4 ms·
> With healthcare, the free market has clearly failed. The United States now has the highest per capita healthcare costs in the world, but not a commensurate le
by a3n 13y ago
> With healthcare, the free market has clearly failed. The United States now has the highest per capita healthcare costs in the world, but not a commensurate level of health, ...
Because you aren't buying health. You're buying health insurance. It may come with free assumptions, but those are generally worthless, and they are not health either.
If you want a thing, you should buy that thing. Health insurance is not health, and absolutely everyone who buys health insurance gets exactly what they pay for: insurance. Whether that indirectly results in health depends on the individual policy.
- jjoonathan 13y ago> Health insurance is not health, and absolutely everyone who buys health insurance gets exactly what they pay for: insurance. Part of his point is that people often pay for health "insurance" and don't receive the insurance they thought they were paying for (their "insurance" provider drops them the moment they get sick). You can blame people for not being able to understand the plans they are buying (dozens of pages of dense, industry-specific terminology) but you might as well blame the sky for being blue. One of the things the ACA does is make it easy to compare plans so that insurance companies actually have to compete against one another. > If you want a thing, you should buy that thing. There are two problems health insurance solves that make direct purchase of health care a complete non-starter. * 1: Most people have insufficient cappitalization to accept the heavily skewed risk profile. * 2: If you purchase emergency care at the point of provision, you are either forced to accept the terms "offered" by an effective monopoly (if you are conscious) or you are forced to pay whatever the "care" provider wants after the fact (if you are not conscious).
- a3n 13y ago> You can blame people for not being able to understand the plans they are buying Hmm, didn't mean to sound like I'm blaming people. I'm mostly just raging impotently at the fact that for most people the only meaningful way to get at health care is through health insurance, whose motivation is to not give it to you, good and hard. Given the costs and accessibility of modern medicine, I recognize that it would also be difficult for most people to pay directly. I would prefer, though, that we did that through a single payer (government) arrangement, the same way we pay for national defense. (The difference being, of course, that national defense is required by the Constitution, and health is not.)
- swalkergibson 13y agoGive me a break. Here is a scenario for you. What if you were hit by a drunk driver on your way into work on Friday morning and end up in an extended hospital stay with multiple surgeries? The bill could rack up to several hundred thousand dollars. You get all of your medical bills and you think everything is just fine, your insurance will take care of it. Then, your insurance company sends you a letter that says you missed one of the dozens of questions during the course of filling out your policy and they cancel it on you. Now, you can either pay those bills (haha, unlikely), settle them (killing your credit), or declare bankruptcy (killing your credit). Now, you cannot finance shit. House, car, credit cards. You are essentially fucked, through no fault of your own. Your argument is unbelievably ignorant.
- humanrebar 13y agoThat's a very detailed hypothetical in which there is clear liability so talking to a hypothetical lawyer would be the best course of action. The point is that we don't pay for the bandages and bedpans, we pay deductibles and premiums (if that) so of course costs are out of whack.
- swalkergibson 13y agoYa, because the justice system is so efficient. While I wait two years for a settlement that might or might not cover all of my bills, I can fend off creditors while my FICO score goes down the drain (and that is even if there is somebody to sue). If you believe that medical bankruptcies are okay, then there is really nowhere for this discussion to go because I happen to think that is total hogwash.
- georgemcbay 13y agoI'm sure that quick judgement against the hypothetical drunk driver will result in you soon receiving the hypothetical hundreds of thousands of dollars he has in his hypothetical savings account.
- humanrebar 13y ago