4 ms·
One of the biggest disappointments for me about the ACA was that it didn't address one of the most obvious problems with the American healthcare system -- the s
by humanrebar 13y ago
One of the biggest disappointments for me about the ACA was that it didn't address one of the most obvious problems with the American healthcare system -- the significant discount for employer-provided healthcare.
- IbJacked 13y agoIs employer-provided healthcare discounted, or merely subsidized by the employer (or both)? The plan through my employer seemed inexpensive, but they were paying a significant portion of the premium.
- bradleyjg 13y agoIt depends on exactly what you mean by discounted, but in a very real way the answer is both. First there's the obvious, and quite significant, tax benefits to employer provided healthcare over private purchased healthcare. In the former case, neither the employer nor the employee pay payroll taxes on their contributions and the employee portion is also exempted from income tax (the employer also doesn't pay income tax on its contribution, but it wouldn't for cash salary either). Second, more subtly, the group market faces much more favorable underwriting than the individual market. Even if non-employer group health insurance were allowed (which it isn't anymore under ACA) such groups are always subject to self-selection bias and thus are unlikely to be underwritten as as favorably. However, this point is somewhat tricky because there are both cross-subsidies and gross economic surpluses, which can be hard to untangle.
- jacobn 13y agoIt's tax deductible for the company to offer employees health care, but individual plans bought by individuals on the exchanges are not. So it's effectively subsidized in one case but not the other.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Domenic_S 13y agoThe biggest disappointment about the ACA is that the discussion completely ignores the cost of care. In other words: the healthcare discussion in America revolved around "how can we make it so everyone can afford this $300 asprin?" rather than, "Why are we letting hospitals charge $300 for asprin?" A very clever smokescreen.
- humanrebar 13y agoI won't argue with that. Employer-provided healthcare is one of the key obfuscators of the cost of healthcare as far as patients are concerned. It also has secondary effects in employment markets: * employers should not be encouraged to replace full-time workers with part-time workers because of health insurance costs * employees shouldn't be making decisions about careers and jobs based on what health insurance costs will be * the actual compensation levels between jobs is harder to evaluate since health benefits can be a huge chunk of compensation these days
- usefulcat 13y agoThere's a simple reason they charge whatever they want and generally can't even be bothered to disclose those prices ahead of time: because they can. To critics of the ACA, the relevant question is, who or what is in an effective position to put downward pricing pressure on hospitals? Because to date, it has clearly not been individuals or insurance companies.
- jjoonathan 13y agoSingle-payer systems have a track record for being much better at putting downward pressure on pricing. Not only can they secure drug discounts of ~50% due to their ability to bargain as a bloc against much smaller insurance companies in the US, but they lack perverse incentives to allow costs to rise. Insurance companies don't care about reducing costs, only reducing costs relative to competitors. Since their "cut" is a fraction of overall expenditures, they're quite happy to see costs rise, as long as they rise in tandem for their competitors. Nobody who is familiar with the market is surprised that single-payer systems are so much cheaper. Health Care costs by country: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_health_expenditure_%28PPP%29_per_capita http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_total_heal... Scholarly Analysis: http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources http://www.pnhp.org/facts/single-payer-resources
- twoodfin 13y agoWell, if you really wanted to de-couple health insurance from employment, you'd have been better off voting for John McCain, whose health plan transformed the tax-advantaged status of employer health care into an individual tax credit available regardless of how your health care was purchased. Neither President Obama nor Sen. Baucus (the real author of what became "Obamacare") ever had that in mind: If you weren't going to get single-payer, there was no way you were going to cut government worker and blue collar labor unions away from the very cushy tax-advantaged plans they'd negotiated with their employers for current and retired members. They're already extremely upset about just the "Cadillac" tax.
- x0x0 13y agoShe single biggest disappointment of the ACA is how few people understand what could be passed in the american system of governance, which combines a huge number of veto points with the republican party that plainly couldn't give a fuck less about people unable to afford healthcare.