5 ms·
But isn't it entirely possible that he's right?
by wvenable 13y ago
But isn't it entirely possible that he's right?
- halostatue 13y agoPG can be correct that “hacker-founders” (what YC looks for, AIUI) who are female may not exist in sufficient numbers to be visible to the YC process—and still be in the wrong because there is a strong gender bias against the production of female hacker-founders in our society. The question—as I read the articles surrounding this—was about the larger problem (of the continuing ultra-dominance of the tech industry by men) and what YC might be doing to improve the situation. (And the answer is…nothing?) The bias here is the same thing that keeps female participation in OSS horribly low: the “meritocracy” involved is inherently biased toward young males because of the way that our society works as a whole. YC can't fix this, but there may be things that can and should be done to improve how it handles that existing bias.
- wvenable 13y agoIsn't that lack of female hacker-founders exactly what pg was saying? I don't understand how pg could personally be in the wrong about that. And this is exactly my point, pg is now vilified for what? Not doing enough? It's ridiculous.
- halostatue 13y agoI think that what you're missing is that while the fact that there's a lack of female hacker-founders is true…only looking for hacker-founders further solidifies a blatantly sexist problem in the tech industry. So his statement is right—but the attitude is wrong and it is pure blame-shifting. Facts like this can be correct in the small, but wrong (not incorrect, but…ill-intentioned) in the large. The issue is about the larger problem, not the smaller problem. pg has been defending the smaller problem (the facts of the analysis) while ignoring the larger problem. At least in the articles I read this evening (I was on vacation last week when this apparently broken). It's a systemic/societal problem, and YC certainly can't fix it on its own, and has limited ability to fix it in any case. They started doing something different with Watsi…maybe there's something they can do different for female founders (as pg himself has suggested that there's another essay coming, plus some announcements from YC in that direction in any case).
- wvenable 13y agoLooking for hacker-founders is what YC does. That is its reason for existence. It's not an employer. It's not a general investment firm. It's not a school. It invests in hacker-founders. PG expertise is hacker-founders. Only looking for hacker-founders isn't sexist, in of itself. If there is a larger problem in society, that's not really PG's domain of expertise and we shouldn't expect it to be.
- halostatue 13y agoI think you're missing the point that I'm making that only looking for hacker-founders (and landing mostly with young men) is sexist in and of itself because it both perpetuates existing stereotypes and reinforces sexist roles. Note that I'm not saying that YC should change its selection criteria—I understand what they're looking for and why. But they don't get to wash their hands of this societal/systemic problem and say that it's Just That Way. Change has to be proactive. YC is in a position to help make a difference. It has disproportionately large mindshare in the tech industry. Maybe it's next non-profit needs to be something to address the gender imbalance in tech.
- wvenable 13y agoYou are just saying that women can't be hacker-founders but you don't think YC needs to change it's selection criteria. What you really want is for YC to be more charitable to support women. That's fine. But at least be clear what you are talking about. Personally, I don't know exactly what PG is doing to support women in technology right now. But from what I gather it's not nothing. He's probably doing more than any of us. Maybe you should get off your high horse and stop telling other people what they should be doing to solve the problem.
- halostatue 13y ago> Maybe you should get off your high horse and stop telling other people what they should be doing to solve the problem. If that’s what you think I’m doing, then I have either failed to make myself clear or you have failed to comprehend what I’ve said. I’ll be charitable and assume the former. 1. There is no legal obligation for YC to change its selection criteria. 2. I am not looking to have YC change its selection criteria. 3. As long as YC has selection criteria that are inherently biased (as the YC selection criteria are[a]), the only thing that I’m saying is that they can’t pretend that the criteria aren't biased against women (and certain visible minorities). I’m not on a high horse and telling YC to change things. I don’t expect them to be more “forgiving” of female founders not meeting their extant criteria. But it’s socially irresponsible to say that “I can't do anything about it, because the problem happened ten years ago.” I’m pointing out that while this is a thorny problem not of YC’s creation, there is an opportunity and perhaps a social responsibility that they have to encourage the people they fund to help fix this problem for the young women coming up five or ten years from now. [a] As stated before: the bias behind the YC selection criteria is a fact, and it's admitted by PG himself in his response to this debacle. Selection criteria that expects someone to have ~10 years “hacking” experience prior to choosing YC is biased heavily in favour of people who already have accumulated advantages that permit them that exploration time (and are encouraged to do so in that particular direction) and against people who do not. This means that women are underrepresented because technical/engineering disciplines are not seen as “acceptable” for girls to do; certain visible minorities are underrepresented because, at least in America, race is strongly correlated to income and corresponding free time. These are facts.
- theorique 13y agoSo what could he / YC do? And what can they do right now? The main thing that comes to mind is to do some marketing outreach to diverse pools of potential techie founders (Ada Initiative, PyLadies, etc). Beyond activities like this, can pg or YC be held responsible for the preceding stages of the pipeline?
- ceol 13y agoNot really, no. Everyone is biased. The point isn't to eliminate them but to acknowledge them and understand how they affect you. Sexism in tech is a very large problem, and like every other large problem, it's made up of many small problems. I think it's silly for pg to claim that there's nothing YC can do to get more women founders. No one's asking him to fix the whole thing — only to explore some ways that he could do his part to fix his small problem and get some more women founders through YC.
- wvenable 13y agoI think it's silly that you think pg is claiming there is absolutely nothing he can do. The problem is now that many many people are now reading as much as possible into everything that he saying. If he has an opinion, you don't know exactly what it is. But you'll analyze every word, every phrasing, and make up your own assumptions. That is all that is happening here.
- ceol 13y agoThe full transcript is at the bottom of the submitted article's page, and from the conversation, it's pretty clear that pg thinks there isn't anything he can do. When asked what YC could do to bring more women founders in, he says they don't exist and then says we need to start looking at middle school computer science curriculums. Those are two things he flat-out said; I'm not reading anything into it.
- wvenable 13y agoI would say it's pretty clear that PG thinks there isn't any more he can do. Lets not assume that he's doing absolutely nothing now. I'll ask again: isn't it possible that he's right? There seems to be general consensus that girls do not get into computing science at a young age. So it makes sense there would be shortage of women with right ability at the right time for YC. There's nothing controversial about that. And short of inventing a time machine there isn't anything PG can do about that. I know a lot of women in computing and almost none of them started as young as my male peers. These women code and some started their own companies. But they didn't do it in their late teens or early 20's because they hadn't even discovered it then.