4 ms·
So here is a complete anecdotal suspicion: I have had the iPhone since the first day of release. I have gone through 16 physical devices over that period (due
by samstave 13y ago
So here is a complete anecdotal suspicion:
I have had the iPhone since the first day of release. I have gone through 16 physical devices over that period (due to me breaking them a lot and going through several employers where I had never purchased my own phone since (well before) it was released). I am currently, for the first time in a long time, on my own personal device; an iPhone 4.
I upgraded it to iOS7 when it was available. The device is a slow POS and I want to stab my eyes out when I use it....
However; there is a behavior that I have only personally noticed recently: (Please tell me if you see the same thing)
Whenever I transition between literally ANY screen, I see a quick BLINK of the screen - in the same anim that you would see when you take a screenshot.
So I am wondering "Is my phone taking a screen cap of EVERY switch/transition I make? WHY"
Now, I know that iOS does do screen caps of things so that when you are switching in various ways that it already has a cache of the last state of that screen in order to thumbnail the previous view... BUT I understood this to be limited to certain circumstances. Currently I am noticing it on pretty much ANY transition.
Even if this is the actual, "Normal", my suspicion is that this fact can be used to entirely rebuild an entire session of activity for a user through their entire interactions. Even if you just grab these screens which are used at a system level - a great deal could be inferred from just these workflow screen caps.
- sneak 13y agoI think they're on to you. Quick, hide the evidence.
- jbergstroem 13y agoComplete bogus - but lets play: If you were the NSA; why would you even hint to the user that you were taking screenshots? Its not like the blink animation is tucked away from software control.
- samstave 13y agoThat wasnt my point: irrespective of any "nefarious interest" in said screen shots; IS the iOS device actually capturing every single screen change via a screenshot? As I understood it - there were certain apps that were captured in the past. This was so that when the app loaded it had the previous state shown as quickly as possible, and it would then refresh. My point was I am noticing this flashing screen cap anim on literally EVERY screen change... this does not make sense to me and I am wondering why the device does this. Finally, I surmise that if it actually IS doing these caps, that if one COULD get access to them one could then build a pretty clear session history. Again, I said it was a simple suspicion. I have no idea if this is actually happening; but the device seems to be revealing the caps happening... but I am not so sure.
- ewoodrich 13y agoThe screenshots that are used for transition animations do not make the dimming "screenshot" effect that occurs when pressing the Menu and Power button. That invisibly occurs immediately prior to an animation, to produce a less computationally intensive 2D effect. The iPhone 4 runs iOS 7 terribly and more likely you are seeing some graphics stuttering from the (albeit limited on that device) new iOS 7 fade/transition animations.
- coolnow 13y agoIf you were the NSA, would you be taking screenshots just as the target was /switching/ apps, instead of taking them while they're using it? Oh, he's opened Mail, take a screenshot of Mail's splash screen while it's loading, now don't do anything. Oh, he's done using the app, quick, take a screenshot of his empty inbox before the app switches to Candy Crush. Not to mention that the screen flash while a screenshot is being taken is a usability feature and is there to help us know when a screenshot has been successfully taken. I know there are tweaks on Cydia that allow screen recordings, so why are the NSA messing about taking screenshots of some unimportant (no offense, i mean it in a national security sense) guy? tl;dr your iPhone 4 is struggling with iOS 7 and probably has some redraw problems, most likely no one is taking screenshots of you while you're switching apps.
- samstave 13y agoI am not talking about the "NSA taking screen shots" -- I am talking about the iOS taking screenshots... this is just a "nice feature" that any phone tapper/hacker (like the NSA) could exploit. My question is: Does the iOS device, in fact, take a screenshot of every single transition? everyone seems to miss my question, thus I must be posing it poorly. What I said again, simply, was that: I knew that some transitions had a screen capped to allow for a faster, subjective, transition to the user... a UX cheat. However, I noticed that my iOS7 device APPEARS to be doing this on EVERY transition... Is it really capping, or, as you smartly suggest; the iPhone 4 is a POS that struggles in the anims for each transition. Finally, I was just surmising that should the device, indeed, take a screen for every transition; this could be a sweet exploit in rebuilding session actions for any user of the device.
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoYes. The screenshot is old/known, and it does that in order to make the transitions appear smooth. It's also been cited as a privacy risk before, for the reasons you mention. http://www.networkworld.com/community/node/32645 http://www.networkworld.com/community/node/32645
- alan_cx 13y agoDunno if you are right or wrong. Its just sad that people now think like this. That little device of joy, which has now become almost essential, is now a source of stress, worry, and suspicion.