4 ms·
How many good questions do you see that are "CLOSED AS NOT A REAL QUESTION"? The site is fine for what it is, but there's definitely a market for building a be
by melling 13y ago
How many good questions do you see that are "CLOSED AS NOT A REAL QUESTION"? The site is fine for what it is, but there's definitely a market for building a better StackOverFlow.
- stefan_kendall 13y agoStackOverflow seems to have devolved into a bunch of shit questions. Anything too technical doesn't get answered, since the real veterans have left, and anything not technical enough (like an approach to a problem) gets closed. I loved SO in the beginning. Now it's a cesspool.
- mlvljr 13y agothe point on too technical not getting answers -- exactly
- nathan_long 13y ago>> the real veterans have left Evidence?
- orclev 13y agoThere are a few holdouts in certain areas. E.G. there's a pretty active and good Haskell community on SO currently.
- VLM 13y agoThat annoys the heck out of me, because if it truly is not a real question, then the "general masses" of answer authors would naturally agree. Instead some deletionist authoritarian jerk needs to force his idea on everyone else, because obviously no one else is worthy enough to make a judgment. Why feel the need to force what they call the truth on everyone, if it is in fact the truth? Or more likely they're full of it and just enjoy watching the world burn. The worst part is the selection of judges is based basically on who spends the most clock time googling for people too lazy to use google, it has nothing to do with taste or skill or ability or experience. Random selection would be more effective. A site could be designed that isn't based on an anti-social, exclusionary, classist, authoritarian philosophy. The tragedy is it wouldn't look too much different than SO. So close, and yet so far...
- aaronem 13y agoBuild your leveller's idea of Stack Overflow, then, and let it compete on its merits against the one which already exists. I'll be interested to see the result.
- greenyoda 13y ago"Instead some deletionist authoritarian jerk needs to force his idea on everyone else, because obviously no one else is worthy enough to make a judgment." I think they caught this disease from Wikipedia, where deletionist authoritarian editors kill articles on real people because they're "not notable enough" while allowing thousands of words to be written about minor characters in TV series.
- alfasin 13y agoUsually questions are "closed" by 5 users (not by a moderator) so make it "5 jerks" (and I am one of them BTW...) A question should be closed because it's a dup, or because it's not clear, or there's not enough information and the author didn't bother responding to the comments that mention that etc. If you don't think so - you can write a comment and vote to "repoen". If you feel better by calling us "jerks" - good for you... Happy new year!
- shortstuffsushi 13y agoClosed as not a real question. 150 question upvotes.
- insteadof 13y agoAsking about the colour of the bikeshed always draws more upvotes and views than a question asking why the screws buckle and eject when the outside temperature reaches 30C but only if the interior is 21C. Popularity does not mean a question is within the scope of the site guidelines.
- frostmatthew 13y ago> Popularity does not mean a question is within the scope of the site guidelines. True, but it might indicate adequate reason for modifying the guidelines.
- m_myers 13y agoThere is a time and a place for everything. For opinion-based questions about programming, that place is http://www.slant.co/ http://www.slant.co/ (not affiliated with Stack Exchange).
- vitd 13y agoI just checked this out and it looks horrible. There are no categories. It's just a long list of unrelated questions, like "What's the best app for listening to music?" and "What's the best 2D graphics and physics engine?" It looks completely unusable.
- praveenhm 13y agoThis is one of the most annoying part of stack overflow,instead of closing the discussion,they should have a provision to move to more opinionated discussion list.
- 13y ago
- collyw 13y agoI remember signing up for a news on a site "Not Constructive", here on HN a while back. I really wish it would appear.
- m_myers 13y agohttp://slant.co http://slant.co is pretty much that.