4 ms·
Not at all surprised. Anyone that used the app would be suspicious of the backend behind it. Should have taken that $3bn while you had the chance.
by untog 13y ago
Not at all surprised. Anyone that used the app would be suspicious of the backend behind it. Should have taken that $3bn while you had the chance.
- jkelsey 13y agoStill too early to make those types of statements. I think it mostly depends on how much the media plays this up.
- X4 13y agowe are kind of the media.. and reddit is too.. I also believe that they made a fatal error by not selling everything for $3bn then jumping aboard. To not have anything to do with the "soon to come security issues". I mean they could have mentioned it and downplay it as they did just recently. I don't think that the new owner would take security more serious than them. For us it was really really good that he rejected the offer! Because otherwise we would see the trade market crash $3bn, guess who would have to pay loss.. we.. well, if he saw that coming, which I doubt, he would be a hero.
- wrongc0ntinent 13y ago>I don't think that the new owner would take security more serious than them. I don't know about that. Their dismissal was (at least framed as) "well that's a lot of data, so it's not going to happen!" Actual excerpt from their blog, on the 27th: "Theoretically, if someone were able to upload a huge set of phone numbers, like every number in an area code, or every possible number in the U.S., they could create a database of the results and match usernames to phone numbers that way." This is kind of a joke.
- twistedpair 13y ago> Because otherwise we would see the trade market crash $3bn A sale of SC hurts all other companies in the market? Hard to understand this posit.
- myko 13y agoNot to mention I don't think most of snapchats target audience even cares about this issue. My 20 year old sister certainly doesn't.
- ja27 13y agoUnless it's changed recently, the phone number is user-supplied and I'm not sure if it's verified at all. They do claim that the phone number "will be stored as unique mathematical representations (or 'hashes')..." rather than plaintext, but I imagine if you know it's a non-salted phone number that's been hashed, it's pretty easy to brute force. But were they lying about hashing the phone numbers? I guess it doesn't matter if they hashed the phone numbers if they're going to expose an unlimited query API that can be brute-forced like this.
- boxy 13y agojaz27: Why is your comment grey? Did they really claim phone numbers are hashed? If so, why has nobody else touched on this subject?
- elliottcarlson 13y agoPosts get grayer due to downvotes. The more downvotes, the lighter the text will be.
- ja27 13y agoYes. I signed up in-app today (with a fake phone number) and that's a direct quote from the app. No idea on the downvotes. I guess because, like I said, telling users you hash the phone numbers doesn't matter if you're using them to search for an unhashed userid. But they're implying to users that their phone numbers are secure because they're hashed, when it really doesn't matter.
- stouset 13y agoSalts, in a cryptographic context, are considered to be public. Salting does not mitigate a brute force attack against a limited search space.
- elwell 13y agoOr the $4bn. http://www.theverge.com/2013/11/15/5106950/google-snapchat-4-billion-buyout-rumor http://www.theverge.com/2013/11/15/5106950/google-snapchat-4...