3 ms·
"How common is "common"? This is the first I'm hearing of it, and I'd like more than the author's word." They're scientifically proven to be medically ineffect
by VLM 13y ago
"How common is "common"? This is the first I'm hearing of it, and I'd like more than the author's word."
They're scientifically proven to be medically ineffective although for people with psychological non medical issues they are scientifically proven to reduce anxiety. Daughter's got a cough. Moms freaking out. Doc verifies its not bacterial so there's nothing to do but chill out, these viruses take care of themselves, rest and hydrate. Moms freaking out. You treat MOM not the daughter with a harmless magic potion. Mom is now calm, that makes daughter calm and unstressed, and thats medically proven to help or at least not harm someone who needs hydration and rest, and issuing poorly distilled water is medically proven to be much safer for everyone involved than giving antibiotics for a viral infection.
I'm a pretty strong supporter of homeopathic treatment of viral illnesses, at least in comparison to the US (edited: informal) standard of antibiotic treatment. Its enormously safer than antibiotics and its just as effective WRT virus infections. Just make sure its really viral in nature not just a poorly tested culture test in the lab.
(edited to explain I'm not talking theory here; my daughter's pediatrician has recently switched from antibiotic treatment of minor viral infections like coughs and colds to homeopathic treatment... when I found out from my wife what my daughter was prescribed, I was momentarily furious, come on lady I'm a hard science guy don't BS me with homeopathic stuff like that, but I thought about it for about five minutes and decided to high-five her next time I see her, it really is genius in that people too dumb to understand antibiotics have no effect on viruses are too dumb to know homeopathic stuff doesn't work, so the net result is positive)
I've been trying to figure out how to convince idiot industrial farmers that homeopathic water might be a better idea than pumping the livestock full of antibiotics. The problem is in filthy industrial farming operations, the livestock all die without antibiotics because ... drumroll ... filthy industrial farms are filthy.
- saosebastiao 13y agoThanks for the insight. I've never thought of the possibility of treating the stressed-out parent with homeopathy. It seems brilliant! My only problem is how does the doctor know that will calm the nerves? If my doctor prescribed my kid homeopathic medicine, I would never go to him again. Placebo only works when the people don't know they are being duped.
- dllthomas 13y ago"Placebo only works when the people don't know they are being duped." It's my understanding that this is (surprisingly!) not the case.