues like nuclear weapons. Which was particularly convenient for them since most of what they conceded was not actually verifiable, so the "concessions" amounted to making promises they had no intention of keeping, in exchange for actual stuff. The point is, people had enough food to survive, which is the point I was addressing. No, the point you were addressing was that the system in which the people lived was able to provide for them, which was not true of the Soviet Union. If the West had not agreed to play the USSR's con game of trading non-verifiable concessions for actual stuff for decades, the USSR would have collapsed a lot sooner than it did.
- scarmig 13y ago
- stefantalpalaru 13y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Past_and_present_anarchist_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Past_and_present_anarchist_com...
- PavlovsCat 13y agoHow is our current state that different from anarchy? Do we actually have rule of law, not to mention anything resembling justice; or only up to the point where it becomes inconvenient for the powerful? So it works marginally better for those aligned to power or operating in the shade of its inefficiencies; sure, but you could also say this about the world Mad Max drove around in..
- maxk42 13y agoGenerally speaking, you can't survive without organs. Generally speaking, you can survive without government.
- pdonis 13y agoIf you have a growth and the doctor advises you to remove it, do you ask him what will he replace it with? Irrelevant, because the OP isn't advocating removing a growth; he's advocating "removing" my entire body structure. If a doctor advised you to get a body transplant, would you not feel the need to ask him what your body was going to be replaced with?
- coldtea 13y agoOnly if you feel "the entire body" is the government, police, etc. I'd say there are is an actual country, made of solid land, tons of assets, houses, buildings, shops, companies, and around 350+ million people that are outside of this "whole body" and they can build a new structure if it goes away. Heck, some say those all are that started the USA in the first place.
- pdonis 13y agoA transplant of the entire body might be a bit much as an analogy, yes; but "removing a growth" is far too little. I'm not even sure replacing a single defective organ, which was the analogy another poster used, is enough to convey just how much "the system" now infiltrates every aspect of our lives. some say those all are that started the USA in the first place I'm not sure this analogy holds up very well either, because the British government's impact on the colonies was much, much smaller than the current US government's impact on the USA. To "build a new structure if it goes away" would be orders of magnitude more difficult now, and would involve a lot more pain, suffering, and violence.
- etherael 13y agoAnarchocapitalism, YouTube "machinery of freedom" for the ten minute primer. "The Problem Of Political Authority" for a good book presenting the case that the entire idea of political authority on which all states are built is internally inconsistent and unacceptable as well as why an ancap system would work well in practice. It's the best alternative system I have seen so far I think, although I think instead of trialing it out by revolution in an enormous country like the US it will be good to see it in action first in the currently developing Honduran ZEDE's as well as seasteads when they become a reality. It's much easier to say it's a good plan when there is practice rather than just theory.
- thangalin 13y agoFewer people vote than own Internet-enabled devices.[1] Centralized anonymous participation in policy deliberation, creation, and education seems a logical step. Consider the following application: http://davidjarvis.ca/world-politics/ http://davidjarvis.ca/world-politics/ Reducing the influence of Special Interest Groups is accomplished through moderation whereby moderators are randomly selected, from the entire population of users, and are empowered for a random interval of time. The path to adoption begins at municipalities wherein contributions are initially restricted to civil servants, whilst benefits and drawbacks to upcoming policies are publicized. Once many cities are using the system to deliberate and solicit public feedback, usage at the Provincial (or State) level could follow. Similar systems exist[2], however they are too complex for recording open and transparent discourse to achieve majority consensus on a particular policy. Thoughts? [1] I am reminded of this quote from V for Vendetta, "You now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing your conformity and soliciting your submission. How did this happen? Who's to blame? Well certainly there are those more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if you're looking for the guilty, you need only look into a mirror." [2] https://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/wiki/Related%20Links https://bitbucket.org/djarvis/world-politics/wiki/Related%20...
- pdonis 13y agoI don't see how any of the alternatives you refer to are "burning the system to the ground". They're just incremental changes to the system we have. (That's not to say I think they're necessarily bad ideas; just that they don't seem to be the kind of ideas that the OP is advocating.)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- etherael 13y agoAnarchocapitalism, YouTube "machinery of freedom" for the ten minute primer. "The Problem Of Political Authority" for a good book presenting the case that the entire idea of political authority on which all states are built is internally inconsistent and unacceptable as well as why an ancap system would work well in practice. It's the best alternative system I have seen so far I think, although I think instead of trialing it out by revolution in an enormous country like the US it will be good to see it in action first in the currently developing Honduran ZEDE's as well as seasteads when they become a reality. It's much easier to say it's a good plan when there is practice rather than just theory.