4 ms·
If this stuff did start to enter the public domain after 28+28 years, the modern entertainment industry would be screwed because they would have to compete with
by pessimizer 13y ago
If this stuff did start to enter the public domain after 28+28 years, the modern entertainment industry would be screwed because they would have to compete with it. Rationally, they'd rather it burned than free.
- justin66 13y agoThere's some interesting stuff on that list but I don't think it'd be competition to anything. I like the idea that the kids would be watching Bridge on the River Kwai instead of the latest recruitment video but it doesn't seem likely. Of course, the studios would lose the long-tail revenue from controlling movies like Bridge on the River Kwai (or licensing the movie rights to things like the old version of 3:10 to Yuma) and that does add up.
- toyg 13y agoAt this point, it's mostly about preservation. Kwai is one of a zillion war movies produced more than 40 years ago; unlike the bridge, that movie will forever endure, but so many of its contemporaries will disappear -- a fate entirely avoidable in this age of long-tail hyper-specialized scholarly studies, unlimited data capacity and worldwide p2p redundancy. Art will be lost because of unbridled greed, and this is the real tragedy.
- pessimizer 13y agoIt's a weird feeling when you know that some of the torrents you are seeding may make you the only source of distribution of that work in the world at that moment. Gives you a sense of responsibility if it's good.
- judk 13y agoDo we need the zillions of other movies? At some point, we need to curate to not be overwhelmed
- warfangle 13y agoHow can one curate that which is lost?
- pessimizer 13y agoThe kids aren't the purchasers of the majority of entertainment products. If the kids had a choice between free River Kwai, and $12 modern version of 3:10 to Yuma (or something funner), the $12 would become $2 in no time.
- justin66 13y agoWhat? edit: so you were just restating what you already said. It wasn't persuasive the first time.
- pessimizer 13y ago>I like the idea that the kids would be watching Bridge on the River Kwai instead of the latest recruitment video but it doesn't seem likely. The kids aren't the purchasers of the majority of entertainment products. If the kids had a choice between free River Kwai, and a $12 modern version of 3:10 to Yuma (or something funner), the $12 would become $2 in no time. Prices on new product would have to be lowered to compete with free old product.
- scarecrowbob 13y ago"Prices on new product would have to be lowered to compete with free old product." I do not believe that this is true at all. Having taught film history classes at a university, where some of the most interesting, significant human artworks were rejected because they were silent, had subtitles, or simply were not in color, I can say with no hesitation that there is little or no demand for things that aren't colorful, animated explosions featuring contemporary stars. That's not a value judgement: people can watch whatever; that's just the current market as I understand it.
- chrismcb 13y agoRight, because movie ticket prices and dvd prices are going down in the face of free tv and cheap online streaming. Yes today's content has to compete with yesterday's content. But they do already. A new Robocop is coming out. I'm sure it will do just fine, even though you can find the original for cheap or free.
- thirdtruck 13y agoAnd in the case of some old films, and despite offers to store it for them, many studios have literally burned their material.
- res0nat0r 13y agoBurned? Blah. The Cat in the Hat, Atlas Shrugged and probably others from that list are still popular. The books are still being printed and sold, not being hidden away from society.
- pessimizer 13y agoI didn't say that anything had been burned. I said that rather than have it go into the public domain, publishers would rather it be burned, because it competes with their catalog.
- judk 13y agoIf they weren't still copyrighted, new media sellers would want them destroyed