4 ms·
It isn't "bullshit" to complain about something unethical. I feel that it's this type of thinking ("because I can and it's legal and it doesn't matter that it's
by chaostheory 13y ago
It isn't "bullshit" to complain about something unethical. I feel that it's this type of thinking ("because I can and it's legal and it doesn't matter that it's wrong") that's the cause of a lot of the world's problems: from patent trolling lobbying for corporate welfare, to even more mundane stuff like spam and crapware from installers. When people start thinking that this is acceptable, it's not too far from thinking "because I can totally get away with it, there's nothing wrong with not doing it regardless of the ethics and legality" leading to even worse shit like selling fake food or dumping pollutants and waste into rivers.
- famousactress 13y agoI'm not arguing that ethics are bullshit. I'm arguing that they don't apply to your relationship with Starbucks because Starbucks is of a size and makeup that it's achieved a humanity index which approaches (if not reaches) zero. It's akin to applying an ethical framework to your relationship with a robot. I agree that "because I can" is causing enormous problems. The most damaging perpetrators of this are these corporate super-organisms (Starbucks being just one example) and sociopathic assholes (this includes patent trolls). In dealing with either of those entities (but not each-other!) we do the world a disservice holding ourselves to a one-sided ethical yardstick. Fuck ethics when dealing with them. Play by their rules.
- chaostheory 13y agoJust because Starbucks is a large, profitable organization, it doesn't mean that it gives people a blank check for doing anything they want against Starbucks regardless of whether or not it's wrong. > The most damaging perpetrators of this are these corporate super-organisms That doesn't mean all corporations including Starbucks are the same. Over generalizing something doesn't help. Are you going to tell me that everyone belonging to a particular ethnic group is prone to stealing so we should just lock them all up at night? > In dealing with either of those entities (but not each-other!) we do the world a disservice holding ourselves to a one-sided ethical yardstick. When you start down this road, it'll be easier and easier to start breaking your own rules on when it's right time to do the right thing (or prevent yourself from being asshole at times).
- famousactress 13y agoYour argument is circular because it assumes it's possible to do something "wrong" to Starbucks. I'm arguing that it's not possible because ethics don't actually exist in the relationship in the first place. Ethics are a social contract that Starbucks won't participate in. Any participation on your part is optional, and I believe silly. > That doesn't mean all corporations including Starbucks are the same. No, of course they're not all the same. But at some point they abandon humanity and are literally incapable of making an ethical choice independent of business value. Certainly the brewer or other small businesses are well below this index. There are people at those entities that are capable of making a ethical decision without regard to how it will affect the organization. Where organizations cross that line is fuzzy, but Starbucks is certainly past it. Also, I don't believe I'm generalizing at all. I certainly think the evaluation is case-by-case, but I'd certainly be quick to assume that any publicly traded company worth billions falls into this category. [Edit: Also, I didn't say it gives anyone a blank check. There are obviously legal consequences, and the law increasingly vastly favors entities like Starbucks, because money buys law in the US. In short: If you're the brewer in this story the scales are already tipped against you. Opting-in to the idea that you ought to treat Starbucks the way you ought to treat your next door neighbor doesn't help anyone but Starbucks.]
- chaostheory 13y ago> Ethics are a social contract that Starbucks won't participate in. Really? This is a really strong assumption. So people as a group cant act in an ethical manner? > Also, I don't believe I'm generalizing at all. But you are. Here are your generalizations: * Ethics are a social contract that Starbucks won't participate in. (What proof do you have?) * But at some point they [ALL corporations] abandon humanity and are literally incapable of making an ethical choice independent of business value. > Also, I didn't say it gives anyone a blank check. There are obviously legal consequences, and the law increasingly vastly favors entities like Starbucks, because money buys law in the US yes might equals right and the ends always justify the means /s
- famousactress 13y ago