6 ms·
Pollution Rising, Chinese Fear for Soil and Food
- InclinedPlane 13y agoI find it sort of ironic, in a deeply tragic way, that a totalitarian state such as China finds itself incapable of enacting the sort of sweeping environmental regulations which were the linchpin for bringing about vastly cleaner air, water, and soil in the liberal democracies during the mid-20th century. Indeed, it wasn't so very long ago when a great many pundits were crushing on the ruthless efficacy of China's absolutist government. China is more than advanced enough and more than wealthy enough to solve these problems. But perhaps the government is too corrupt and too disconnected from the value of human life to do what needs to be done.
- wavefunction 13y agoI agree. I am always sickened by the US politicians pointing to Chinese "regulations" (or lack-thereof) on labor or the environment as competitive advantages to be emulated. Then I remind myself these are the same sorts of people that have never left the borders of the US and don't understand exactly how wonderfully _clean_ the US is in comparison to those sorts of places. I hope for the sake of the Chinese people and the rest of the world that they figure it out. We are starting to have similar problems with "unresponsive" governments in the West and it will unfortunately be to everyone's peril eventually.
- dnautics 13y agothe story isn't quite as monolithic as that though, in the 19th century America, lawsuits came about as people claimed that pollution from factories caused personal damage and the state courts repeatedly ruled that industrial progress (and the resulting economic growth) were protected interests and put the kaibosh on them - e.g. Lexington & Ohio Rail Road v. Applegate. So having a 'responsive' government can be a problem, depending on exactly whom the government is 'responding' to.
- wavefunction 13y agoWell certainly, and littering in America was supposedly endemic before the anti-littering campaigns of the 1960s with stiff penalties were instituted. That is my frustration - that short-sighted individuals don't realize how hard fought and won many of the things they take for granted are.
- ams6110 13y agoPrivate property ownership is essential for anybody to care about environmental issues. If the government owns all the property, citizens don't have any economic or personal ownership stake in protecting it from pollution.
- yequalsx 13y agoThat is quite a bold claim there. Do have any evidence that it is true? Are there studies you can cite or data that you can refer too? Your claim is that absent an economic or a personal ownership stake then one can not have an interest in protecting the land from pollution. This is a false statement for me personally so on strict logical grounds the claim is false but perhaps I'm an outlier.
- wehadfun 13y agoYou want a study that says that someone cares about things they own? If the farmers actually owned the land they hopefully would have complained about near by factories, or stopped paying taxes on the land by now.
- Retric 13y agoNobody owns the air but we all like to avoid lung disease and death.
- jshen 13y agoMany of the Superfund sites in the US were owned by the mining companies that left the extreme levels of pollution. The evidence is clear that ownership doesn't dissuade a company from polluting its own land when it can make a ton of money in the process.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoIts actually quite accurate: https://www.google.com/search?q=economics+private+vs+public+goods https://www.google.com/search?q=economics+private+vs+public+... Free rider problems, tradgedy of the commons, etc. The best examples are conservation with regards to fisheries and sought-after endangered specifies. You have to give people an economic incentive, which usually includes some sort of privitazaion of the resource (for fisheries, tradable quotas). I actually just read an entire chapter about this concept last night: http://books.google.com/books?id=lbOkUCVNSPoC&pg=PA31&lpg=PA31&dq=naked+economics+free+rider+problem&source=bl&ots=6Ot3KpsLR9&sig=gopN8MG_DsIX91gDBxu56TMySk0&hl=en&sa=X&ei=FTTDUrv2B-mkyQHNg4DICw&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=naked%20economics%20free%20rider%20problem&f=false http://books.google.com/books?id=lbOkUCVNSPoC&pg=PA31&lpg=PA...
- jinushaun 13y agoTalking with Americans that have lived in China, it sounds like the problem isn't the govt, but culture. Like the anti-spitting campaign during the Olympics, the Chinese govt need similar strong tactics to get its citizens to care about the environment. I don't know how successful the anti-spitting campaign worked out, but the West's current love affair with the environment didn't happen over night either.
- pavlov 13y agoThe West has a love affair with the environment? Maybe about 2-4% do, half of them living in cities and the other half in the countryside (very different lifestyles but similar goals of a minimum environmental impact). Another 5-10% care enough about the environment to make daily conscious choices for it, but most of those choices amount to lip service or marketing-driven "greenwashing". Most of these people live in cities. The rest just don't care, and will continue driving their cars and eating >300g of meat per day until they die or become incapable of deciding for themselves.
- jedrek 13y agoI think you underestimate the massive changes in attitude that have come about due to the environmental movement. The very fact that your examples are eating meat and driving, and not dumping waste into parks, throwing trash on the ground, pouring used oil into streams, using lead paint, burning leaves and grass, etc is a testament to the changes that have occurred. All the behaviors I listed were commonplace in the 1950s, now they unthinkable and strongly disapproved of.
- WalterBright 13y agoMy father told me that highways used to be lined with trash thrown out of car windows.
- nicholas73 13y agoThe environmentalists got me when I was young. The awareness never left even if it only amounts to taking out the recycling. Some of my favorite places as a child are still my favorite today - the CA Academy of Sciences and the Monterey Bay Aquarium. Those two institutions alone probably have changed Bay Area perceptions of the environment. China should set up institutions like that, both for research and public awareness. There is so much biodiversity in China that we rarely hear about [0] [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_giant_salamander http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_giant_salamander
- dharmach 13y agoHow China's pollution problem defers from that of US's or UK's, say 100 years back?
- InclinedPlane 13y agoPopulation, population density, automobiles, and lingering effects of recent poverty. London's metro population peaked around 9 million right around 1940, although it's back up to similar numbers. The population of manhattan peaked around 2.3 million in the 1920s. The population of Beijing, Guangzhou, or Shanghai are all about 20 million plus. There were fewer automobiles in London even in the mid 20th century than there are in the big Chinese cities today (there are over 5 million cars in Beijing alone). Many of those automobiles are either diesel powered trucks, buses, and cars or 2-stroke scooters and motorcycles, all of them highly polluting. Add to that the heavy reliance on coal for home heating and cooking and you have the pollution nightmare that is now quite evident. The population of the entirety of the UK was only 50 million in 1950, and the population of the US in 1950 was only 150 million. Today in China nearly 50 million people live in Guangzhao alone, and over 100 million people live in the top 4 largest municipalities, within an area that is in total similar in size to Los Angeles county. And the pollution contribution from the population of more than a billion who often live near the major cities is also not inconsequential.
- DanAndersen 13y agoThere's probably little difference, but I'm not sure if that's a legitimate excuse. Is a heavily polluting industrial phase necessary for countries to become developed? I'm not sure if that's true or not; maybe it is and it's acceptable for developing countries to make the same environmental missteps as developed nations had in order to progress to the same levels of development. I would hope, though, that with technological advances there would be a greater ability to be industrial while mitigating some of the environmental issues that plagued the US and the UK during their industrial revolutions. I don't know if this is a valid analogy, but I sometimes think about what this argument would sound like if it was about something like slavery instead of environmental damage. There was much infrastructure and industry in parts of the US built on the backs of slaves, but I think that if there were modern-day countries with substantial slave industries, we wouldn't find it defensible to say that the US also had slaves too in the past and that developing countries should have a chance to do so as well as a temporary part of their development. Maybe pollution is a necessary evil for any society, and maybe it's not as bad as slavery. It just seems like placing each society on separate 'tracks' of development for them to go through the same troubles and dangers without criticism both demeans developing societies as "oh, they're just 100 years behind us" and also ignores the sort of "horizontal gene transfer" of technology and social/philosophical/political concepts that can accelerate developing countries' development.
- snake_plissken 13y agoChina's heavy metal pollution is staggering. The tap water in many areas tastes like heavy metals, or how you might imagine heavy metals tasting. Stick some aluminium in your mouth. Then put a 9-volt battery, with some zinc, in there and gurgle it all with Listerine. It's difficult to describe unless you've tasted it. And if there is a country that could tackle an issue as immense and demanding as this, it's China.