3 ms·
"Does having easy answers available on SO make us dumber?" Yes, in that the worlds largest helper only supports simple boring common questions, as per the arti
by VLM 13y ago
"Does having easy answers available on SO make us dumber?"
Yes, in that the worlds largest helper only supports simple boring common questions, as per the article. If you're trying to do stats in scala, and the only help you can get is "hello world" in java, that's not good for Scala, statistics, or much of anything else, making the world overall dumber.
By analogy, lets say reality TV shows completely push video documentaries off the air. This is not so far fetched. The net result is likely to be dumber.
- aaronem 13y agoBy what mechanism do you imagine Stack Exchange-style sites starving out more detailed and comprehensive treatments of individual subjects? The proposition would seem to require the assumption that all programming can be reduced to cookbook recipes.
- VLM 13y agoTheoretical mechanism would look something like noob who could someday write detailed comprehensive treatments of some Clojure topic tries to get started, sees 99% of his available resources for help are java oriented, eh, better stick with java in case I need help later on, and the possibility of noob growing up to be clojure author of a detailed treatment has disappeared. "The proposition would seem to require the assumption that all programming can be reduced to cookbook recipes." Its one of many effective ways to start learning a language, although not the only way. To distort or screw something up, you don't necessarily have to mess up 100% of the population, just a good chunk of them. You could try to argue that few to no experts ever took their first steps as cookbook script kiddies, but I don't think that would be successful.
- testrun 13y agoThis does not make sense whatsoever. You don't go to SO to get a feel for a language. You go to SO to get quick answers for a problem you are having for a language already chosen.
- aaronem 13y agoSome languages are better supported and have broader ecosystems than others, and for a given language this tends to be self-perpetuating as a result of its effect on the languages which people choose to learn and use. This you blame on Stack Exchange? I concede the model is less than perfect, but really. And you seem to mistake knowing languages for understanding programming. The essence of the skill is the ability to formally specify an algorithm which solves a given problem; the rest, more or less, is libraries and syntax.
- nathan_long 13y ago>> If you're trying to do stats in scala, and the only help you can get is "hello world" in java Are people posting Java "hello world" answers on your Scala questions? I doubt it. Are you manually slogging through dozens of Java questions looking for Scala ones? You should be searching. I see no reason why you should ever have to look at Q&As irrelevant to you. Worst case: you have questions nobody can answer. Which means one of two things: 1. Your question is unclear or too specific to your situation 2. You're working in a niche area. If #2, you're no worse off than if SO didn't exist. So what's the problem?