2 ms·
Would it be fair to conclude that any setup that requires ID is a suppression scheme? I.e., if ID is required for travel - is it a travel rights suppression sch
by smsm42 13y ago
Would it be fair to conclude that any setup that requires ID is a suppression scheme? I.e., if ID is required for travel - is it a travel rights suppression scheme? If the ID is required for real estate ownership - that is a real estate ownership suppression scheme? If the ID is required to own a firearm - is it a firearm ownership suppression scheme?
Note I'm not asking if IDs were used in the past to suppress votes - I'm sure there were cases where that happened. What you're claiming is that ID requirement and voter suppression is the same, which is much stronger claim. So what I am asking is this ID requirement that makes it suppression or how one can distinguish suppression ones from non-suppression ones?
- nknighthb 13y agoThe set of people who do not have and/or will have trouble getting IDs has little if any overlap with the set of people who travel by air, purchase real estate, or lawfully purchase firearms.
- smsm42 13y agoI wasn't asking about which sets of people overlap or not. I was asking what makes ID requirement be identical with suppression - is it ID requirement itself or something else? If it is something else - what exactly it is? Is it where set of people is relevant - it is OK to ask some people to show the papers but not the others? Which people should be exempt and which should not be?
- MichaelSalib 13y agoWe know that voter id requirements are based in voter suppression because those requirements are targeted to preventing an attack that is economically infeasible and they don't even effectively mitigate the attack. Look at my other comments in this thread for the details, but in brief, the cost of using voter impersonation fraud is extremely high, the probability that authorities will detect it is also high, and the penalties for breaking the law in this way are very serious. What's more, bypassing the ID requirement is trivial for criminals, in the same way that bored teenagers can purchase alcohol whenever they want because forging ID cards is easy. Note also that IDs are actually not required for flying in the US. Flying without an ID is annoying and time consuming, but definitely doable (I've done it).
- smsm42 13y agoMost voter ID proposal I've read also make voting without ID annoying and time consuming, but doable. This is taken as a clear evidence the goal is voter suppression. Thus I am asking, why the same thing with flying is not considered movement rights suppression? I don't see how without ID checks cost and detection probability of voter fraud is high. You just get a list of guys who are dead or in jail or otherwise aren't going to show up (shouldn't be that hard to do), and pay somebody some small sum to show up at the polling place and vote as the name on the list. Where's the high cost in that?
- smsm42 13y agoHere's an experiment: http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/367278/report-new-york-investigators-obtain-fraudulent-ballots-97-percent-time-john-fund http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/367278/report-new-york-... I.e. there are zero controls for the ballots, at least in New York. What data your assertion that this is impossible bases on, again?
- djur 13y agoWhat I am claiming is that the current batch of voter ID schemes are part of an organized vote suppression effort by the American right wing under the pretense of preventing fraud. I would be willing to believe that the programs were being adopted in good faith if there was any evidence of widespread voter fraud and if the programs included aggressive efforts to ensure that every eligible voter has access to a free ID.
- smsm42 13y agoThere's no evidence of widespread terror campaign in US airport and yet TSA grabs my balls each time I fly, and NSA collects my phone calls. There's no evidence of widespread harm from drugs like marijuana and yet thousands of people are jailed for mere possession of it. There's no evidence of gun bans be effective measure of crime control and yet cities like Chicago and Washington insist on it. There's no evidence RIAA and MPAA are seriously hurt by piracy and yet we have DMCA and almost had SOPA. There's no evidence copyright extensions are necessary and yet we have Mickey Mouse protection act[1]. There's no evidence of US being a criminal wasteland and yet you may very well commit three felonies every day[2]. If you really want to go into "show me the data before you make the law", you're waking up way too late. It's not a conspiracy, it's called "federal government". [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonny_Bono_Copyright_Term_Extension_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sonny_Bono_Copyright_Term_Exte... [2] http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052748704471504574438900830760842 http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405274870447150...
- dragonwriter 13y ago> There's no evidence of widespread terror campaign in US airport and yet TSA grabs my balls each time I fly, and NSA collects my phone calls. [...] > If you really want to go into "show me the data before you make the law", you're waking up way too late. Campaigns for voter ID laws -- and the opposition to them -- are older than the NSA warrantless surveillance programs or the TSA. Not to mention that the opponents of all three of those things have substantial overlap, so saying that people who oppose one of them have categorically "woken up to late" because the other ones exist (no matter which one you pick) doesn't make a lot of sense, since its not unlikely that the people you are criticizing as late to wake up are also already opponents of whichever the "earlier" outrage is that you are pointing to to make that claim.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Would it be fair to conclude that any setup that requires ID is a suppression scheme? It would be fair to conclude that any proposal which increases the burden of doing a thing is intended to prevent and/or discourage some group of people from doing that thing. If there is no strong evidence that there some significant problem with people who are wrongfully be doing that thing that the particular scheme is well-designed to solve, it is pretty fair to suspect that the intent is to prevent/discourage people who are rightfully doing it, and, whether or not this is the intent, and whether or not there is a real problem in evidence that it might solve, it is reasonable to question whether any effect, even incidental, of preventing/discouraging people who are not wrongfully engaging in the targetted act is a substantial enough negative side effect to reject the proposal. > What you're claiming is that ID requirement and voter suppression is the same I think there is more than sufficient evidence to conclude that the actual concrete voter ID proposals that are actually being made are either intended as or draw a significant portion of their support from people who view them as voter suppression schemes, and that, intent aside, their primary effect would be as mechanisms for voter suppression.